It'd be worthwhile to invest in a skill you (hopefully) use for everything: decision making.
A good follow up to Managing Oneself, which it sounds like you've read, is Decisive: How to Make Better Choices in Life and Work by Chip and Dan Heath. To borrow a few direct example questions that might help you answer your own: What are some non-technical skills that would improve your next 10 minutes in life? What about the next 10 months, and subsequently the next 10 years? Imagine the tables are turned, and you are trying to provide the same advice to your best friend who happens to be in your same exact position. How would you advise them? If you could no longer do what you are currently doing, what else would you pick?
Between not knowing you, and having little information to go off, take this with a very fine grain of salt: from the strengths you outlined, especially the needing to believe in it attribute (aka aligned values) coupled with extroversion, you may be well suited for some sort of evangelism role. Maybe begin thinking about your core values and from a macro perspective what is it that you care about most. There are many organizations trying to do good and nearly all of them could benefit from a louder voice.