HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nathanasmith

831 karma · joined July 30, 2015

submissionscomments
nathanasmith··on We built voice modulation to mask gender in technical interviews
You keep bringing this point up in the comments and you've been answered but I'm curious about something.

You say elsewhere that while 20 percent (the actual number is around 18) of CS grads are women, only 10 percent of junior devs are in fact female. Others have mentioned that maybe the women went on to graduate school or are working some CS related job that doesn't fit the definition of "junior dev".

The latter points seem reasonable to me but you keep bringing it up though so here's my question, where do you think 50 percent of female grads are ending up? The unemployment line? That would seem like a very large number of people, such a large number that it would have been recorded somewhere. Do you have any actual statistical data beyond the raw numbers you keep bringing up?

nathanasmith··on Dunning-Kruger and other memes (2015)
>>Do not forget that this very "self esteem" thingy is almost exclusively American. The other nations do not even think in such terms.

This over inflated sense of importance or "self esteem thingy" may be exclusively American but not anywhere close to all Americans subscribe to it. There are 330+ million people of various ages and backgrounds living in the US. I don't see how painting with such a broad brush like you have been does anything but inflame debate.

My question is this though, as much as people like bandying DK around, has it not been replicated? Specific to you, has the effect not been tested anywhere outside North America?

nathanasmith··on Brexit and the Failure of Western Establishment Institutions
You could easily flip that around and say that older people have the more informed opinion in addition to more life experience.
nathanasmith··on Microsoft is the first big company to say it's serving the legal marijuana trade
The absurd thing is that while marijuana being a schedule I drug which in the DEA's own words:

>> Schedule I drugs are the most dangerous drugs of all the drug schedules with potentially severe psychological or physical dependence.[0]

Cocaine and methamphetamine are both schedule II.

Now I understand the difference is that Schedule II means there are some medical uses but to lump marijuana in with "the most dangerous" but not meth? That just seems ridiculous.

[0]https://www.dea.gov/druginfo/ds.shtml

nathanasmith··on Anders Ericsson on deliberate practice
What works for me is downloading the source code of projects that are generally considered to be examples of great code. I then go through it, stopping at critical junctures asking myself, What would I do next? Then comparing that to whatever the author of the program did. If I'm "wrong", I attempt to figure out why and adjust accordingly.

This was directly inspired by the technique Benjamin Franklin used to become a great writer.[0]

[0]http://historymatters.gmu.edu/d/6220/ Search for the word spectator in the link for the relevant paragraph.

nathanasmith··on Oculus Rift exclusivity protection leads to a VR piracy arms race
Pardon me but I see it as a glorified monitor/input device. I do realize there is a qualitative difference but the point is, neither the monitor or the mouse I currently use have any exclusive titles and I would be hard pressed to pay $600 for the privilege. So, Vive it is, assuming they don't pull this mess.
nathanasmith··on Why Suburbia Sucks
>>I suspect many (perhaps most) of the people reading that article agree that suburbia sucks - the tricky part is fixing it.

"Fixing" it by doing what? Making it more like the urban core? That place already exists. If you like it then go live there. Obviously many people like the lifestyle of living in the suburbs. There is room in this country for more than one kind of neighborhood.

nathanasmith··on Experienced Programmers Use Google Frequently
More often than not I will very deliberately type my search phrase one character at a time paying careful attention to all the autocompleted results. Very useful habit to get into as I have solved quite a few problems much faster than had I gone down the rabbit hole of my original query.
nathanasmith··on Microsoft stops Google being used for Cortana searches
> Complaining that Cortana uses Bing is like complaining that Google Now uses Google.

Not really at all. People use Google because it provides superior search results. Bing takes longer to crawl new sites and doesn't crawl them nearly as often as Google does.

nathanasmith··on Why Do Some Poor Kids Thrive?
I mostly agree with you. Maybe our emphasis is different. I try to look at the issue from a practical standpoint. I can't change where I was born or how much money my parents had or even what I did 5 minutes ago. What I can do is take my present set of circumstances and do what I can do to make things better from this point on. If I lay in bed all day, things aren't going to improve but if I get on this computer and work until 9 o'clock tonight doing what it is that I do then I stand a pretty good chance of having a more prosperous future. Especially if I do that consistently. And it's hard work. I'd rather play video games but I don't. I work.

Regarding the people you grew up with, you say they work as hard as you do. Are you sure about that? And while they may be working hard, how smart are they working? For instance, some went to college, did they get a degree in something that is in high demand where the pay is good? And getting a college degree is only one piece of a good education. How much did they really learn, and consequently, how competitive are they in the job market? Even if they're all in high demand STEM fields, they still have to compete with the thousands of other job seekers after all.

Thinking through the alternatives and making smarter choices is hard work. And that is cumulative. It's kind of like compound interest too. You may not see a big difference from day to day or month to month but given some roll of the dice in circumstances, over the course of years and decades, working hard will almost always make a huge difference.

nathanasmith··on Why Do Some Poor Kids Thrive?
I had a comment in mind I was going to go with but when I clicked reply in a new tab, I notice you ninja edited putting in the last line where you came clean and admitted that there was a little something you did that made a difference.

My question is this, ignoring your edit, if you say it was all luck based on the 8 points here, am I to conclude that anybody with these advantages would all have the same outcome no matter what they themselves did (taking into consideration the likely variability of behavior in context of your profile). If they worked their asses off, they would be no more successful than you are now and if they had just did the minimum, they'd be just as successful as you are.

I'd surmise this would not be the case so it seems likely that how hard one works, given the hand they're dealt, means a little more than you think.

nathanasmith··on Why Do Some Poor Kids Thrive?
Yeah well, in everything I've done as far back as I can remember when I worked harder I got better results and when I slacked off, I got worse results. I'm thinking how hard you work has a little more to do with success than you give it credit for.
nathanasmith··on YouTube-dl: Open-source YouTube downloader
Um, I'd be interested!
nathanasmith··on Austin Startup Sees a Big Future for Little Homes
He's probably right about the appreciation

I'm not saying you're wrong but I'm curious what you have to back that statement up. Detroit is rapidly losing population[0] with no end in sight. Typically for prices to rise, there has to be some kind of demand. I guess you could just gut the supply by wholesale tearing everything down and seeing if you can sell what's left.

0. https://www.google.com/publicdata/explore?ds=kf7tgg1uo9ude_&...

nathanasmith··on Being a “dumb” girl in Computer Science
The cottage industry devoted to writing blog posts about how hard it is to be a woman in tech and all the sexism and hardship all women face along the way seems to be doing their part to continue to intimidate and discourage women from learning to code.

As long as there is a market for that kind of rhetoric and enough eyeballs show up to generate the ad impressions, blog posts will be written about it. If shit on a stick was what everybody wanted to read about, we'd be up to our ears on whether blue or purple shit was the hotness this fall. The transparency of it and that people seem to find it confusing is the funniest thing of all.

nathanasmith··on That awkward moment when Apple mocked good hardware and poor people
I am not poor yet I have a Moto E that I bought from Best Buy last black Friday for $10. I love it. Anybody that would judge me based on my choice of phone would promptly get their face laughed in.
nathanasmith··on The Plan to Give Every Cellphone User Free Data
>> I think he's saying that's what Song's argument is.

I didn't say anything about whose argument it was just implying that it was specious.

>> Pretty sure comments like that will get you downvoted

I stopped worrying about internet points long ago.

nathanasmith··on The Plan to Give Every Cellphone User Free Data
>>> the social benefits outweigh the very small cost.

Of course they do, when it's somebody else's money. Bye bye karma or whatever it's called on this site.

nathanasmith··on What’s Next in Computing?
I would argue that education could benefit immensely from VR. Why explain it when you can show it. Imagine something like Fantastic Voyage in high school biology.
nathanasmith··on Revisiting the Google Pixel C – Better, but Not There Yet
I follow you on everything else but

>> most apps only run in portrait mode

What? That's not even remotely true. I think out of the hundred or so apps I have on my Android tablet, there might be one that is stuck in portrait mode.

nathanasmith··on Windows Phone is dead
Microsoft is not competing against Netscape-caliber companies in the mobile phone race.
nathanasmith··on Windows Phone is dead
I'm picturing myself in a developing country with a phone in hand, thinking about how to go about getting a "computer". Let's see, with this phone, I can go and buy a compatible keyboard and dock, then find a screen that is advanced enough to be compatible with the dock's interface. Or for almost certainly less, I can buy some no-name tablet or basic chromebook or laptop. I would probably go with the tablet/laptop.
nathanasmith··on Windows Phone is dead
> I really think this is the future of computing. I mean why bother having a desktop or laptop if you can use your personal device, plug it into different things and get the full experience as if you had a laptop or desktop?

And when you need to make or receive a call? Pull out the bluetooth earpiece (yet another fiddly thing to carry around)? I'd rather just have a tablet and a phone and I think most people would agree.

nathanasmith··on Bilingual people are twice as likely to recover from a stroke, study finds
I'm in Florida now but I did live in Atlanta for a few years and, if pushed, yo puedo hablar espanol suficiente para un conversacion simple. La problema es que no tengo oportunidad para bastante practica para fluente. So, I'm kind of in this half and half limbo where I can understand and speak enough Spanish but not enough that any native Spanish speaker would actually want to have a conversation with me. And for the other person who brought up the buying and selling to Spanish speakers aspect, the vast vast majority of Spanish speakers I've ever came in contact with speak a hell of a lot better English than I speak Spanish so that doesn't really make sense in practice either.
nathanasmith··on Bilingual people are twice as likely to recover from a stroke, study finds
As a native English speaker, born and raised in the US, it is a lament of mine that I can't justify the enormous time and effort needed to become bilingual. I guess I could learn Spanish, but why? It would be primarily recreational. And the time spent could almost certainly be more productively used picking up some other useful skill. Maybe I should just do it anyway in light of the more abstract benefits that the article touts.
nathanasmith··on How we cracked millions of Ashley Madison passwords
Could be. Cynosure is also a noun denoting something that attracts attention through brilliance.
nathanasmith··on Ask HN: Do you take anti-depressants?
I was on Prozac for a few months and while it did reduce anxiety, the effect was fairly mild. The problem was that it destroyed my sex drive. Even worse because of the way it hammers down on emotional extremes, I even started questioning my relationship with my girlfriend like I didn't care one way or the other about her. I stopped using it and went back to depressed normalcy within 3 weeks. That was when I decided to try cardio and dietary improvements. After a month of that, I felt less depressed than ever and haven't looked back.
nathanasmith··on Ask HN: What are your note-taking techniques?
http://ankisrs.net

The number one problem with note taking for me is keeping track of all the notes. In the past, I'd make all these great notes with Zim then never read them. With anki and spaced repetition, that problem is solved. When the memory of the note is on the verge of decaying, anki reminds me, keeping it fresh.

Anki has a web, android, Windows, Mac, Linux, and iOS client, it features online syncing, supports html markup and has extensions support with python. Works for me!

← PreviousPage 9 of 9