HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

firesteelrain

2,202 karma · joined January 27, 2023

submissionscomments
firesteelrain··on What happened to the Snowden archive
Exactly coming from a London-Swedish guy the spewing nonsense is what I should have expected. What business of the US is what we do anyways?
firesteelrain··on GitLab Outage
VMWare Cloud Foundation with Dell R7725s
firesteelrain··on What happened to the Snowden archive
One did. But he was declared a traitor and treasonous. I agree with them.
firesteelrain··on 28% of job postings on company career sites have been open over 90 days
It’s a pipeline requisition or feeder requisition. Sometimes companies will close and refresh it. Can’t rely on job listings alone
firesteelrain··on What happened to the Snowden archive
It’s clear you want the last word with AI help so I’ll let you have it.
firesteelrain··on What happened to the Snowden archive
Well their complaint triggered a formal DoD IG investigation and produced a highly critical audit plus fraud investigations. Trailblazer program was killed in 2006. That all happened well before Snowden. Snowden skipped all of those channels entirely. Binney and Drake were taken seriously but you are glossing over all do the other stuff that Snowden leaked that had nothing to do with the privacy concerns deemed that went beyond what FISA courts authorized (and no court found violation of 4th amendment).

Snowden did it completely wrong and you can’t convince me otherwise. I don’t see this conversation going further as you move the goalposts.

firesteelrain··on What happened to the Snowden archive
That’s not what they said.

They said that Snowden caused a shift in the public debate not that nobody listened to them beforehand (you should know they were raising concerns going back to 2002).

Baltimore Sun was reporting on Drake in 2006. Binney was publicly talking about it to Wired News and Democracy Now in 2012. Snowden happened in 2013.

firesteelrain··on What happened to the Snowden archive
“Snowden talked to the IG” only applies to his conversation with the CIA IG about management and IT. There was no NSA IG complaint about surveillance which contrasts with the others (Binney and Drake that you mentioned). So no he did not even try. Was the Binney and Drake incidents ugly? Yes. But neither are in jail and both still live in the US.

Snowden did it completely the wrong way.

firesteelrain··on What happened to the Snowden archive
You report it to the Inspector General (IG). How are you not familiar with it ? Snowden even talked to them before not about this but something else. He is a traitor. The other stuff he leaked had nothing to do with Americans “privacy concerns”. It was fairly minor
firesteelrain··on What happened to the Snowden archive
You report it to the Inspector General (IG). How are you not familiar with it ? Snowden even talked to them before not about this but something else. He is a traitor. The other stuff he leaked had nothing to do with Americans “privacy concerns”. It was fairly minor
firesteelrain··on What happened to the Snowden archive
There are secure ways to whistleblow inside the org he was in and not to the press and not to Congress itself. He didn’t use those avenues.

He also leaked information that didn’t need to be leaked which had nothing to do with the privacy issues people keep being up (which btw were not ruled to be in violation of the 4th amendment only that they went beyond the FISA approved collection standards)

firesteelrain··on What It's Like to Work in One of America's Data Centers
There is a lot of electrical supply and demand is high plus incentives from Virginia itself and proximity to DC. It’s already a data center dense market
firesteelrain··on What happened to the Snowden archive
Again you are missing the point. Nothing was proven in violation of the 4th amendment. Ninth Circuit didn’t even latch on that argument nor express it. Courts agreed that the metadata collection program went beyond what was approved by the FISA courts. But he leaked a whole host of foreign spying programs that had nothing to do with Americans.
firesteelrain··on What happened to the Snowden archive
GP is implying that Russia is his canonical home because Snowden was acting like a spy
firesteelrain··on What happened to the Snowden archive
He wasn’t being abused.
firesteelrain··on What happened to the Snowden archive
What about leaking secrets of the United States has anything to do with morals? He might as well been a foreign adversary
firesteelrain··on What happened to the Snowden archive
Only one program went beyond what was originally authorized and shutdown. The rest had no basis to be leaked. It caused grave damage to the national security of the US. Those programs had nothing to do with the privacy of American citizens that everyone keeps latching on here. They are ignoring the rest of the stuff
firesteelrain··on Why does mathmain need an encrypted loader?
What is the fix for npm at this point? It has a lot of issues with the registry
firesteelrain··on What happened to the Snowden archive
It’s wasn’t anonymous back then iirc and I wasn’t advocating for leaking anything
firesteelrain··on What happened to the Snowden archive
He leaked WAY more than necessary and didn’t seek out official whistleblower channels. Stuff that didn’t even have to do with US privacy. Say what you want about spying on foreign adversaries but every government does it to another one and that didn’t need to be leaked.
firesteelrain··on What happened to the Snowden archive
It was his choice to leak as himself. He could have used whistleblower routes (which was investigated and he only sent 1 email but never reported it)

Really have to question his motives

firesteelrain··on What happened to the Snowden archive
He could have returned to the US. His citizenship wasn’t revoked.
firesteelrain··on What happened to the Snowden archive
About Russia? Nope.
firesteelrain··on What happened to the Snowden archive
He isn’t deserving of a pardon or exile by the damage he did. But he could have stayed and faced the consequences if the cause was sincere
firesteelrain··on What happened to the Snowden archive
He didn’t have to flee at all
firesteelrain··on What happened to the Snowden archive
There isn’t one under the law so no.

Why wasn’t the whistleblower process followed? Why didn’t he try to contact his congressman/ senator ? He could have said I don’t want a clearance anymore and disclosed his concerns. He could have reported anonymously even.

He wanted public debate and discourse on something that the process didn’t allow

firesteelrain··on What happened to the Snowden archive
The problem is he can’t excuse the offense under the Espionage Act because it doesn’t have a public interest defense. One could argue that it should have that defense. But that doesn’t mean the resulting trial would have been a “muppet trial”

He could have had counsel, challenged the government, and had a jury decide guilt. It would have been fair. It actually looks worse to flee like he did

firesteelrain··on What happened to the Snowden archive
Oh it was very serious what he did. But it was odd he went to Hong Kong then to Russia on his was to Ecuador. It wasn’t well thought out
firesteelrain··on What happened to the Snowden archive
He could have returned to the US. He chose to exile in Russia. He was already fleeing. I posted a bunch about it below
firesteelrain··on What happened to the Snowden archive
He was faced with the possibility of arrest or hoping for full asylum in Russia. It was another calculated gamble. But I don’t agree he was stuck. It was all self created problem. No one forced him to take the circuitous route he took and no one forced him to leak as himself. Could have been private/anonymous. Could have stayed in the US.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →