>Each targets an industry that seems to strip people of their agency and rob them of their dignity. Each seems to hijack healthy behavior with a set of short term incentives whose end results are self destructive and degrading.
>One does not wish to waste a child’s youth away on 18 hours of evening cram school a week, but to do otherwise is to risk falling behind. It is a classic arms race problem: no player can stop the game from the inside, even though all players would benefit from a cap on the game. An outside force is needed to halt the madness. Xi Jinping has decided to be that force.
I feel the author's logic is flawed here. In the previous paragraph, he wrote-
>Xi Jinping is not reigning in capitalism writ large; Beijing is not scrapping market mechanisms altogether. Semiconductor foundries, agricultural conglomerates, and Christmas light factories (to choose three examples of hundreds) have been untouched by Xi’s ‘common prosperity’ agenda. It is a very select slice of Chinese capitalism that is being “reigned in.”
You mean, working in 'agricultural conglomerates' or being factory workers making 50 RMB a day, is not 'hijack healthy behavior with a set of short term incentives whose end results are self destructive and degrading.'? (short term benefit for the factory owners to the detriment of the society and workers.)
The author took a winded way to try to distinguish the reason why certain industries are targeted, but really there is no need- the PRC literally tells you why themselves: 'Fictitious Economy' vs 'Real Economy' .
(https://www.reuters.com/world/china/chinas-cabinet-says-it-w...)
In Xi's eyes, anything that can't be physically grasp and control by the party belongs to 'Fictitious Economy' , hence the move to squash meal delivery (self-organized proto-union), k-pop/entertainment (voluntary idol worship), cram school (corruption and private source of education), and real estate (mass bubble speculation). Real Economy is output that the party can allocate and mobilize. The populace must lie down and accept whatever the party provides.
No need to invoke fancy Marxism philosophies.