2,906 karma · joined November 25, 2021
-----BEGIN GEEK CODE BLOCK----- Version: 3.12 GIT d--- s++:++ a+ C++ UL++++ P+ L++ E+ W+++ N++ o-- K++ w+ O---- M+ V-- PS+++ PE-- Y++ PGP+ t+ 5 X+ R !tv b+ DI-- D+ G- e* h r- y+ ------END GEEK CODE BLOCK------
The point is that a sufficiently motivated actor could use a very broad array of tactics, some automated and some manual, to identify, observe, track, and/or locate a target. Maybe they can’t pin you down with your browser fingerprints because you’ve been smart enough to use tools that obfuscate it, but that’s not happening in a vacuum. Correlating one otherwise useless datapoint that happens to persist long enough to tie things together at even low-ish confidence is still a hugely worthwhile sieve with which to filter people out of the possibility pool.
The problem isn’t that it doesn’t affect most average people, or that it it’s terribly imprecise. The problem is that it’s even a little effective, while being nearly impossible to completely avoid. It’s also a problem if that’s used by a malicious state actor against a journalist, to pick a rather obvious example. Because even in isolation, this kind of violation of civil liberties necessarily impacts all of society.
The public should be given more information and control, broadly speaking, for when they are asked to trade their rights for convenience, security, and/or commerce. In particular, I think the United States has allowed bad faith arguments against regulatory actions and basic consumer rights so corporate lobbyists can steamroll any chance of even baseline protections. It would behoove all of us to be more distrustful of companies and moneyed interests, while being more engaged with, and demanding of, our governments.
All that said, the main project looks to be open sourced under a GPL3 license, so distrust and verify: https://github.com/ghostery
I’d like a feature in my HN reader that sticks a red button at the bottom anytime XKCD has already made the points I’m reading.
> Could Not Give Kudos
>Kudos could not be given to the message for the following reason: > Kudos Flood: You have exceeded the limit of 10 kudoed messages per minute.
Enough said. There are simply too many people telling Mozilla to fuck right off for me to Kudo them all.
Edit: correcting autocorrect.
Any answer that’s not fully bulletproof immediately rules any other opinions you may hold illegitimate.
/s