HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

llm_trw

3,929 karma · joined February 12, 2024

omni_vision_ai@proton.me
submissionscomments
llm_trw··on Grok 3: Another win for the bitter lesson
Do you know what places people who are interested in research congregate at? Every forum, meet up or journal gets overwhelmed by bullshit with a year of being good.
llm_trw··on Grok 3: Another win for the bitter lesson
If the bitter lesson were true we'd be getting sota results out of two layer neural networks using tanh as activation functions.

It's a lazy blog post that should be thrown out after a minute of thought by anyone in the field.

llm_trw··on Tensor evolution: A framework for fast tensor computations using recurrences
Anyone working on deep learning for one.
llm_trw··on Grok3 Launch [video]
With salaries like that it's not first world either.

If op is trying to catch up to frontier models locally on a budget 1/5th of what you can get in the west then I can see why she would feel the way she does about Ai.

llm_trw··on Grok3 Launch [video]
$5000 monthly salary?

My heart goes out to all the oppressed programmers in the EU.

llm_trw··on Grok3 Launch [video]
To quote Marx on the current churn in the US government:

>The bourgeoisie cannot exist without constantly revolutionising the instruments of production, and thereby the relations of production, and with them the whole relations of society. Conservation of the old modes of production in unaltered form, was, on the contrary, the first condition of existence for all earlier industrial classes. Constant revolutionising of production, uninterrupted disturbance of all social conditions, everlasting uncertainty and agitation distinguish the bourgeois epoch from all earlier ones. All fixed, fast-frozen relations, with their train of ancient and venerable prejudices and opinions, are swept away, all new-formed ones become antiquated before they can ossify. All that is solid melts into air, all that is holy is profaned, and man is at last compelled to face with sober senses his real conditions of life, and his relations with his kind.

LLM training—and the massive (potential) copyright infringement that everyone is engaging in to train these models—is the latest contradiction in capitalism. For the first time in my lifetime, this contradiction isn’t harming the workers but is instead affecting a segment of the capitalist class.

Not since the abolition of slavery has one class of capitalists required the destruction of another to modernize the means of production.

We are in for an interesting decade.

llm_trw··on Grok3 Launch [video]
Because the difference between a model that costs 10 million to train and a model that costs 10 billion to train is 6 months.

Deepseek R1 is something that you can run in a garage on hardware that the average software engineer can buy with a months salary and when it came out last month it was better than _every_ other model.

llm_trw··on The Joy of Nand2Tetris
Read chapter 5 of SICP.

Whenever I talk to people who rave about SICP I get the feeling they never made it to chapter 4 and beyond.

> In this chapter we will describe processes in terms of the step-by-step operation of a traditional computer. Such a computer, or register machine, sequentially executes instructions that manipulate the contents of a fixed set of storage elements called registers. A typical register-machine instruction applies a primitive operation to the contents of some registers and assigns the result to another register. Our descriptions of processes executed by register machines will look very much like ``machine-language'' programs for traditional computers.

https://mitp-content-server.mit.edu/books/content/sectbyfn/b...

The transistor level simulation happens in 3.3.4 "A Simulator for Digital Circuits".

llm_trw··on Grok3 Launch [video]
An algorithm with no idea of what abstraction even means.
llm_trw··on What will happen if you do an entire woodworking project using a VR headset? [video]
That's not something AR headsets do.

That is a arbitrary object detection problem, which is in general harder to solve than just using an ips.

llm_trw··on What will happen if you do an entire woodworking project using a VR headset? [video]
Finding tools requires an indoor positioning system which is somewhat different to vr headset.
llm_trw··on Grok3 Launch [video]
You make the start of a good point, but miss most of it.

You can absolutely have open source machine code.

The issue is and always has been that you need to have access to the same level of abstraction as the people writing the source code. The GPL specifically bans transpilers as a way to get around this.

In ML there is _no_ level of abstraction other than the raw weights. Everything else is support machinery no different to an compiler, and os, or a physical computer to run the code on.

Linux isn't closed source because they don't ship a C compiler with their code. Why should llama models be any different?

llm_trw··on Grok3 Launch [video]
Linux doesn't ship a compiler or CPU when you download it. It's not open source I guess.
llm_trw··on Grok3 Launch [video]
An llm isn't software any more than a matrix is.

What do you think an open source matrix should look like?

llm_trw··on Grok3 Launch [video]
Without seeing the context window you have no idea what the Ai was working on. It could have literally been told to mock and belittle "the information" in every reply. Something that deepseek r1 is exceedingly good at.

Mr Musk, we can't afford a shitpost gap between communist and capitalist AIs!

llm_trw··on Grok3 Launch [video]
It did give us racially diverse Nazis though. Not sure if grok would do that.
llm_trw··on The Joy of Nand2Tetris
Structure and interpretation of computer programs is a better nand2tertis. The issue is that it contains about 10x the information, assumes what an undergrad science student in 1980 would have known, has problems that are entire chapters of nand2tertis and uses scheme.

And it's not until the end of the last chapter that you build a stack machine in about 40 pages from memory.

llm_trw··on Show HN: Letting LLMs Run a Debugger
Probably. You don't know until someone tries.
llm_trw··on A decade later, a decade lost (2024)
Just remember than not a century ago the average family would bury half their kids.
llm_trw··on We were wrong about GPUs
> If the cost of an easily managed solution is low enough

Because vertical scaling is now large enough that I can run all of twitter/amazon on one single large server. And if I'm wrong now, in a decade I won't be.

Compute power grows exponentially, but business requirements do not.

llm_trw··on We are the "thin blue line" that is trying to keep the code high quality
Then it means the rust code does impact the C code and the rust people were lying.
llm_trw··on OCR4all
It works better than those apps when you know what you are doing.

Not everything needs to be made for a chimp.

llm_trw··on We are the "thin blue line" that is trying to keep the code high quality
Explain what the point is.

Rust developers are promising that rust in the kernel should have no impact on c in the kernel.

If rust in the kernel has no impact in c then you should be able to remove the rust from the kernel and move it to it's own project, since it will have no impact on the c either way.

llm_trw··on We are the "thin blue line" that is trying to keep the code high quality
What extra effort? If you match upstream it's a drop in replacement and anyone who cares will use it. If they don't it's because they don't care.
llm_trw··on OCR4all
Tesseract has had a near 100% success rate since the first time I used it in 2008 _when you read the manual_.

Black letters on white background, xheight of between 10 to 30 px, tiff format, mono column layout, etc., etc., etc..

People get terrible results because they treat it like a phone app and drop a barely legible colored jpg of a bent page and wonder why it's garbage.

llm_trw··on We are the "thin blue line" that is trying to keep the code high quality
What I don't get is the complaints from the Rust people.

If Rust truly is zero overhead on the C side of things then they should be just able to fork Linux indefinitely without any worry about what upstream does. Just fast forward every change and you're golden.

Then they can write every driver they can imagine to their hearts' content.

The fact they aren't doing this tells me that the promise that this won't impact C people at all isn't much of one.

llm_trw··on We are the "thin blue line" that is trying to keep the code high quality
>Noone's asking the maintainers to make the project happen.

If you're asking them to accept your code then yes, you' are asking them to support your project forever.

If you weren't sending them patches then they couldn't block you. Since you are they can.

Again, it's not their job to support this great idea you have that means they have to change how they've done everything for the last 30 years.

llm_trw··on We are the "thin blue line" that is trying to keep the code high quality
It's not the maintainers job to make your project happen.

It's yours.

If you need someone to do free work but you can't convince them then you either get their boss to tell them to do it, you take over their job, or - the one thing that no one under 30 ever seems to do - fork and do the work yourself without anyone stopping you.

llm_trw··on The OBS Project is threatening Fedora Linux with legal action
Hey remember that time that Sam Altman got fired, started a mutiny, then took over and ~executed~ fired everyone who stood against him?

Crazy how much drama happens in open projects like openAI.

llm_trw··on Resigning as Asahi Linux project lead
Personally I'd go with the "biggest worries graph" for an explanation as to why I avoid rust like the plague. If you have half of all respondents say that it's not used enough the corollary they seem to have derived is "let's force it everywhere so it does get used more". Meanwhile forth people are hacking away on building a gui in 300 bytes in a mailing list open since the 80s.

I know which of the two languages was easier and more pleasant to hire for - which should be impossible as I kept getting told no one uses forth.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →