HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mtgp1000

43 karma · joined June 14, 2020

submissionscomments
mtgp1000··on Smokers quit in record numbers amid Covid fears
There's no proof of that. In fact there's still no proof to my knowledge that nicotine itself is harmful - to the contrary, it may have neuroprotective properties.
mtgp1000··on Co-founder of Gokada found decapitated, dismembered inside New York condo
The noise and evidence of a broken window acts as a strong deterrent - as well as a warning system to those inside. Using a stolen/copied/fabricated key is comparatively silent.
mtgp1000··on Orthodox Privilege
>but had a hefty implied message

There used to be a word for this as well; we called it "putting words in other people's mouth".

One can criticize aspects of a movement without being against the whole movement, or the people in the movement.

>one which is rightly considered offensive to most of modern society

What hubris.

mtgp1000··on German court bans Tesla ad statements related to autonomous driving
Counterpoint: Elon Musk is the only (publicly visible) CEO who is seriously talking about going to Mars and direct interfacing between machines and humans and making tangible steps toward these futuristic goals.

His rockets are [mostly] not exploding, his cars are selling to [mostly] good reviews, and neuralink seems to be doing something too.

Perhaps his cult of personality is deserved because although he (along with basically the entire industry) overpromised on self driving timelines, nonetheless he does seem to be one of the few people with the practical vision to take us into a techno future.

Consider that this guy went from a payment processing app to a bonafide private rocket company and is democratizing space flight (and satellite internet!) in what, about a decade?

People love to hate the guy, I believe because he has brash and harbors some unpopular (callous but rational) opinions. Regardless, the respect that he gets from his fanboys is arguably in deserved, if you're the type to find inspiration in great people.

mtgp1000··on Resignation Letter
It appears that there is a higher than usual proportion of negatively scored comments ITT. I think that might say something about the so called silent majority - the very people who are [rightly] unwilling to comment publicly because of the cancel culture highlighted in the article.

Those people are here, anonymous votes give them a voice that they are socially being denied.

mtgp1000··on I Know What You Download on BitTorrent
I believe it was Comcast who was performing payload injection (possibly over https with cert fuckery) a few years ago to display warning overlays that you've been caught torrenting.

That was egregious.

mtgp1000··on Deschooling Society (1970)
>This is an encultured attitude, not an innate one

The only encultured attitude I see here is the modern western delusion that the average child (or person) intrinsically wants to make the substantial, multi year effort required to learn complex subjects.

The vast majority of people do not enjoy learning. No one wants to spend their time on math problems (outside of a tiny minority).

This is also tied to the nonsensical idea that we are all equally capable of everything; the ability to learn (both in general and by specific subject) is randomly distributed and probably normally so like many biological processes. That itself ensures that given equal curiosity, not all children will make the varied effort required to learn.

mtgp1000··on SAS Rescue 3 Trapped British Diplomats in Albania
They may have transitioned from communism, but communism leaves psychological scars (or rather adaptations) which are passed on for generations through culture. The nature of authoritarian socialism is such that it breeds mistrust and selfishness in private.
mtgp1000··on How companies became addicted to debt
A growing number of netizens are starting to believe that we are already living in an American Weimar Republic. And it's hard not to see the many social and political parallels - I'm not familiar with the economic side of Weimar Germany.
mtgp1000··on PG: The biggest source of stress for me at YC was running HN
As someone who occasionally has run-ins with mods, I have to remark that moderation as of late has been quite welcoming to "dissenting" opinion, exceptionally so given current events.

Thank you, dang, you have shepherded a glimmering institution among a sea of rough.

mtgp1000··on Quibi reportedly lost 90 percent of early users after their free trials expired
I hadn't heard of this service until just now but I worry that it is another volley against the consumer in the war on the attention span.

It can't be good for individuals or our collective to consume all of our media in short, predigested clips (or posts, or comments). I genuinely believe that the average capacity for "long running" thoughts (and general idea complexity) is being eroded.

All of our media seems to be

mtgp1000··on African tech workers push back on U.S. startup built to help them
On the other hand they're investing in Africa where I don't believe anyone else is. I don't think opportunities for Africans to learn/practice software development in their native country are very common. Moreover while their salary is low compared to western devs, it's still (apparently? Article not clear) high for Africa, where wealth inequality is extreme, mind you, so their "low" salary probably goes a really long way. I imagine they also hire inexperienced workers, so this sounds like a legit opportunity depending on what they're doing.

I suppose the crime here is misleading investors as to the proportion of funds that go to salary...but I don't know what they're doing with the money, and unfortunately they might be passing on more of it than some popular charities.

Article needs work perhaps.

mtgp1000··on Chicago Police Department shuts down its arrest API
It's purpose is to presume innocence, a tenet which seems to be rapidly fading from society.
mtgp1000··on The Bitter Lesson (2019)
>We want AI agents that can discover like we can, not which contain what we have discovered. Building in our discoveries only makes it harder to see how the discovering process can be done.

I think these lessons are less appropriate as our hardware and our understanding of neural networks improve. An agent which is able to [self] learn complex probabilistic relationships between inputs and outputs (i.e. heuristics) requires a minimum complexity/performance, both in hardware and neural network design, before any sort of useful[self] learning is possible. We've only recently crossed that threshold (5-10 years ago)

>The biggest lesson that can be read from 70 years of AI research is that general methods that leverage computation are ultimately the most effective, and by a large margin

Admittedly, I'm not quite sure of the author's point. They seem to indicate that there is a trade-off between spending time optimizing the architecture and baking in human knowledge.

If that's the case, I would argue that there is an impending perspective shift in the field of ML, wherein "human knowledge" is not something to hardcode explicitly, but instead is implicitly delivered through a combination of appropriate data curation and design of neural networks which are primed to learn certain relationships.

That's the future and we're just collectively starting down that path - it will take some time for the relevant human knowledge to accumulate.

mtgp1000··on The Bitter Lesson (2019)
>But, rather than an irrelevant "bitter" lesson about how big machines can perfom more computations than a human, a really useful lesson -and one that we haven't yet learned, as a field- is why humans can do so well without search

I think the answer is heuristics based on priors(e.g. board state), which we've demonstrated (with alphago and derivatives, especially alphago zero) that neural networks are readily able to learn.

This is why I get the impression that modern neural networks are quickly approaching humanlike reasoning - once you figure out how to

(1) encode (or train) heuristics and

(2) encode relationships between concepts in a manner which preserves a sort of topology (think for example of a graph where nodes represent generic ideas)

You're well on your way to artificial general reasoning - the only remaining question becomes one of hardware (compute, memory, and/or efficiency of architecture).

mtgp1000··on Chicago Police Department shuts down its arrest API
Are you suggesting that media are pro-police right now? After nearly universally coming out in support of the current protests?

What term would you prefer? One that does not presume innocence?

mtgp1000··on U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native American reservation
>all their varying climates causing different socioeconomic structures to emerge

Which supports my point, that trying to view native practices through modern concepts is a bit like forcing a square peg through a round hole.

>One of the reasons that many continue to think that aboriginal Americans had no concept of private property, however, is because many tribes did regard land as being communally owned. Carl Watner explores the topic in The Journal of Libertarian Studies

The article seems to conflate "private property" with land ownership. Even this particular paragraph speaks of "communal ownership" which isn't quite the same as the concept of ownership in modern US law, though there are certainly provisions for group ownership.

Point is that article only supports what I'm saying, that it's borderline slanderous to assign morality to the behavior of cultures from 300+ years ago according to modern laws and ideas. Regarding this discussion, "theft" certainly becomes a strong word when you consider how different (and heterogeneous) concepts and practices were back then.

mtgp1000··on U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native American reservation
How do you think warring tribes treated each other? You are aware that some proportion of native tribes kept both native and black (and probably white to a lesser extent) slaves, right?

It's also interesting that you choose the word "theft" as though the natives even had a concept for land ownership. Seems people are too eager to view history through a modern moral lense these days.

mtgp1000··on Robinhood has lured young traders, sometimes with devastating results
This reads like a series of increasingly terrible decisions.

I don't have access to the full article but if they are laying the case for having Robinhood regulated (as I suspect) then I'd say what's even more unfair is preventing responsible people from having nice things because irresponsible people can't be trusted not to hurt themselves, or understand the risks they're taking.

Granted, that bit about gamefication does concern me, it's sort of dopamine abuse - I'd argue to an extent it's a dark pattern, just like frequent unsolicited attention grabbing notifications from other apps to encourage use.

mtgp1000··on MIT and Harvard file suit against new ICE regulations
If they're non-citizens what does it matter to them if they break the lease?
mtgp1000··on Don’t ask if artificial intelligence is good or fair, ask how it shifts power
>In my view, those who work in AI need to elevate those who have been excluded from shaping it, and doing so will require them to restrict relationships with powerful institutions that benefit from monitoring people.

I am not going to choose who I work with based on their race/sexuality/gender.

>Researchers should listen to, amplify, cite and collaborate with communities that have borne the brunt of surveillance: often women, people who are Black, Indigenous, LGBT+, poor or disabled.

Right, we know, only privileged straight white men escape the clutches of surveillance.

All these ideologues are doing is setting the stage for the marginalization of whites, a global minority and soon to be minority majority in the US. I can't believe this kind of casual discrimination has not only been normalized, but is openly and explicitly encouraged.

This is not ok.

Edit: you know, the same way that it takes generations to build wealth, it takes generations to build knowledge, especially institutional knowledge. If we just hand over a chunk of our industries to people because of their identities, by definition we will be even less of a meritocracy - and that's bad for all of society.

mtgp1000··on Sweden: higher Covid-19 death rate while failing to collect on economic gains
Handwashing practices, physical greetings (kissing in some cultures), sharing of eating utensils, personal space, city density; There's no reason to expect R0 values to be the same all over the world.
mtgp1000··on A Letter on Justice and Open Debate
How about we start with the blatantly racist assumption that I'm white? And the fact that such behavior is being normalized by BLM and allies, and I'm being held hostage for not going along with a movement which I believe is about to set race relations back by a hundred years?

This isn't about me. This is about the country running off a cliff. And it's the fact that I'm not even allowed to question your presumptions about how the system benefits whites at the expense of blacks - which is statistically unsupported, but that's beside my point.

Again, it's the fact that I risk being unpersoned for even bringing it up.

mtgp1000··on A Letter on Justice and Open Debate
The people downvoting you were clearly not watching the streams of protestors chanting and screaming into megaphones. The rhetoric was consistent across the country.

The premise is that the system is white supremacist in nature and must be torn down. From there it is implied that if you do not support tearing down the system, you are a white supremacist. And what do we do to white supremacists?

Except the vast majority of people who are iffy about what's going on aren't supremacists of any sort. The word "racist" is quickly losing effect.

Politics might not be 1 dimensional, but pendulums are.

mtgp1000··on A Letter on Justice and Open Debate
Have you been paying attention to what BLM has been saying?

What do you expect these people to feel when they are being accused openly of white supremacy and Nazism, simply for not going along with leftist politics? That's a unilateral carte blanche to be violent. Punching Nazis is great but it's a serious problem when you are far too loose with labels, as we've been watching. Silence is violence, right?

I assure you that the millions of non-white immigrants who [reluctantly] lean towards Trump are not white supremacists - but all it takes is a single accusation to literally ruin a life. When that is the status quo, it isn't surprising to hear people say that they are voting right like "their life depends on it" because it increasingly seems to.

Regardless of the justification, you cannot deny that BLM are presently the aggressors, openly rallying to explicitly subvert US institutions. Not everyone has to agree with the culmination of the long march through the institutions.

mtgp1000··on A Letter on Justice and Open Debate
TD is not far right. 4chan is "far right". 8chan is "far right". But there are regular far left threads on chans advocating for all kinds of radicalism (including violence) as well as making legitimate talking points - no one gets banned, even though the sites primarily lean right.

The only "side" interested in actual free speech currently is the "far right", unlike left leaning forums and media outlets which explicitly censor one particular point of view, regardless of whether it is backed by legitimate science which should be open to discussion.

Censorship has undeniably become a leftist problem, if you insist on reducing the high dimensional space of political leanings to a single myopic dimension. Unbelievable that in 2020 people are shamed for going to the last places on the internet where discourse is unrestricted.

mtgp1000··on A Letter on Justice and Open Debate
There are discussion websites other than reddit...

Also calling the_donald "far right" really indicates the bias of discourse online. Which is part of the problem - people are deliberately loose with language and netizens (at least on reddit) truly believe that Nazis have taken over the Republican party...

mtgp1000··on A Letter on Justice and Open Debate
>While we have come to expect this on the radical right, censoriousness is also spreading more widely in our culture

The "radical right" enclaves on the internet are literally the only places where you won't be banned for not falling in line.

We need to have this discussion in more than one dimension. Left/right and authoritarian/anarchist are orthogonal metrics.

mtgp1000··on Palantir Announces Confidential Submission of Draft S-1
I don't know anything about the legitimacy of this IPO, but if they have a competent ML team, then what terrible things they can do with their data are [unfortunately] worth killing for if you're an authoritarian government.
mtgp1000··on San Francisco most intensely gentrified city in new rankings
I read a few paragraphs and this seems to be a good source for what I'm describing. As usual, the road to hell is paved with good intentions.

https://fee.org/articles/how-the-federal-government-created-...

← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →