297 karma · joined May 19, 2013
>All people criticising Aadhar for being insecure frankly don't have a real solution in place.
Criticising something doesn't necessitate me to providing a solution. It's like saying all movie critics should be good actors.
>Being an Indian citizen I know and have experienced benefit owing to Aadhar. I get subsidies from the government, one uniform identity that I can use to get important things.
Sure aadhar might have some benefits for you. But the critique is raising many points which make it incredibly dangerous and harmful in the long run. It's like using steroids to gain muscle faster, which is very harmful in the long term.
>Coming to the security part, which centralised biometric DB doesn't have risks.
Yes and those systems do get criticised so it can be improved. Also, aadhar claims to be open source, open API, run by volunteers, none of which it is. It sells your data to private services. Were you going to address that point at all?
>Mozilla being such a nice organisation with so many good initiatives. Why don't it come forward and dedicate some of its resources in helping out the Indian Government?
Indian government has a lot of resources too. It's not exactly poor. It could do a good job if it wanted to. That's not what this criticism is about.
>Wouldn't that be better than just criticising without knowing any ground reality of how things operate in India?
How do you know the author doesn't know the ground reality of things in India?
Look, criticism of a system or policy serves to ignite debate on how best we can make improvements and move forward. Rather than being snarky and getting all defensive and making silly illogical arguments, how about you contribute to the discussion by addressing the points raised in the article?
>Finally any Indian in USA simply has no right to criticize Aadhar since the US Visa process requires biometrics from all visitors.
This simply doesn't hold any logic. If Aadhar is so good, then it should be able to stand up to any argument based on its merits regardless of where it's coming from. Can you actually present any points against the points being made by Mozilla?
Are you ok with your intimate personal details being sold to private companies? Maybe your son or daughter have a sickness and now all the private companies can know about it. Maybe years from now the collected data will be used to make decisions about whether to admit them into a school or hire them as professionals.
Please think calmly and logically rather than being sensational, egotistical, and personal. Nobody is trying to hurt your "Indian Pride".
For what its worth, they did "disrupt" the economies in question and made the incumbents appreciate the consumer more, but also profited highly from it. Now its time to stop the free lunch and even the playing field.
- We are now allowing Chinese govt' backed companies to acquire Canadian companies that develop advanced military tech. This was banned even under Harper. http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/politics/liberal-green-l...
- Influential chinese are buying up political sway by "donating" to political campaigns: http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/politics/influential-chi...
I don't care about chinese people driving Audis. It's when they come over and treat Canada and Canadians as something that can be bought over, corrupted, and pushed around that frustrates me. And I'm not the only one here.