967 karma · joined October 20, 2011
Who writes this stuff?
This is the logical consequence of people moving their activities from decentralized, open services (email, IRC, and usenet) where revenues are generated (and cost incurred) at the ISP, to centralized, closed services (Facebook and twitter) where cost, revenue, and control is centralized by the platform owner.
The natural response will be for Google and Facebook to compete (or simply threaten to compete) with residential ISPs, forcing some sort of accommodation by the ISPs, and binding ISPs to the media platforms (Facebook, Google, et. al.) in ways never before seen.
You can expect most people to acknowledge the problem - briefly - and then return to complaining about your solutions.
Basically, if someone takes control of the hardware or software we're hoping that it would still be very difficult to get at the contents of the emails.
For example, suppose that this was implemented on a VPS on some random hosting provider, and I own all of the code on the VPS. The hosting provider could record all email traffic coming into that box, but that problem isn't in scope (and could be addressed with, say, openPGP).