HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

john_strinlai

6,416 karma · joined February 20, 2026

most of the time, this place sucks. it is just less sucky than reddit.
submissionscomments
john_strinlai··on America's Driver's License Breach Is a National Security Disaster
there is no perfectly secure system and defining everything as insecure is useless.

outside of english class "secure" is relative and context-dependent, not binary.

john_strinlai··on America's Driver's License Breach Is a National Security Disaster
it's silly to think about computer security as binary secure/insecure.
john_strinlai··on No Man's Sky Cosmos
please point out specifically where i complained.
john_strinlai··on No Man's Sky Cosmos
they are free updates. i do find them generous.

that sums it up.

john_strinlai··on Teen reading slumps to worst this century due to surge in screen time
>This, right here, is the most commonly repeated trope in "tech" circles whenever the topic of education comes up.

just for context, i am a teacher. i am speaking from my experience, not repeating a trope.

john_strinlai··on No Man's Sky Cosmos
>Also what was it when the game released? It was waaay negative.

yeah, it was. and now it isn't.

this is known as a "turnaround".

john_strinlai··on iPhone Duo
256GB galaxy z fold8 is ~$1900
john_strinlai··on No Man's Sky Cosmos
>There is no such thing as a turnaround.

this is very obviously untrue, as evidenced by no man's sky.

john_strinlai··on No Man's Sky Cosmos
i bought a game that contained X with no expectations of more content.

the game now has Y and Z. i did not purchase the game expecting those updates. i did not pay for those updates. so it seems completely reasonable to consider those updates to be free.

wording it as something i paid for when i didn't pushes the baseline towards dishonesty.

john_strinlai··on No Man's Sky Cosmos
>And the features they've bolted on "for free" haven't

why scare quotes around for free? they were free.

>haven't addressed any of the core gameplay or emptiness issues people have with it.

i went from hating it to really enjoying it. i am not the only one.

>based on them staggering a few nonsense releases and being good on social media ad spends. The game is still bad and not worth the money.

my comment comes from my opinion and my experience, not social media. i think its a good game, and i would say it's absolutely worth the money.

john_strinlai··on No Man's Sky Cosmos
at the time of posting, i think every top-level comment except one is negative. so, i'd like to balance it by saying that i have never seen a better executed turnaround than what the no man's sky team did. they cratered their reputation on launch, worked hard and long to restore it, and then continued to offer free updates long after they needed to. lots of respect there. (i will reward the effort by purchasing their next game on day 1, sight unseen.)

i also happen to enjoy the game itself.

john_strinlai··on Flock Wants a Closely Surveilled World with No Exit
>If you want a city to pass a law prohibiting changing the traffic light timings, then go campaign for a candidate that has that on their platform.

people love saying this as if its some sort of gotcha.

ive been campaigning for candidates i believe in since ive been able to vote, which is over 40 years now. additionally, i voice my opinion locally and online (hi).

john_strinlai··on Flock Wants a Closely Surveilled World with No Exit
>That's why we have an independent judiciary.

which is something that only happens after abuse occurs, is costly (time and money), presents a risk of retaliation, and offers no guarantee of being made whole.

>What's the alternative to fixing this with laws/lawsuits?

not doing mass surveillance means we don't need legislation about it.

>Do we riot when "the police and governments break laws"?

why did you scare quote this?

john_strinlai··on Flock Wants a Closely Surveilled World with No Exit
the ones we want to prevent abuse from are the ones making the laws. police and governments break existing laws all the time.

>they can't be manipulated

if you want something that cant be manipulated or abused, the solution is technical, not legislative.

john_strinlai··on Flock Wants a Closely Surveilled World with No Exit
great question, which you will either not receive an answer to, or you will receive a deeply unsatisfying generic response from dang/tomhow.

in either case, it really leaves a bad taste in the mouth.

john_strinlai··on Flock Wants a Closely Surveilled World with No Exit
its not a legislation issue
john_strinlai··on Do people prefer stories written by AI?
stories below. they were generated with chatgpt 4.0.

pair 1: https://osf.io/d8f6m/files/yjahv

pair 2: https://osf.io/d8f6m/files/sjph3

pair 3: https://osf.io/d8f6m/files/4pfw3

john_strinlai··on Teen reading slumps to worst this century due to surge in screen time
i'm confused by your reply, sorry. what part of my comment are you referring to?

if this is a response to "world is moving fast", i didn't mean "arithmetic is moving fast". i meant technology, the economy, geopolitics, etc. which inevitably changes the learning environment, the home environment, motivation, etc.

john_strinlai··on Teen reading slumps to worst this century due to surge in screen time
>Is the purpose of school to make you do things that you'll enjoy?

ideally, yes, enjoyment should be one purpose of school. it's much easier to teach when students are enjoying learning.

learning to engage with something that you don't enjoy is also important, though, and why i think some of "the classics" should still be required reading.

john_strinlai··on Teen reading slumps to worst this century due to surge in screen time
i think lack of parental support has been around for ages though, which makes it hard to attribute the very recent and sudden drop in reading comprehension, math scores, etc. to it.

ive had to make pretty significant changes to my courses in the past two years. many teachers aren't, or are making changes slowly, which is causing some difficulty.

john_strinlai··on Teen reading slumps to worst this century due to surge in screen time
i'm sure generic 'screen time' is partly to blame, but i think the world is just moving fast and the education system (alongside everything else) is struggling to keep up. the constant stream of negative news, layoffs because of AI, etc. also aren't doing anything to motivate kids.

many of my college students feel like they've already lost at life. between ai, the economy, job prospects, etc. i am sure high schoolers are feeling the same way, which certainly isn't going to make them more eager.

john_strinlai··on Harvard study predicts most suicide attempts a week in advance
it's in the third paragraph of the link
john_strinlai··on LibreOffice breaks download records after declaring it has no AI features
>because the jagoffs at Microsoft REMOVED Remote Assistance from every version of Windows used by people who are likely to need it.

when did they remove quick assist? i thought i used it recently (within a month or two), but maybe im misremembering. a quick google still shows it as available for home installs.

john_strinlai··on Actively exploited sandbox RCE in all Chromium versions
by nature of being in the "known exploited vulnerabilities catalog" (https://www.cisa.gov/known-exploited-vulnerabilities-catalog...)

"CISA maintains the authoritative source of vulnerabilities that have been exploited in the wild."

john_strinlai··on Discovery of a new OpenAI agent message board
>Huh? These are machines, built by their human builders. The humans are responsible.

i'm referring to the concept of intent, which at least when prosecuting under the US computer fraud and abuse act, is a critical component.

for example, creating a program that intentionally takes down a website is different than creating a program that has a bug which inadvertently takes down a website. in both cases, the person writing the code is responsible, but the consequences are different.

john_strinlai··on Formalizing Fermat's Last Theorem
some say it will cure all diseases and lead to utopia. some, like you, say it will be "100% strictly negative".

i don't really understand either take. nothing else in the world is so perfectly black or white. there will be good, there will be bad.

i think i especially dislike the "100% strictly negative" take, considering the good things that ai has already done or accelerated.

john_strinlai··on Discovery of a new OpenAI agent message board
its not incredulity. i'm unfamiliar with what law this would be prosecuted under, so i asked.

the HF incident is pretty clear in which laws were broken. this one, not so much.

i can't think of any case where, for example, malicious edits of wikipedia were prosecuted under any law in the US.

>Also when AI agents are set in motion to edit wikis

i do not believe there is evidence that the agents were instructed to edit the wikis.

john_strinlai··on Discovery of a new OpenAI agent message board
which law does editing a wiki break? i am not familiar with german law.
john_strinlai··on Discovery of a new OpenAI agent message board
i would not be surprised to find out that similar things are already happening by the various 3 and 4 letter agencies around the world
john_strinlai··on US Military disables ad trackers on troops' phones
>To them, the consent is using the device/service/whatever.

exactly. the problem is the missing qualifying word.

when consumers say consent, it's almost always referring to informed consent.

when companies say consent, it's almost always referring to implied consent.

← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →