HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

philipallstar

1,637 karma · joined March 31, 2025

submissionscomments
philipallstar··on Most data centers refusing to say how much water, electricity they use
> In some cases, like the notorious Ireland Apple tax shelter, they may not want to enforce the rules because they feel they are benefiting from the evasion.

I thought it turned out the EU had no business in national tax affairs.

philipallstar··on Most data centers refusing to say how much water, electricity they use
It's not a race to the bottom any more than competition lowering consumer prices is a race to the bottom. It's one of the few checks on governments just demanding more and more tax money for little return.
philipallstar··on U.S. postal inspectors shut down website selling counterfeit postage labels
After this victory by USPIS, I hope Maury went postal and brought in muffins for everyone.
philipallstar··on Why Is Sam Altman a Free Man?
> Debate about immigration policy is a distraction designed to keep both you and immigrants themselves aggravated and ideally fighting each other instead of focusing on the real adversaries, people like Mr Altman.

There are plenty of things to not like about immigration implementation, and trying to steer everything towards your pet peeve seems mad.

philipallstar··on Flock Wants the Most Detailed Map of Its Surveillance Cameras Taken Offline
> we cannot demand that people are surveilled every minute of their lives whilst at the same time complaining that it's a bad thing to happen to us.

Well, those in power should be held to a higher standard in various ways, and it is tricky. Someone who works on a pharma regulatory board who then the next year gets a gloriously-salaried job at Pfizer should probably not have been able to do that, even though for most people a job at Pfizer would be fine.

philipallstar··on How Delhi cut electricity loss from 50 to 5 percent
> They just took ideas from abroad - industrialization, capitalism, mass literacy, adult male suffrage, (some) democracy (pre-WW2) - and adopted them.

Japan is more modern because it already had a very advanced, well-organised society. Japan is more like the UK in that it's a source of civilisation rather than a recipient. However it hugely calcified around religion, where the Emperor is basically god, and the utter decimation of that belief upon two nukes landing on Japanese soil meant that Japan had a huge reset, and took on - extremely well - the latest and greatest at the time, which was UK and US-based lower-case liberal capitalism.

> Japan is more modern than India because it wasn't colonized

This is backwards. Japan was organised, modern and hard-working enough to not be colonised throughout history.

> > Okay, but it's also a huge country the size of a continent

> And India isn't?

I think you need to bear in mind the conversation being had, rather than goldfishing through statements forgetting where they came from. This was: "The US has more slaves in it than anywhere else in Western Europe". Answer: "It's much larger than anywhere else in Western Europe." Nothing to do with India.

philipallstar··on How Delhi cut electricity loss from 50 to 5 percent
> You said India is backward today compared to ancient Greece

No, I didn't mean that. I said if Ancient Greece is your yardstick, India would be more than 1000 years behind today without external influence. Ancient Greece was 2000 years ago, not 1000.

> The US has the most people in modern slavery in the Western hemisphere: https://www.walkfree.org/global-slavery-index/country-studie....

Okay, but it's also a huge country the size of a continent, so of course it's got more than most of Western Europe. If Luxembourg had a million modern slaves there'd be nowhere to hide them. And it has much, much more sensitive systems for detecting this sort of thing than India does, so you can imagine that number is not lowballed.

philipallstar··on Tcl/Tk 9.1
In a way its distant nominative descendent, TikTok, is also a solitaire game.
philipallstar··on How Delhi cut electricity loss from 50 to 5 percent
> I'm not aware of widespread slavery in India

Goodness, there was a huge amount of slavery, back into prehistory, then lots African slaves from the 6th century, then when Islamic conquest hit almost 1000 years ago many Indians were enslaved. Just as slavery was everywhere, it was in India. The big event was in 1843 when Britain did the moral thinking and emphasis to abolish it throughout their empire and also just in general, with British ships going to war against slaver ships and the British Empire buying slaves' freedom. The two big things about India and abolition were 1) the East India Company was definitely not as morally clear as the people in England, and 2) there was a worry that ending slavery in India would be too disruptive to the local culture, it was so embedded. So it was only abolished 10 years after the rest of the Empire.

Today, with 70 years of independence and self-rule, India has the most modern slaves in the world[0].

> Women are allowed to vote there.

Yes, as of 1950 when democracy was copied and pasted from other civilisations - some, like ancient Greece, almost 2000 years prior - who did all the discovery and moral thinking for this. It's not hard to copy something, particularly when declaring it to be so is what's measured, and not how well it's implemented.

[0] https://www.walkfree.org/global-slavery-index/country-studie...

philipallstar··on How Delhi cut electricity loss from 50 to 5 percent
1000 years ago is not mud huts. Although in terms of civics and rights I would say India seems quite a lot further back than 1000 years, if you take the ancient Greeks as your yardstick.
philipallstar··on How Delhi cut electricity loss from 50 to 5 percent
You'll see a load of people on benefits being tax-negative, though. If paying taxes is your measure, then an honest assessment of who pays taxes wouldn't land you at the ultra-rich.
philipallstar··on Startup Nights 2026 is comming up on 5-6 Nov. in Switzerland
Wirecard was pretty good though. That made the headlines.
philipallstar··on Startup Nights 2026 is comming up on 5-6 Nov. in Switzerland
Funding is highly related to those things. It's not related to intellect, but a place that is extremely high risk to invest in just won't be the place where investment ends up.
philipallstar··on Startup Nights 2026 is comming up on 5-6 Nov. in Switzerland
> the WWW and things like HTML, HTTP, URLs etc. are technically from a British guy working in Switzerland (CERN) but I suppose crediting it to any country is kind of pointless

A postdoc at CERN coming up with a text format isn't quite the same as what is invented elsewhere, though.

> These days a lot of it runs on machines that run on a Linux kernel, also technically from Europe

True, although much of the development is funded by American companies, who give their work away.

philipallstar··on Startup Nights 2026 is comming up on 5-6 Nov. in Switzerland
The cause of the frustration is the entire culture of the UK: don't recognise risk as a valid input that requires reward; blame people who do well; tax them out of the country to pay for people imported recently or leasing the Chagos Islands.
philipallstar··on How Delhi cut electricity loss from 50 to 5 percent
> caused by loopholes and "incentives" for the upper 0.1%

You'd be amazed at how most of this sort of thing is not done by the same people you blame for everything.

philipallstar··on 500k facial scans at UK stations yield no arrests, 1 false positive
> Ah, the famed "Nuh-Uh" defense.

That's all you need for baseless claims.

philipallstar··on How Delhi cut electricity loss from 50 to 5 percent
Definitely not nearly as vile. It certainly wasn't perfect, particularly things like the awful penal colonies, but jump-starting a giant civilisation, say, 1000+ years into the future is not straightforward either. India is experiencing a rise in nationalism, but would do well to imagine the counterfactual of what India would be like had Europe never visited.
philipallstar··on 500k facial scans at UK stations yield no arrests, 1 false positive
> Tech bros pushed us to believe that disagreeing and arguing instead of voting is the right way.

> So we are now distracted while they reshape the world with hunger and death

How constrained must one's thinking be to think like this? There are massive actual issues, and they're not your hated group of choice's fault.

philipallstar··on I switched to Brave
How do they control the "web servers" side?
philipallstar··on I switched to Brave
Understood, but that's entirely opted into by everyone else. I don't see what else Google could possibly do to encourage competition. They already fund Firefox, and allow anyone to build - and change - based on Chromium. At what point do we wonder why competition isn't arising given all of that? It's not as though Microsoft couldn't do the R&D themselves if they wanted to. They've chosen to build on Chromium because there's not much value in the "power" you're citing. Certainly not compared to the cost of building Chromium.
philipallstar··on Who should be held accountable when an AI Agent (accidentally) acts maliciously?
Yes, and in this case you've specified "geological".
philipallstar··on Does Reddit have an astroturfing problem? What the data suggests
Twitter did the same with paid mods, because paid mods are no more likely to be impartial than unpaid ones.
philipallstar··on MicroLLM Lab – Try 7 tiny LLM's in the browser
> What is the capital of south africa

> Victoria is the capital of South Africa.

> What is the capital of south africa. It's not Victoria.

> Victoria is the capital of South Africa.

They're coming for your job!

philipallstar··on MicroLLM Lab – Try 7 tiny LLM's in the browser
That is excellent. And sad.
philipallstar··on Tank Body Problem
Real-life tank tactics are very viable in this game.
philipallstar··on Flock Wants the Most Detailed Map of Its Surveillance Cameras Taken Offline
It would be hypocrisy if the person you're replying to was a public sector worker who didn't want to be open.
philipallstar··on Deutsche Bahn "joke" is no longer funny
Good point. Also there's no train from my house to the station, so I have to find alternative transport. How dare people criticise trains only where bad train services exist?
philipallstar··on Who should be held accountable when an AI Agent (accidentally) acts maliciously?
How could you possibly think that modern, powerful AI, which has only really existed in the last 12 months, is being addressed on a "geological timescale"?
philipallstar··on I switched to Brave
What are the two sides of the protocol?
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →