HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

seanmcdirmid

38,819 karma · joined January 10, 2012

submissionscomments
seanmcdirmid··on Amazon refused to give pregnant workers bathroom breaks
I'm going to say its bad, but especially bad for low paid blue collar workers. When I worked at McDonalds as a kid, a lot of crew would get pregnant and work until 8 months, and be gone for a couple of months, I don't know how they did it, and I don't know why it had to be like that.

Richer white collar workers have it better (much much much better), still not great. Our nation is just failing at this, I don't see Amazon being especially bad beyond the typical bad (which is already too bad). Best case is they just outsource their problem to the lowest bidder and the same or worse behavior happens.

seanmcdirmid··on The Nonfiction Book Market is Collapsing?
Nothing has really changed: bad writers using AI will still be bad writers. Good writers using AI, with some effort put into learning how to use it, can benefit a lot from it in terms of (at least) writing good content faster.
seanmcdirmid··on The Nonfiction Book Market is Collapsing?
If done right you couldn’t tell either way, and you probably wouldn’t care. The point of writing is to get a message out to the reader as efficiently as possible, don’t waste their time. The writer ensures that, AI is just a tool at that point. The problem with vibe writing with AI is that AI has no sense about wasting the reader’s time.

We should just be judging writing by its quality. There were always bad writers who wrote like LLMs or worse. It takes a lot of practice to write well.

seanmcdirmid··on The Nonfiction Book Market is Collapsing?
There is a lot of curation and editing that go into AI generated content. Like if you just use an AI to write from a prompt, you’ll just get slop (vibe writing), but if you plan it, review the bullet points, delete and add points that make the narrative stronger, have it sketch some writing out after you are happy with what it is covering, then rewrite that because LLMs have absolutely no sense for word rhythm.
seanmcdirmid··on The universal programming language of LLMs
A parallel question: do you think Python being so entrenched in LLMs model weights means that future new programming languages are just going to resemble Python? Corpus means models that write that language means more corpus of that language.

OH, but LLMs are even better at natural language than they are with Python (which is why you have to often go from PL code to NL to get it to do something well, then go back to PL from the updated NL). So any kind of new language they develop will definitely be some kind of natural language where they derive semantic meaning from it to quickly use some deterministic PL to do something.

seanmcdirmid··on I refused to train the AI that could replace me
I hope you are right, but it definitely feels like everything is turning against workers. They might have jobs, but prices are such that they are still getting by or not at all.
seanmcdirmid··on I refused to train the AI that could replace me
We are seeing workers get laid off to free up more money for AI and only the AI techies are making more money? It could be temporary, but the way AI is currently owned and structured, the owners and investors are positioned to reap almost all of the financial benefits whereas workers will just be expected to do more with AI for the same pay and hours worked.
seanmcdirmid··on I refused to train the AI that could replace me
Why do humans need to work to exist?

We just need a new model for existing that isn’t based on labor. We should have started working on these problems in 2016 when it was obvious they were coming, but we elected a regressive twice to help us go backwards instead.

seanmcdirmid··on I refused to train the AI that could replace me
Increased productivity is nothing to sneeze at even if you work the same amount of hours. The real problem with AI is that the productivity benefits are focused with the owners and not the workers.
seanmcdirmid··on Asahi Linux on M3
The FCC? I guess you mean their wifi chips or cellular modems or something? I can’t see the FCC having jurisdiction over anything else that Apple does. Maybe you meant the FTC?
seanmcdirmid··on Mamdani bans AI in NYC schools
If Chinese kids are taught how to use AI from an early age, while American kids have to wait until they are in university, which ones are going to be make economically competitive when they become adults?

I think we already know the answer to this question, I’m not sure what America plans to do about it, or maybe just fade away into irrelevance?

seanmcdirmid··on US diesel prices hit a record high of $5.85 on average
> We use appropriation and tax dollars to expand the road network, but the railroads generally don't have access to either.

The federal government leases tracks using Amtrack money (among other public agencies). They get low interest rate loans as well. Definitely nothing near Chinese level of subsidies.

seanmcdirmid··on The largest electric aircraft just flew [video]
Ground effect planes are already pretty limited to calm water situations. Like between Seattle and Victoria, or maybe Seattle and Vancouver. I would say the Alaskan marine highway would be a good fit, but that is mostly for freight and cars.
seanmcdirmid··on The largest electric aircraft just flew [video]
I remember reading about making ground effects electric planes for this reason. You need a reserve, but if your plane could double as a boat and was flying over water, that would satisfy the requirement.
seanmcdirmid··on US diesel prices hit a record high of $5.85 on average
It has a good rail freight system but it’s running at capacity. Trucks are still needed for connections.
seanmcdirmid··on Gemini 3.8 Flash and 3.8 Flash Cyber
Ultra AI is like $99/month, and it is hard to exhaust unless you are running a lot of concurrent requests.
seanmcdirmid··on Lake Ontario ("Lake America")
The swiss system mostly works because the people are disciplined, believe in lots of self responsibility, they actually have militias with mandatory participation (like America's 2nd amendment, but the first clause isn't flavor text), you have to join the volunteer fire brigade, etc... Immigrants who want to become swiss citizens...they do a spot check of your home cleanliness to make sure you are "swiss enough".
seanmcdirmid··on Dyson CameraJet electric toothbrush
I loved my Dyson but switched to Chinese robovacs because, even if stick vacs made cleaning the floor easy, I still sucked at consistency. Now I have three robot vacuums because my townhome is three floors.
seanmcdirmid··on US may ask parents to prove citizenship to get passports for their children
Dreamers aren’t (by birth) citizens because they aren’t born here, they just came here at very young ages.
seanmcdirmid··on True Rate of Unemployment
Poor people pay payroll taxes, which usually is flat and doesn’t have a big deduction. At $50k, a single person is paying just as much if not slightly more in payroll as they are in income tax.
seanmcdirmid··on Lake Ontario ("Lake America")
Moderate, business-oriented Democrats and Republicans would all agree with you, BUT these are a group of people that both sides of the party are railing against so they have basically no influence at this point. Even Obama, people selectively remember him fondly (or not) for his compassion and mild socialism, not for his strong free trade stance.
seanmcdirmid··on Lake Ontario ("Lake America")
They did vote to ban minarets, which was odd. Also, the Swiss are fairly conservative in the classical personal responsibility sense, which makes for good citizen voters. They do this through an aggressive policy of education and assimilation that emphasizes “Swissness.” Dropping Swiss style into other countries might not work out as well.
seanmcdirmid··on Lake Ontario ("Lake America")
Tariffs are very populist and both sides have some amount of support for them, so I don’t see them going away. If anything, the democrats are less libertarian than the republicans (historically, before Trump), so I just don’t see them liberalizing tariffs so much as going back to a more sane Obama-style normal.

The socialist wing of the Democratic Party is even less libertarian than the moderates, and it’s hard to call them controlled.

seanmcdirmid··on Lake Ontario ("Lake America")
It’s called dummy-mandering, when you try to create more districts that are less safe with tighter margins, but you get the math wrong or sentiment changes by the time the election comes.
seanmcdirmid··on Google Antigravity introduces Boost deep reasoning (/boost)
Are 3.5, 3.6 any better? It is pretty flaky, Deepseek v4 flash is more reliable than 3.7 flash at least.
seanmcdirmid··on SK Hynix CEO sees memory chip shortage lasting until 2030
DDR-5 is still expensive, at least until China can get more production online.
seanmcdirmid··on Apple caught off guard by AI demand for Mac Mini and Mac Studio
Uncensored models are also popular reasons, although it’s more of a niche.
seanmcdirmid··on Google: Lake Ontario/Lake America name change in the U.S. will appear in Maps
Alaskans actually prefer Denali, even the republicans didn’t want the name changed back again. The state of Alaska itself officially adopted Denali as the official name in 1975, long before Obama made the political statement you are hallucinating. This is just Trump making a statement pretending that Obama was being woke rather than requesting something the Alaskans requested on their own.
seanmcdirmid··on Why OOP Exists
The article feels a bit late since we have come full circle: OOP attempted to force natural language ontologies into deterministic code, while LLMs can now process natural language ontologies directly. Prose has become the source code humans write (or at least read), and model weights are the new compiler that extract objects (or functions) and relationships directly from a written specification to generate Python. OOP hasn't disappeared; it has finally been supplanted by the natural language it always tried to mimic.
seanmcdirmid··on Norway Shrugged (2024)
I'd much rather there be a pre-tax on loans rather than a wealth tax to prevent premature liquidation. The former makes sense: if you borrow money, you should pre-pay the tax you would pay once you pay off the loan, or at least some fixed minimum percent that can raised or lower at the time the loan is paid off. And get rid of the stupid step up in basis on death.

A wealth tax on unrealized assets is going to create huge distortions in the economy, there are other ways we can fix this.

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →