HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

polymatter

1,380 karma · joined August 12, 2011

software developer and accountant

interested in functional programming, learning chinese

email: glisher (underscore) rock (at) hotmail (dot) com

submissionscomments
polymatter··on Longest Lines of Sight on Earth
Londoner here.

Nope, we use a comma as a thousands separator. I believe some European countries use a period though.

polymatter··on I'm Loyal to Nothing Except the Dream
The media was waiting for anything to crucify Trump. He has done nothing but stoke them. He already has been demonized as a white supremisist. The narrative "Trump will ban all Muslims and turn the US into a fascist state" was already on the press, they just needed an excuse to print it.

And there are many who not only disagree with Trump, but are appalled at his persona. There was that big march and that whole "Not my president" thing. They are already primed to believe that Trump will attempt to turn the US into a fascist state. In that light they say this as Step 1 of the "US turns fascist" and they are reacting as though he is suggesting Step 10 Imprisoning political opponents. Because they "see" the path and are doing everything they can to stop it.

polymatter··on An ex-cop's remorse
An excellent point that context matters a lot. Have you seen the Guardians 'The Counted' database of people killed by police? You can click and read a synopsis of each death (https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2015/jun/...).

According to that 811 people were shot and killed by police in 2016 who had a weapon. So a significant % of those killed did indeed have a weapon. I clicked on a few stories of unarmed people shot and killed by police and in some cases it seems obviously justified eg they were driving a vehicle as a weapon or attacked an officer reaching for the officers weapon.

In other cases its less so, eg man killed on 12 December after neighbours mistook his crucifix for a gun or 22 November where a teenager was shot in the back for running from the police or 16 September where a mans car broke down in the road and was shot by police despite clearly complying with instructions.

polymatter··on The Theory of Interstellar Trade (1978)
I saved you the trouble. The author writes about how the Golden Fleece award affected her research (http://www.psychologicalscience.org/observer/the-golden-flee...). She receives at a lot of hate mail - some quite disturbing - and never again receives any more funding from NSF. However, she has had a prolific and distinguished career.

The paper in question is (http://www.elainehatfield.com/uploads/3/2/2/5/3225640/7._hat...) "A little bit about Love" by Hatfield, Elaine & Berscheid, Elaine (1974). It was "facilitated in part by NIMH grant MH 16661 and NSF grants GS 35157X and GS 30822X". It is mostly a review of scientific thinking of the topic at the time and is surprisingly readable and enlightening read.

polymatter··on European Union dedicated questionnaire on the Encryption of Data
The Register reported a man getting 13 months (http://www.theregister.co.uk/2009/11/24/ripa_jfl?page=1) - though I couldn't find a better reference.

BBC also reported on a teenager getting 16 weeks (http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-11479831).

In both cases it seems they were jailed purely for failure to disclose passwords and not in conjunction with any other offence.

polymatter··on Fidel Castro has died
Many many words are better than "evil". How about "autocratic" or "dictatorial" or "power-hungry" or "delusional". Or perhaps a phrase like "ruthlessly uncompromising". All of them convey much more actual information and still have your judgemental tone.

For what its worth, I think "evil" is a word that shouldn't be used outside of storybooks. It is a binary word that is far too overgeneralised to the point it is meaningless to ascribe. It doesn't serve any persuasive or descriptive purpose.

polymatter··on ICQ: 20 Years Is No Limit
For anyone not getting the joke, see http://bash.org/?244321
polymatter··on The man who studies the spread of ignorance
> uninformed people form such a large percentage of the voting pool

agreed.

but surely the natural solution is to increase the number of informed people (education, PSAs, 'nudging' people towards being more informed). not to disenfranchise the poor.

polymatter··on A simple explanation of Chinese characters
Thanks for the reply. I will do that.
polymatter··on A simple explanation of Chinese characters
as someone currently learning Vietnamese do you have any tips for learning the language? I've learnt some Mandarin so I am no stranger to tones - but the tones in Vietnamese seem quite different.

I've been using Pimsleur which I highly recommend, but I find I end up atuned to their particular voices and can not understand genuine Vietnamese speech. Also I am using memrise to learn vocabulary, but without example sentences and the like I find it of limited use until I find the same word in a real life context.

Interested in your thoughts.

polymatter··on Tim Peake: UK astronaut heads for space station
There is a distinct difference between an identity that I have chosen based on my personal preferences and one that is forced upon me by circumstance. One I can change and has deep significance to me. One is assigned and immutable and has very little direct influence in my day to day life.

You have the strange notion that without nationalism to enforce an identity on myself that naturally there is no way my neighbor and me can live in "peace and harmony". I suggest that I can work with other people just fine, even if I don't share an identity with them. In fact, if you can only work peacefully with people similar to yourself I believe that is discrimination of some form or another. I realize no human is an ideal machine, but any person with empathy really ought to be able to work with women/men/muslims/jews/french/british/german/ginger/blond/tall/short/disabled people without issue - especially if they want to remain employed in the modern world.

Finally, please avoid insulting people who express a different opinion to your own.

polymatter··on Finland plans to give every citizen a basic income of 800€ a month
many vulnerable people don't know what they can qualify for and what they can't. especially if they are not particularly literate as many adults are not - especially if they have a non-native background.

many vulnerable people don't claim even if they know they qualify because the whole process is demeaning. sometimes when you have lost everything, you desperately hold onto your dignity, even if that isn't profit-maximising. real people (as opposed to idealised economic agents) are like that.

many vulnerable people can't claim because they slip through the cracks. the process of verification can be intense, especially as the public demand absolutely no benefit cheats meaning everyone is treated as a fraudulent with a lack of empathy or compassion.

many vulnerable people have no incentive to save money (since that might disqualify them from receiving benefits in the future). this is similar to what happens with company budgets. you need to spend all that money or you won't get it next year when you might actually need it.

tl;dr its complicated. the end result depends on a ton of externalities.

polymatter··on The Secret Ingredient in Orange Juice
I am very curious about your comment. how is pure h20 dangerous?
polymatter··on Firefox: We Don't Need Google's Money Any More
perhaps its flash? I keep having the same problem and I suspect flash
polymatter··on What the Future of Working at Home May Look Like
Programmers, accountants, owner, medieval and apprentices are all capitalized where I would leave them uncapitalized. It feels random to me. I put it down to a different writing style.
polymatter··on NASA Orders SpaceX Crew Mission to International Space Station
> These are people who are very likely at the top of their fields, have gone through rigorous (and costly) training, and are going up to do very specific jobs

That is irrelevant to the level safety precautions. Unless you were trying to argue that their costly training makes them worth more than other people. I hope that is not what you were arguing.

> doesn't mean we shouldn't be doing everything we can to ensure a safe flight

At some point you have to declare something 'safe enough' since 100% safety is an impossible perfection. Bicycles aren't 100% safe, but we don't go around insisting on multiple backup systems. Personally I do find it curious that the standard of safety for astronauts is so high. The cynic in me suggests its less out of concern for the astronauts and more to do with the publicity fallout that occurs after disasters and the damage to other assets. The optimist suggests its more a concern for all the ground crew and spectators who are also at risk. There is potential for a lot more than 4 casualties when you play with that much fire.

polymatter··on Google self-driving car pulled over for driving too slowly
If you drove with zero distance between your bumper and the car in front of you, they will be unable to brake hard, because its trying to stop an extra ton of mass. you're fine sure, but they just ran over that kid crossing the road without looking. or just t-boned someone. and heaven forbid someone was tailgating you too.

autonomous cars can form trains because they can react orders of magnitude faster than a human can to suddenly changing driving conditions.

polymatter··on How Finland plans to implement the first nation-wide basic income in the EU
thanks for the detailed reply

I imagine any sensible, practical proposal for basic income would start it relatively low, keeping many current benefits and gradually expand it if it is successful. That seems to be the option Finland proposal will probably take. This will give time to assess the impact and allow corrections/adaptions/cancelling it . No doubt basic income is a blunt instrument, honestly I think that's part of its appeal to me. It seems fair compared to a plethora of well-meaning but convoluted network of social welfare initiatives, that we call a social welfare system.

I will consider you points more carefully.

- obviously a lot depends on the level of basic income. and what is sacrificed for it. I had not considered the politics of people using basic income as an excuse to withdraw education or health subsidies.

- effect on wages can be mitigated in the short term by retaining a (perhaps lower?) minimum wage.

- I agree a lot of basic income will be swallowed in rent. but that will be because that is what is important to people with the money to spend.

- cost-of-living differences will encourage job-seekers to relocate to cheaper areas. this seems like a good thing. if inner city companies can not find the workers it needs, it will either relocate or provide company buses or something. that seems a much better solution than keeping job-seekers where they are.

- non-citizens is a very good point I hadn't considered. But then, non-citizens are penalized by requiring visas etc. plus EU nations will be restricted on what they can do to stop EU citizens claiming.

thanks again.

polymatter··on How Finland plans to implement the first nation-wide basic income in the EU
in what way does having a diverse population pose problems to basic income specifically? you are just stating a general problem.

basic income has no effect on diversity or homogeneity. perhaps it might encourage people to immigrate, but that's hardly a reason not to do it. having a country that is so desirable others would like to immigrate into it is a clear indication of doing something right. besides I think its obvious you would only qualify for basic income as a citizen.

polymatter··on How Finland plans to implement the first nation-wide basic income in the EU
what are the "whole host of negative aspects"?

I will accept that there are almost certainly edge cases which I can't predict that will need ironing out. probably due to the administration of updating the list appropriately. but basic income seems very much like the proverbial silver bullet that never exists, so I am curious over its negative aspects.

in discussing with friends and family, the worst thing about basic income is it means paying people for doing nothing and that _really_ _really_ angers some people. even worse, it means even millionaires get basic income!

polymatter··on The Western diet has nearly killed our ancestral microbiome
Sexual selection is still a thing, and unlikely to go away for the foreseeable future. Diet affects appearance, appearance affects chances to pass on your genes.
polymatter··on Tor Wars: The Signal Awakens
Is there any way to get just the static html pages post 2008 when they just stopped doing them? That's 6 years out of date.

The Wikipedia on DVD link doesn't seem to work http://www.wikipediaondvd.com/.

And I am not sure what to do with the Database backup dumps if the only thing I want is some static HTML pages, how could I get some readable HTML out of them?

polymatter··on For the First Time, a Prosecutor Will Go to Jail for Wrongfully Convicting
FYI he had retired. Taking away his license is purely symbolic and entirely consistent with this light tap on the wrist.
polymatter··on Obama Encryption Policy Rejects Laws Mandating Backdoors
IANAL, but the judge may order you to keep the warrant canary or find you in contempt. Law is based on intent and if your intent in removing that clause is in broadcasting you are under gag order, when the gag order restricts you from doing exactly that, you may find that will be taken as a breach.

This should not be taken as legal advice, YMMV, yadda yadda.

polymatter··on Obama Encryption Policy Rejects Laws Mandating Backdoors
> needing multiple keys in order to decrypt - not sure if that's mathematically possible

As a matter of interest Shamirs Secret Sharing algorithm (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shamir's_Secret_Sharing) is quite nice in that respect. The "secret" would be the decryption key. Using Shamirs Secret Sharing algorithm you could split the key into two so you would need both parts in order to work out the decryption key. The government could have a part. The company could have another. Only when both were combined could anyone work out the decryption key.

This would mean neither the company nor the government could decrypt messages until they work together - and therefore reduce the risk of hackers and rogue employees. It wouldn't break the encryption with dangerous backdoors but would allow the authorities to quickly gain access when needed for a specific investigation.

I doubt anyone would ever implement anything like that since it would be (slightly more) complex and you would have to trust that the decryption parts are valid. But I thought I would just mention it in case anyone else might find that algorithm as interesting as I do.

polymatter··on The Best Jobs Now Require You to Be a People Person
I read him as saying that while men and women are different they are not _that_ different and that social causes is probably a bigger factor than any biological one.
polymatter··on Ex-Googler says she exposed company-wide pay inequality with spreadsheet
I'm not sure why you feel you can't push both of you for a raise.

Surely having the public record is in your favour because you can point to similar jobs that pay more.

polymatter··on The Big Mac Index
For what its worth, in my experience its similar in China. I even saw an ad showing a guy taking his girlfriend to McDonalds on a date.
polymatter··on If you've nothing to hide, you've got nothing to fear
> if you don't like a country you can just move...

you know many many people risk their lives under extreme conditions to do exactly that. See Latin Americans trying to get to US or Africans into Europe.

Hell I am in the process of emigrating from one Western country to another, and its an incredibly stressful process with no guarantee of success for me.

polymatter··on Toyota ad hijacks Siri to switch off iPhones while driving
If your roads are an obstacle course then it sounds like they shouldn't have cars on because they're clearly not wide enough. That's endangering the lives of all traffic, not just cyclists.
← PreviousPage 3 of 19Next →