HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jstanley

23,184 karma · joined May 5, 2012

James Stanley

james@incoherency.co.uk

https://incoherency.co.uk/

submissionscomments
jstanley··on Quebec town recognizes trees as living beings with rights
Are they definitely the same people?
jstanley··on "Fix" MacBook Neo Cursor Lag: Record 1 Pixel of the Screen Every 10 Seconds
But wouldn't the software cursor operations also go in the queue? I don't see the problem.
jstanley··on The deadly rise of giant trucks and SUVs
Complete indifference to the implication that I am in some way responsible for crimes committed by others just because I use a similar tool.
jstanley··on The deadly rise of giant trucks and SUVs
Complete indifference.

That's the same class of argument as telling people they shouldn't use Signal because criminals use Signal.

jstanley··on Plotnine
And how do you express that as arithmetic?

I can get as far as `plot() / 3` but then no idea how to proceed. I don't think overloading arithmetic is a very good way to express this.

jstanley··on Plotnine
Using operator overloading of "+" to configure the plot is... a choice.
jstanley··on Show HN: Teach your kids perfect pitch
This could do with a bit more explanation.

It makes a noise and then has buttons labelled red, blue, and yellow. How am I supposed to know what colour that sound was? Do sounds naturally have associated colours? Is this even the question I'm being asked? It doesn't say what to do or how I am meant to choose the colour.

EDIT: From some trial and error, I still don't get it. It seemed to me that blue was the low tone and red was the high tone but then I got a tone that was definitely lower than a previous yellow tone and it was supposedly blue. Potentially a bug?

jstanley··on AI Engineer Claims to Have Cracked Linear A
Promoting your friends' work is hardly stealing their thunder. It's increasing their thunder!
jstanley··on How many of the 170k English words do you know?
Cool idea, am working through.

It's annoying that you need to click 3 times per question, and the buttons are in 2 different places.

Maybe would be better to just let me click the answer I want and then instantly show me the next question?

Also who is Sandi?

jstanley··on Ice water drowning survival of young patient (2025)
The experience could easily run the other way around, you are doing the same thing you criticise.
jstanley··on The Australian Government to Require SMS/MMS Sender ID Registraion
Showing workers of companies other than Microsoft as Microsoft on caller ID is a phishing risk.
jstanley··on Volkswagen started blocking GrapheneOS users
They can always drive less frequently or more slowly, that's within their power.
jstanley··on Volkswagen started blocking GrapheneOS users
The emissions scandal is completely different, because in that case they were illicitly making the car work better for its owner.
jstanley··on Stop Using JWTs
How can you provide a stateless logout (that invalidates credentials rather than simply forgetting them client side)?
jstanley··on GrapheneOS has been ported to Android 17
Why does it need its own F-droid repo?
jstanley··on Running local models is good now
But how smart is it? All the people running local models never seem to mention that they are way dumber than cloud models.

I don't care how many tokens per second of nonsense it can generate.

jstanley··on Peopleless economy? Not technically impossible
Approximately, yes.

In a sense all this communication is "for somebody". But do you know all the communication your laptop is doing? Do you really claim it is all for you, or all for your benefit? Or is it just something the laptop does that isn't really for anyone in particular?

jstanley··on Peopleless economy? Not technically impossible
I was imagining that the bulk of traffic was things like docker image layers etc. being sent around incidentally but not actually looked at by humans. Things that are to do with the running of the systems rather than directly for human consumption.

Or web pages serving megabytes of Javascript code to display kilobytes of text.

You may be right that most of the bytes are video however.

Still you must agree that there is some level of communication that is not directly for humans, and that the proportion that is not for humans is increasing?

And the same could easily be true or economic activity. Maybe there is some supposed human benefit at some point in the chain of causation, but it can be so far away that no human actually knows or cares.

jstanley··on Peopleless economy? Not technically impossible
That's like asking of the Internet "communication for whom?"

The vast majority of bytes sent over the internet are neither from nor to a human writer or reader.

It turns out that humans are not a necessary component in communication, although that proposition would have sounded very weird even 50 years ago.

Why is it so hard to imagine that humans may not be a necessary component in the economy?

jstanley··on Weave: Merging based on language structure and not lines
People will very often say they "had to" do something, when in reality they merely "chose to" do that thing.
jstanley··on Every Frame Perfect
I think this is actually a perfect example. The animations make it more complicated to follow, not less! If it just highlighted the stuff you were hovered over it would be easy to understand, I honestly don't get the motivation behind the animation.
jstanley··on Every Frame Perfect
True in 3d CAD when switching between work planes. I can't think of another application.
jstanley··on A low-carbon computing platform from your retired phones
They're not useful as phones, because the battery, screen, radio, etc. are damaged; but they may still have a working CPU inside, which would be sufficient for this project.
jstanley··on Twenty One Zero-Days in FFmpeg
Some of the ffmpeg developers were on Lex Fridman's podcast recently, and the topic of security came up.

They were talking about how there was a vulnerability in an extremely niche codec that is only used for one video game from the 90s or something, and were saying that the person who reported the vulnerability was acting like it was a big deal but it's really not because this codec is hardly ever used.

I was left wondering whether they were oblivious to the fact that an attacker who can supply a video file to you is free to use whatever video codec they want? It wouldn't matter if the developers thought the codec was never used at all; if it is still available then an attacker can use it.

Or was I just missing something? Is there a good reason why vulnerabilities in this codec are not a big deal after all?

jstanley··on The Alchemist of Flesh: The Man Who Turned Humans into Stone(2025)
A long and rambling article with lots of nagging popups, about a potentially interesting subject.

Wikipedia has a summary: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Girolamo_Segato

jstanley··on A jacket that harvests drinking water from the air
But couldn't someone copy out the mere listing of ingredients anyway?
jstanley··on Pokémon Go Scans Trained the Navigation Tech for Military Drones
If making holes in things that didn't have holes in them before is a sufficient condition for "violence", does that make drills violent too? Or is that taking words-mean-things too far?

Or perhaps can we accept that it is possible to make holes in things without doing violence, and that an object that can make holes in things is not inherently a violent object even though it would be violent if you made holes in things like people or animals, or in property without permission.

jstanley··on Let's Encrypt bans certificate usage in any US sanctioned territory [pdf]
It may be the case that "most of" their sanctions-related blocks apply only to governments (let's say there are 100 such blocks), while they still disallow usage by persons located in a country or territory that is the target of comprehensive US sanctions (let's say there are 50).
jstanley··on Show HN: Learn from 30 historical figures, open source, nonprofit, self-hosted
I think "echo" is a fine word to use, they're hardly calling them "reincarnations".
jstanley··on Show HN: We post-trained a model that pen tests instead of refusing your code
Which text are you referring to? Because the text in this submission is (at least partly) LLM text.
← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →