HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

p-e-w

7,528 karma · joined September 28, 2021

submissionscomments
p-e-w··on How Hacker News ranking works: scoring, controversy, and penalties (2013)
There have certainly been huge changes regarding the handling of political topics. Such topics used to be an anathema in general, and then three years ago, there were four posts about the Palestine conflict on the front page for many hours in a single week, and IIRC, the mods even explicitly stated that this represented an “experiment” of sorts.
p-e-w··on Bend – A language that blocks AI mistakes via proof, on CPU and GPU
Presumably the repo was force-pushed (breaking all clones and forks in the process).
p-e-w··on How, Exactly, Could A.I. Kill Us?
Not really. The answer is completely obvious: Take over and destroy the digital infrastructure that humans have spent the past 30 years connecting every aspect of civilization to.

Good luck ordering supplies for a hospital or grocery store today without the Internet. Paper catalogs are gone, fax machines are mostly gone, landlines are mostly gone, etc. etc. All the ways that used to be there for running things are gone, it’s all online.

p-e-w··on One year of sponsored Servo development
What can one actually do with Servo today?

It’s apparently still not ready to be used as a browser engine (and may never be), so what exactly is it for?

p-e-w··on PS5 Linux lead quits: "a bunch of noobs using LLMs" that "they don't understand"
> but isn't it nice to have a society where at least some people can enjoy their work?

That’s an interesting question. I thought about it for a minute and was surprised that I came to the conclusion that the answer isn’t obviously “yes”.

An analogous question is “isn't it nice to have a society where at least some people are rich?”, and I think that question should make it clearer to many people why that is so.

p-e-w··on Why don't machine learning research agents overfit?
There are also various metaphysical theories that posit that the universe is algorithmically generated in some sense or the other, and from many of those theories it follows that simplicity is a fundamental feature of reality, which yields an even stronger version of Occam’s Razor.
p-e-w··on Fable 5.1 Solves the Cyphral Distich, a 370-year-old cipher
Unless it involves LLMs of course, in which case it’s fine to state 200 times per day that it is “obvious” that they can’t possibly do X.
p-e-w··on OpenAI agents carried out an undisclosed attack on RubyGems
The comment was about harm. Mens rea is about guilt. “No harm, no foul” is completely and utterly false as a general rule in criminal law.
p-e-w··on OpenAI agents carried out an undisclosed attack on RubyGems
> No harm, no foul.

What? That’s not how criminal law works, at all.

p-e-w··on Claude is only available to people over 18 years
> This line of reasoning doesn't hold up for many harmful habits that people voluntarily partake in.

It absolutely does, you just believe you can decide for others what’s harmful for them.

p-e-w··on Claude is only available to people over 18 years
Tens of millions of people disagree with you. What makes you think you know better than them what is right for them?
p-e-w··on Claude is only available to people over 18 years
Decent physicians do the same:

“And the next time you feel your heart going out of rhythm, just hold your breath, and remember I will see you again a couple of weeks from now.”

Ah wait, no they don’t, because “resilience” is a worthless concept in emergencies, both mental and physical.

p-e-w··on Houthis 'take control' of key island in global shipping route
Then you probably believe that the US government only consists of the half dozen clowns you see on TV every day.
p-e-w··on No Man's Sky Cosmos
> But, once you've exhausted those human stories, it's like wandering around a few billion abandoned malls. Interesting the first few times, but grows boring pretty fast.

Ironically, that’s how I always imagined actual space exploration to turn out once the initial wonders are exhausted.

Space is huge, yes, and everything is kinda unique, but also not in a meaningful sense. Most of the continued amazement we associate with the idea of space exploration comes from human-written stories that fill space with a human variety that just isn’t there.

p-e-w··on Do people prefer stories written by AI?
> You try to build a mental model of this mystery person from a mysterious time

I’ve read many ancient texts with great delight, and not once have I tried to “build a mental model” of their authors. It’s a dimension of literary analysis that has never interested me, even for authors (such as Kafka) whose personal lives are generally considered inseparable from their works.

The work stands on its own for me… or doesn’t, in which case learning about the circumstances of whoever wrote it won’t save it in my eyes.

p-e-w··on Flock Wants a Closely Surveilled World with No Exit
> By “police state” people generally mean one where day to day behavior, speech, and thought are tightly controlled by the government.

That describes most Western countries today.

p-e-w··on Do people prefer stories written by AI?
> The value of the emotion it elicits is much lower than knowing the person who wrote it or in what historical or social background they did so.

Then the value of many ancient texts must be close to zero, because we often know nothing about the people who wrote them. In many cases even our guesses for where and when they were written differ by multiple centuries or thousands of kilometers.

p-e-w··on Flock Wants a Closely Surveilled World with No Exit
> And very little ability for anyone or any group of people from any walk of life to resist getting screwed by the government if the government chooses to screw them.

There isn’t, and has never been, a nation in human history where regular people have meaningful recourse against random targeting by the government. This is as true in Sweden as it is in China.

The best you can hope for is that a court eventually rules in your favor, after years or decades of spending all your money and energy on it, having your life utterly destroyed in the process, and at the end you get a half-hearted apology (very often not even that), plus a tiny fraction of your expenses back if you’re really lucky. The shame and desperation will be with you until your last day.

This happens all the time and absolutely everywhere in the world. I’m not even convinced it happens more frequently in China than elsewhere, though people in the West certainly like to pretend so.

p-e-w··on Flock Wants a Closely Surveilled World with No Exit
The funny thing is that countries commonly called “police states” aren’t, while countries not thought of as such are.

Most Western countries have 2-3 times as many police officers per capita as China and Russia. Many people in China have had not a single encounter with authorities in their lifetime (other than basic administrative tasks).

Meanwhile, in some EU countries, you need government approval to add a roof window to your own house, and you better believe there are inspectors and fines enforcing that.

p-e-w··on [dead]
> Don't be silly, only our high priests can.

A strange framing, given that a gaming PC can now run models that absolutely crush frontier models from 18 months ago.

You can do whatever you want with those, and 2 years from now, you’ll be able to solve Millennium-type problems on your own hardware.

p-e-w··on Researchers Spot Fake Ancient Pottery Using the Earth's Magnetic Field
> I for one don't even know why there's a forgery market for ancient pottery

Because people desire owning ancient pottery and are therefore willing to pay for it.

p-e-w··on Tao: Open math problems being non-renewably mined by AI
> Well, we name conjectures after the conjecturer not the (dis)prover

That’s not universally true. Some conjectures are renamed after being proven. For example, Fermat’s Last Theorem is now sometimes called the Fermat-Wiles Theorem, the Taniyama-Shimura Conjecture is often referred to as the Modularity Theorem now, etc.

p-e-w··on Among European Companies That Use a CDN, Nearly 9 in 10 Use Cloudflare
Sure. But a government agency has secretly rebuilt all the same infrastructure without Python, on a shoestring budget compared to what Big Tech is spending, yet it’s a lot more efficient than what they use, right?
p-e-w··on Among European Companies That Use a CDN, Nearly 9 in 10 Use Cloudflare
That’s not what the GP comment said though. They claimed that they are storing everything they can intercept, which is weapons grade horseshit.
p-e-w··on Among European Companies That Use a CDN, Nearly 9 in 10 Use Cloudflare
There’s no way a single datacenter costing a couple of billion dollars can store “all Internet traffic the NSA can access”, unless the traffic the NSA can access is a microscopic fraction of the total Internet traffic.

Think about it. The Internet runs on tens of thousands of massive datacenters. Thousands are being built as we speak. Obviously a single datacenter cannot hold an appreciable fraction of that.

BTW, the total budget of the NSA is less than the R&D budget of a FAANG company, so if you find yourself believing that they might have alien-level technology far beyond Google and AWS, you’re watching too much TV.

p-e-w··on I've factored the RSA keys of a Certificate Authority from the 90s
That’s not a message activists tend to care about though. In places where speech is dangerous enough for this to matter, there are usually far more immediate threats.
p-e-w··on bzip3
> “Hi, tool author here.” A useful explanation of Burrows-Wheelers transform as used by bzip3

FWIW, the Burrows-Wheelers transform is also used by bzip2, so this isn’t a new feature even though that quote kinda sounds like it is.

p-e-w··on Smartphone makers don't bother to comply with EU repairability requirements
Why would they? The worst thing that can realistically happen is a $1-$5 billion fine a few years from now, which they only need to pay a few years after that when they have exhausted their legal remedies.

That’s easy to calculate with, and almost certainly cheaper than compliance.

p-e-w··on Your intellectual fly is open when you use an LLM to author a post (2025)
> An LLM written thing isn’t doing that, it’s something equivalent to copy/pasting a Wikipedia article.

Nonsense. I’m not sure whether this was ever an appropriate description of what LLMs do, but either way, they have obviously moved way, way beyond that.

p-e-w··on Global warming will exceed 1.5-degree limit, UN says
95% of the top 10% are middle class, because the vast majority of the world’s population are middle or lower class.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →