HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

samuel

744 karma · joined May 8, 2008

submissionscomments
samuel··on What's Inside the EU Green Pass QR Code?
That's interesting, but I guess it needs some legal support at the Austrian level, because the regulation doesn't prescribe those uses for the certificate.
samuel··on What's Inside the EU Green Pass QR Code?
As far I have been told by the national authorities of my country, that's the case. I haven't read the whole regulation but this paragraph I think it addresses it:

This Regulation establishes the legal ground for the processing of personal data within the meaning of point (c) of Article 6(1) and point (g) of Article 9(2) of Regulation (EU) 2016/679, necessary for the issuance and verification of the interoperable certificates provided for in this Regulation. It does not regulate the processing of personal data related to the documentation of a vaccination, a test or a recovery event for other purposes, such as for the purposes of pharmacovigilance or for the maintenance of individual personal health records

Member States may process personal data for other purposes, if the legal basis for the processing of such data for other purposes, including the related retention periods, is provided for in national law, which must comply with Union data protection law and the principles of effectiveness, necessity and proportionality, and should contain provisions clearly identifying the scope and extent of the processing, the specific purpose involved, the categories of entity that can verify the certificate as well as the relevant safeguards to prevent discrimination and abuse, taking into account the risks to the rights and freedoms of data subjects

So, if my interpretation is right, a national law backing those "secondary" uses must be in place.

samuel··on What's Inside the EU Green Pass QR Code?
It implicitelly does. In that case, the certificate has to show 1/1 instead of 1/2 for a two doses vaccine.

Besides, the recommendation for people who had the infection is to get the shot 6 months after the diagnosis, so it would make no sense to include that information in the recovery one.

Source: I work for one of the regional healthcare providers in my country and my team had to develop our EU compatible certificates.

samuel··on What's Inside the EU Green Pass QR Code?
You are right with regards to the technical side, but there is an important detail to note. Those certificates only can be used for travelling between eu states. Any other use is currently banned and would need to ammend the EU regulation.

So the local nightclub cann't(legally) check these certificates.

samuel··on What's Inside the EU Green Pass QR Code?
This is the official github of the project.

https://github.com/eu-digital-green-certificates/

There are Android and iOS apps for QR reading, although they don't point to the production certificate chains so can't be used to verify "real" EU certs.

samuel··on “AI promised to revolutionize radiology but so far its failing”
There is an IHE-Standard Profile that specifies how data has to be to laid out in portable media(USB,CD). All PACS systems follow it and it's basically a no-problem today.

I don't doubt about your anecdote, but I don't think that it's a very common occurrence.

https://wiki.ihe.net/index.php/Cross-enterprise_Document_Med...

samuel··on Transcript of controller telling plane to land in Minsk
AFAIK, countries may lawfully deny entry to their airspace. If the outcome is that an aeroplane has to divert its route, well, tough luck. Those countries played their cards.

To be a comparable case two conditions should be met, namely that a) the bomb threat is real, and b) landing in Minsk the most rational decision.

If both a) and b) are real, well, everything was lawfully managed and the blogger just had bad luck. But if they aren't, no it's not the same case at all.

samuel··on Complexity is a source of income in open source ecosystems (2019)
That's are my thoughts, mostly, but in the end libraries are the killer feature of successful programming languages. I have got used to it and I'm more proficient now at data analysis tasks using R than Python/pandas thanks to tidyverse+ggplot.

The object system mess though... I have no words.

samuel··on Nonnative English speakers share their gripes about speaking English
Bear in mind that people tend to use periphrasis for concepts don't know or can't remember in the moment, which can end sounding fancy.
samuel··on Pg8000 – Pure-Python PostgreSQL driver
I wouldn't blame MySQL for that. JDBC's default mode since 1.0 is autocommit set to true, and surely predates MySQL's success.
samuel··on DragonflyBSD 6.0
This brings backs memories... I still used FreeBSD by then, and I remember that the 5.x branch really had problems and the drama that surrounded it in the community.

I started using FreeBSD(4.3 or 4.4) in the Uni out of curiosity, but kept it for the massive improvement in performance and stability. Loads that brought Linux to its knees(>10) were handled easily by FreeBSD.

The documentation was also superb... the only drawback was having to compile everything, never got used to it.

samuel··on How to Learn Unix Tools
The best way is being restricted to dumb terminals for compiling and running university assigments.

I don't know how younger people force themselves to learn to use the command line. I had a windows 98 at home at the time and the university enviroment seemed primitive in comparison, but I had no choice.

And were lucky, we had X-terminals!

samuel··on We Keep Telling the Myth of a Renaissance Golden Age and Bad Middle Ages (2020)
You are right about the heretics part. But he has a point in the sense that the Catholic Church mostly fought against witch hunts, look

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alonso_de_Salazar_Fr%C3%ADas

Alonso de Salazar Frías has been given the epithet "The Witches’ Advocate"[1] by historians, for his role in establishing the conviction, within the Spanish Inquisition, that accusations against supposed witches were more often rooted in dreams and fantasy than in reality, and the inquisitorial policy that witch accusations and confessions should only be given credence where there was firm, independent, corroborating evidence. He was probably the most influential figure in ensuring that those accused of witchcraft were generally not put to death in seventeenth- and eighteenth-century Spain. The Spanish Inquisition was one of the first institutions in Europe to rule against the death penalty for supposed witches. Its Instructions of 1614, which embodied Salazar's ideas, were influential throughout Catholic Europe.

samuel··on Hyperinflation Pushes Venezuela to Print 1M-Bolivar Bills
But then the government has to default, hasn't it?
samuel··on Lena
That's true in general, but very common surnames, usually those ending in -ez, are ommitted for brevity in informal situations.
samuel··on “I will slaughter you”
I'm trying to make sense of the response. Someone used curl/libcurl in a rootkit? Is that all?
samuel··on Cambridge Bitcoin Electricity Consumption Index
It's completely meaningless because GWh aren't interchangeable. A hydro o thermal energy source too far from inhabited places could be used for bitcoin mining and its CO2 footprint would be near zero.

I'm not saying you are wrong but this requires a far more exhaustive analysis.

samuel··on IceWM 2.0 – Ice Window Manager
Same feeling. I used to prefer WindowMaker, but switched wm's in an almost weekly basis and definitely IceWM got its share.
samuel··on Invention of satanic witchcraft by medieval authorities was met with skepticism
I'm reading "Rise and fall of the dodo" and the plot is mostly what you described.
samuel··on International evaluation of an AI system for breast cancer screening
A bit unrelated, but I'm surprised because of how second readings are performed.

_In the UK, each mammogram is interpreted by two readers, and in cases of disagreement, an arbitration process may invoke a third opinion. These interpretations occur serially, such that each reader has access to the opinions of previous readers._

I wonder if it's sensible to condition the opinion of the second radiologist this way. My first impression is that this should be done blindly or the temptation of just confirming the previous reading because of fatigue/lazynes or to avoid confrontation could severely affect the results.

Similarly, a future in which the radiologist gets too much support could just impair their skills and turn them into a sort of a mechanical worker who simply accepts what the AI overlord has decided.

samuel··on Spanish government orders GitHub to take down Tsunami Democràtic repository
> How much Moorish blood remains in the people of Spain today?

There wasn't much to start with, since the moorish conquest didn't displace the people but "incentivized"(ahem...) people to convert.

> How many conversos did the Inquisitors burn at the stake, generations after their ancestors converted, on the strength of rumormongering by jealous neighbors?

It's hard to know, but I've seen stimates around 3k-5k. Germanic wytchhunts probably had a much higher number of victims. The Inquisition was a pretty bureacratic institution, and it had proper trials with defence lawyers, questioning of witnesses, etc... Inquisitor [Alonso de Salazar](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alonso_de_Salazar_Fr%C3%ADas) for example, saved probably thousands of people by setting high standards in Inquisition trials.

Yes, it was VERY BAD and TERRIBLE, I'm not condoning it, but it wasn't the worse that humanity has seen. By far.

samuel··on Spanish government orders GitHub to take down Tsunami Democràtic repository
It's the best it could happen to anyone who wishes to use the app.

People installing binary blobs from anonymous github repos which are politically charged while granting location permissions... what could possibly go wrong?

samuel··on Spanish government orders GitHub to take down Tsunami Democràtic repository
> The rulers of el-Andalus were no angels either, but their abuses were nothing compared to the censorship-protected horrors of the Inquisition.

That's not true. The Almohads, unlike the almoravids, forced christian and jews to convert, under threat of death.

samuel··on Spain jails Catalan separatist leaders, protesters take to streets
Good point! That was one of the things that were at stake at the trial.
samuel··on Spain jails Catalan separatist leaders, protesters take to streets
> substantial evidence that there was violence involved.

This was your original claim. You are implicitely withdrawing it and moving the goalpost to "evidence of substantial violence"(which is ok, but it was so easy to rebate in its original form that couldn't resist). BTW, states have the monopoly of violence which makes the comparison complicated to asses to anyone who believes in representative democracy and the separation of powers(policemen were trying to execute a court order, no less and no more).

You can keep your 500$, I already knew you were bluffing.

Regarding the issue you are bringing. Yes, the police intervention was a massive clusterfuck. It was impossible to stop the so called "referendum" without the complete cooperation of catalan police and the civil guard and national police cops were sent to an impossible mission. Some of them misbehave, probably out of frustration and fear/anger. This is something a policemen should never do.

If that's your point I could agree.

samuel··on Spain jails Catalan separatist leaders, protesters take to streets
Only if you want to trigger an emotional response. Territories aren't beings.
samuel··on Spain jails Catalan separatist leaders, protesters take to streets
Marriage is a overused analogy that's pretty wrong if you ask me. It's only useful if you want elicit a "beaten wife" kind of comparison.

There are other kinds of contracts(marriage is a contract), where one of the partners can't just walk away from it with its share of the assets.

> There's people demanding a referendum (as seen in Scotland) you just put them in jail, problem solved.

It only seems a good example because it didn't pass. I bet it would be a worse-than-Brexit one if it had. The reality is that a country(a modern state) is built over a thousand of trade-offs that can't be just decided in a referendum.

I wish it would be that easy. I'm pretty tired of this mess.

samuel··on Spain jails Catalan separatist leaders, protesters take to streets
Yet the US itself doesn't allow secession, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2012_U.S._state_secession_peti...
samuel··on Spain jails Catalan separatist leaders, protesters take to streets
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dNoPJWLQrDw

https://www.youtube.com/watch?&v=klSib4rhdLs

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=svGsNGOpxsQ

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DyE0DtVd4Q8

samuel··on Strava cuts off Relive
Android's Syncmytracks has served me fine to keep all my runs in Endomondo. Worth a try.
← PreviousPage 4 of 9Next →