HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ecb_penguin

221 karma · joined April 4, 2025

submissionscomments
ecb_penguin··on Apple releases open-source model that instantly turns 2D photos into 3D views
Do you think the OSD is law or something?
ecb_penguin··on Apple releases open-source model that instantly turns 2D photos into 3D views
While most people follow the OSD criteria, there is nothing that says open source software must follow it. Nor is the OSD the only set of criteria or the only definition.

Open source means the source is available. Anything else is just political.

ecb_penguin··on Apple releases open-source model that instantly turns 2D photos into 3D views
Training data is not source code so that's irrelevant
ecb_penguin··on The Bob Dylan concert for just one person
> songs like those ARE his usual fare these days

I've seen him recently and those are not his usual fare: https://www.bobdylan.com/setlists/

He played a couple of his most well-known songs, a few off his recent albums, and one or two I didn't know. It was not 1950s covers...

ecb_penguin··on School cell phone bans and student achievement
You're absolutely wrong: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Correlation

> correlation does not imply causation

correlation CAN imply causation. You missed a word making what you said completely wrong.

ecb_penguin··on I wasted years of my life in crypto
> Having transcations on a ledger forever

Do you think cash transactions don't have even more detailed ledgers? The "tried and true fiat" has been used to catch criminals for centuries because banks keep very detailed records of withdraws and deposits.

> You are just repeating

You are just repeating. Obviously both are being used for crime

ecb_penguin··on Have I been Flocked? – Check if your license plate is being watched
Yes of course you do. If you're being stalked, contact your local police department.
ecb_penguin··on School cell phone bans and student achievement
This was controlled for in the study.

I swear sometimes people only exist to look for flaws in studies they didn't read.

ecb_penguin··on School cell phone bans and student achievement
And of course, sometimes a correlation does in fact imply a causation!
ecb_penguin··on NL Judge: Meta must respect user's choice of recommendation system
> Facebook doesn't exist in a free market. It IS a market.

It is a market that exists in the free market.

> And an unfree one ruled by a dictatorship that you can't vote on.

Ok, so don't use that market. You're not entitled to Facebook, or being able to dictate anything.

> That's what platforms are. They're markets. Its not like making a couch or something.

Bud, I am begging you to close your Facebook account and see it is exactly like a couch you don't have to buy.

> It doesn't matter if the other apps are super amazing and they walk your dog and suck your dick and make you live forever. Literally does not matter.

You heard it here. YC is dead. Close up shop. All these investors just wasting their money because you can't vote Zuck out.

> The app, itself, does not matter. Which is why Facebook is allowed to be as shit as humanly possible.

This is just nonsense. You're trying to sound smart by taking an extreme position. Nuance is smart.

ecb_penguin··on NL Judge: Meta must respect user's choice of recommendation system
> For example laws preventing monopolies (government approvals of mergers, for example).

Can you show me the federal code that includes number of customers?

Do you think monopoly rules are about size or behavior? Do you think a small mom and pop store couldn't act in monopolistic practices?

Do you think a small mom and pop store in a rural captured market couldn't price fix?

Hint: It's not size :)

ecb_penguin··on NL Judge: Meta must respect user's choice of recommendation system
> That would be the sensible idea in a free market.

Absolutely nothing stopping you from starting a social network

> But that ship sailed LONG ago.

I'm pretty sure there are hundreds? thousands? of startups ready to launch that all do some variant of FB.

Why are you on YC if you think free market tech is dead?

> But that doesn't mean the same rules and laws applies - or should apply - to one with 1B users as one with 100 users.

lol, what? We have different laws depending on how popular you are? What are the thresholds for when new laws apply? Is it strictly user count? Engagement time? Revenue?

Innovation may be dead in Europe but don't try to bring this nonsense elsewhere.

ecb_penguin··on NL Judge: Meta must respect user's choice of recommendation system
"As a European, I much prefer technological stagnation over bundled messenger apps"

Fixed it for you.

ecb_penguin··on NL Judge: Meta must respect user's choice of recommendation system
It's the European way
ecb_penguin··on NL Judge: Meta must respect user's choice of recommendation system
> Well, I suppose that's one take on it.

It's the correct take. Facebook had 800M users on the day Messenger was released.

> I would argue that people are in the app because Facebook gave out Facebook Messenger

Why would you argue a nonsense point? Literally all you have to do is Google "when was messenger released" and "number of facebook users in August 2011"

Unless you think those 800M users were just waiting for a shitty messenger?

ecb_penguin··on NL Judge: Meta must respect user's choice of recommendation system
> Please for the love of god make it a legal requirement that messaging must be made available as a separate app

Please for the love of god do not make legal requirements about how to build an app and what features can be included.

> We need to be able to message our friends without seeing a feed without having to convert all of our friends to a new platform.

lol, you have no legal right to how a chat dialog must be presented.

Why don't you try innovating instead of suing?

ecb_penguin··on Man jailed for parole violations after refusing to decrypt his Tor node
You are not allowed unauthorized access regardless of how the key works.

> I am allowed to send any traffic I wish to public-facing hosts

No you're not. Denial of service is a federal crime.

> I have no responsibility to refrain

Yes you do, and this is just beyond silly. The nuance of how you obtained it will be decided in a court. Stop making everything so reductionist and lazy.

> The only traffic I am not permitted to send are credentials I am not authorized to use

Absolutely not. Use of a vulnerability to cause a data breach is OBVIOUSLY a federal crime.

This is beyond absurd.

ecb_penguin··on Man jailed for parole violations after refusing to decrypt his Tor node
> Doesn't this posture also criminalize white-hat hackers, whose disclosures would protect you from the people who actually want to do damage?

There is no law for "white-hat hackers". You don't get to break into a system because the color of your hat.

"White-hat hackers" have contracts, or very specific rules of engagement. Having run many a bug bounty, if someone was malicious, we would absolutely work to prosecute.

You can also find bugs in software freely, as long as you don't obtain unauthorized access to other people's systems.

ecb_penguin··on Man jailed for parole violations after refusing to decrypt his Tor node
Because people think they are clever and are trying to separate the act from the intent.

Unlocked doors, open windows, any lack of security doesn't give you permission to enter. Just as "incrementing a GET request" doesn't mean anything outside of the intent.

The intent was to do damage.

ecb_penguin··on React is winning by default and slowing innovation
> How much innovation is needed

Enough to make it worth it to switch, but not so much that it's hard to switch

> often iteration is better and cheaper

Fortunately React has had major changes over its lifetime that iterating with React was/is the better and cheaper solution.

ecb_penguin··on PayPal to support Ethereum and Bitcoin
That is the point! You don't need companies like Paypal... Companies often offer services that are "not needed" because people like convenience, ease of use, etc.

You don't need Paypal to use Bitcoin, but there's nothing in the spec that prohibits it.

ecb_penguin··on New research reveals longevity gains slowing, life expectancy of 100 unlikely
> Do you believe this limit on lifespan is a uniquely human condition

No

> or do you believe that it's impossible for any animal whatsoever to have a long lifespan

Let's pick an arbitrary timeframe and declare that as long

No, I don't think anything is impossible when you pick dates "for the sake of argument"

ecb_penguin··on New research reveals longevity gains slowing, life expectancy of 100 unlikely
> This is perhaps the single worst form of argument I've ever seen.

It's because you didn't understand it

> 'how can a cancer cell live indefinitely but other cells cannot'

Cancer cells are damaged cells mutating without regard for function. It's pretty obvious that there is a difference between "living indefinitely in a mutated form devoid of original function" is different from a cell performing a specific function

ecb_penguin··on New research reveals longevity gains slowing, life expectancy of 100 unlikely
> Did someone prove mice have souls that go to heaven or hell while I wasn't looking?

What does this have to do with a soul? The comment was about people treating life extension as a religion based on faith more than evidence.

Nothing to do with the soul, or heaven, or anything else.

ecb_penguin··on The share of Americans having regular sex keeps dropping
Everything you said was more popular when rates of sex were higher, so clearly your thoughts aren't correct. On top of that, red states that push abstinence only have always had higher rates of teen pregnancy, again suggesting your ideas are not correct. Abstinence only education never stopped anyone.

> The kids in my community are being taught age-appropriate, consent-based sex ed, and the availability of free, high-quality sex ed is improving.

This has been the case in blue states for decades. I had proper sex-ed in the 90s.

ecb_penguin··on AI Is Wrecking Young Americans' Job Prospects
Is someone being forced? Can you call the police?
ecb_penguin··on Ask HN: Why isn't my ISP providing AI as a service?
Really? What does it say?
ecb_penguin··on Ask HN: Why isn't my ISP providing AI as a service?
Can we ban questions like this? Though I recognize this person is a perfect YC candidate by asking why you can't connect a home connection to a rack of GPUs.
ecb_penguin··on Denmark issues first apology over forced contraception of Greenlandic women
It's wild how awful Europeans are. From Irish laundries, Belgians in the Congo, to Dutch South Africa. Now Denmark and Greenlandic women.
ecb_penguin··on AI Is Wrecking Young Americans' Job Prospects
> Ten years ago GenAI couldn't produce two coherent sentences.

Depending on the question, it still can't.

It's kinda crazy how you view repeating probabilistic outputs as "coherent sentences".

> We've come a long way, what makes you think it won't go further?

Where did I say it won't go further? I said it will never produce what they want.

Those are different things.

Regardless, you're focused on the wrong point.

← PreviousPage 2 of 6Next →