221 karma · joined October 27, 2017
Folks are already using disjoint L3 address spaces with elements like load balancers providing the bridge between the public IP space and their own private IP space. I don't know if you could ever sell me on having more than one "main" IP space though, as I don't entirely understand what purpose that would serve, other than massively complicating the process of understanding what it is you are purchasing connectivity to.
See also RFC 1925, particularly sections 2.6a, and perhaps 2.11 :p
> The April issue of the journal Antitrust Chronicle, edited by Mr. Medvedovsky, features a drawing of a bearded man on the cover right above the words “Hipster Antitrust.” In the middle of an ... there’s a photograph of a bearded man taking a selfie next to the chapter heading “Battle of the Beards.” It is perhaps relevant that only one of the 12 authors or experts in the issue is female. > The Hipster issue was sponsored by Facebook, another sign that Big Tech is striving to shape the monopoly-law debate. The company declined to comment.
Interesting. I'm annoyed that the article moved on well enough for me to come post a comment on the comment that stuck out like a sore thumb.
So we are just presuming sexism? OK David Streitfeld, I immediately trust you and believe that all critics of her paper are evil dudes who just hate women. Oh look, we are moving on from that point immediately to dive into her back story and not backing it up with anything. Guess I'll just have to take your word for it that her critics disagreed with her instead of her work.
This is done not just to preserve end destination, but so every sequential packet in a flow follows the same path, thus must arrive in the same order. (Different paths have different latencies because of distance and buffer depth on the routers.) Many tcp implementations will back way off as soon as they see out of order packets, so network providers must do this.
AS, standing for Autonomous System, is like an ISP's name. BGP spreads routing information by rumor. For example, I start the rumor that I can route to IP addresses in 1.2.3.0/24, and tell my peer ISPs. They tell their peers I told them... etc. To prevent rumors from going in circles, you keep a record of every ISP in the path of spreading the rumor, and call it the AS path. (Otherwise you could never retract the rumor, as it would go in circles. BGP speakers do not accept rumors that they themselves are in the path of. (Except in cases of dirty hacks, but then only a finite number of times.))
This article describes fraudulent AS paths attached to (as I understood it) IP ranges that were legitimately owned by the people advertising them to Hurricane Electric. This is like you telling Hurricane Electric that I (the North Korean ISP) told you that I can route to 1.2.3.0/24, an IP address range you own, even though I told you no such thing and we are not even peers.