HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

duncan_bayne

4,002 karma · joined February 4, 2010

https://duncan.bayne.id.au/
submissionscomments
duncan_bayne··on How to take back control of /etc/resolv.conf on Linux (2018)
I've used it with much success on the ThinkPad X220 and more recently the ThinkPad W540 (the latter of which I dual-boot into Ubuntu).

I'm having a few issues with the docking station on the W540, which I'm currently putting down to the docking station being faulty, as I had no such issues docking the X220.

I plan to test a different docking station in the next few days and see if the glitches go away (USB mouse sometimes needs resetting, and X loses the external monitor until it's restarted).

duncan_bayne··on How to take back control of /etc/resolv.conf on Linux (2018)
To be honest, it's this sort of thing that makes me happy to be back on FreeBSD for everything but gaming and DRM media (hi Spotify).

Sure there's a little more work to get set up (which I've scripted and put in Gitlab, so it's easy the second and subsequent times).

But the documentation is first class (in particular, the FreeBSD Handbook is great), and generally, when you set something up it stays that way.

Reminds me of late 90s / early 2000s GNU/Linux in that regard.

duncan_bayne··on A Saudi prince's attempt to silence critics on Twitter
Anymore?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chappaquiddick_incident

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henry_VIII

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pope_John_XII

Wealth and power have insulated those who possess them from the consequences of their actions since forever.

duncan_bayne··on The Legend of GayBlade
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_Gaytime

Given the intentional double entendre and commercial success - it's now a cultural icon - I'm going to optimistically interpret its existence in a positive light. I mean, I can't imagine this product existing in many (most?) countries at the time.

duncan_bayne··on Is macOS Becoming Unmaintainable?
That's true, but it leaves out the other half of the equation: you'll still likely spend less of your valuable time on your making your Ubuntu installation work, than on anything else (speaking as someone with commercial dev experience on MacOS, Windows, Linux, and FreeBSD).

I spent hours trying to stabilise my wife's XPS13 after a recent Windows Update sent it into paroxysms of BSODs. Reset, reimaged, the whole nine yards: nothing. Ended up installing Ubuntu on it and it's been rock-solid stable since.

duncan_bayne··on Drug cartel assassinates its enemies with bomb-toting drones
Sure but that tends to work against States. Backlash against non-State groups like the PLO and IRA seems less effectual.
duncan_bayne··on Facebook apologizes to users for Apple’s monstrous efforts to protect privacy
The W3C would never ... oh wait ... I remember DRM and EME. Nevermind, yes, of course they'd roll over.
duncan_bayne··on Missions to and Sample Returns from Nearby Interstellar Objects
I'm guessing here, as I've never built a sail-propelled interstellar probe :) But I'm assuming that:

1) The characteristics of a good laser-propelled acceleration sail would be different to those of a good solar-powered braking sail.

2) Flipping around while attached to a deployed solar sail would be hard. In my head I'm imagining something like looping a paraglider (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-oEeTtQIEjs) but much harder. It'd have to be autonomous (no fly-by-wire at those ranges), and for recovery purposes I'd want to have a spare sail anyway that it could deploy in the case the primary got tangled.

duncan_bayne··on Missions to and Sample Returns from Nearby Interstellar Objects
If it was an artifact - especially a discarded solar sail, explaining the acceleration - there might be a follow-up.

Imagine you were making a sail-propelled probe, with the intent of slowing the probe so it was captured by the target system. So the probe would have two sails. The first would be deployed after launch, to catch the initial laser beam, then later solar winds, to accelerate to system escape velocity.

You'd then detach that sail, and cruise. Later, you'd deploy a second sail to start braking on your way into the target system, to slow to capture velocity.

The first thing the inhabitants of the target system would see would be the first, discarded, sail as it tumbled through their system and accelerated back out ...

duncan_bayne··on Missions to and Sample Returns from Nearby Interstellar Objects
It might also be worth leaving artifacts on them, in case of discovery by future spacefaring species - assuming the objects still possessed system escape velocity.

Actually, wouldn't it be a blast if we found signs that someone had done just that already?

duncan_bayne··on Top colleges should select randomly from a pool of ‘good enough’ (2005)
That's true. But, bluntly, and speaking as a member, we don't matter anywhere near as much as the absolute best.

The members of the "upper middle class ticket" group might as well be selected by ballot from the intellectually qualified.

But I'd never suggest that if it in any way imperiled the idenfitifcation and support of the very best and brightest. Which, AFAICT, is exactly what this proposal would do.

duncan_bayne··on Top colleges should select randomly from a pool of ‘good enough’ (2005)
Absolutely. Because we want our doctors and engineers to be just "good enough", none of this elitism for us!

I'm sure they'll still cure cancer and get us to Mars, right?

And the truly elite who miss out by random chance ... that doesn't matter because justice doesn't require us to recognise and appropriately reward genius.

In fact, screw those priviliged geniuses, they're only first in line because they won a genetic lottery right?

/s

duncan_bayne··on The Anti-Capitalist Software License
> Worker coops using the license would be free use

How is a worker co-op using the licensed software for commercial purposes different from, say, a corporation?

duncan_bayne··on The Anti-Capitalist Software License
... which is why it's entirely reasonable for labour to unionise, to increase their bargaining power with employers.

One of the fundamentals of Marxism with which I disagree, though - at such a fundamental level that it drives an emotional response to the license we're discussing - is that paid labour is necessarily exploitation. That is, I consider the labour theory of value to be incorrect.

I'm reminded of the famous Reagan quote:

> How do you tell a Communist? Well, it’s someone who reads Marx and Lenin. And how do you tell an anti-Communist? It’s someone who understands Marx and Lenin."

duncan_bayne··on The Anti-Capitalist Software License
I think you are attracting downvotes because you completely mistook my point.

I support Free software - financially, by evangelising it, by writing it, and by using it.

My point was that I think some large companies are getting a lot more value from their use of it than the authors and maintainers get from working on it.

(Edited to add: I agree wholeheartedly about downvoting vs. replying. I wish more people would reply instead of, or perhaps as well as, downvoting).

duncan_bayne··on The Anti-Capitalist Software License
> when the developer decides you are no longer pure enough

Which will happen. Purity wars in ideological movements are nothing new (and far from limited to the political Left!).

E.g. Orwell was shot during the Spanish Civil War, not by Fascists, but by a different bunch of Communists on whose side he was theoretically fighting.

> You’d have to be insane

Well, this is a Marxist thing, so that box comes pre-ticked.

duncan_bayne··on The Anti-Capitalist Software License
I'm about as pro-capitalist, laissez-faire, pro-free-market as it gets. I was a literal card-carrying member of the LibertariaNZ party back in New Zealand. The spirit of this license disgusts me at a fairly deep emotional level.

That said, I think that this specific concern raised by the license is very real:

> ... If you want your code to empower students, artists, hobbyists, collectives, cooperatives and nonprofits to survive under capitalism while not contributing free labor to corporations.

I've seen a few cases where I think that open source authors and maintainers are getting it in the shorts. Yes there's value - "Egoboo", learning, personal promotion, etc. - but I don't think it's enough in many cases. For example:

* Free software that contributes to the growth and dominance of proprietary, for-profit ecosystems. E.g. I was recently back on Windows for the first time in a decade or so professionally, building an app I'd written in Common Lisp. Scoop (for package management on Windows) and Rosewell (which now supports Windows) made this super easy and pleasant. But ... why would you spend your time writing Free software to benefit such an ecosystem? Unless you're being paid for it, why not spend your time contributing to a Free ecosystem instead?

* Free software that is productised by cloud providers (e.g. https://www.zdnet.com/article/aws-hits-back-at-open-source-s...).

* Companies like Google, who are happy to build upon a plethora of open source products to generate billion-dollar profits, but who then turn around and actively give the middle finger to the communities without which they wouldn't exist (e.g. https://www.theregister.com/2019/04/03/googles_widevine_drm/).

duncan_bayne··on Welders set off Beirut blast while securing explosives
> I'm astonished by the incompetence that's usually going hand in hand with the corruption

I think it follows naturally.

If you replace objective standards of quality with favoritism, bribery, theft, and fraud, then of course you'll attract incompetents like moths to a flame.

duncan_bayne··on Mitochondria may hold keys to anxiety and mental health
Well, I assume that along with her would also be a bunch of genuine cranks, mystics, "skeptics" etc. She'd be collateral damage.

Similar case that springs to mind is the chap who had to infect himself to prove that stomach ulcers were caused by bacteria.

duncan_bayne··on Launch HN: Stacker (YC S20) – Create Apps from Airtable or Google Sheets
Muwhahahahahahahaha.

True client story: I was once required to fill out opex/capex split timesheets into an Excel spreadsheet once a month, for each of my teams.

The spreadsheet came with instructions containing dire warnings that changing the formatting would change the semantic meaning of some of the cells, thereby breaking the spreadsheet for everyone.

I'm pretty sure that the developers of that spreadsheet used cell formatting to encode metadata about the cell values.

duncan_bayne··on The Toxoplasma of Rage (2014)
In what way?

It's not like it's that long to start with.

duncan_bayne··on Firefox push[ing] irrelevant notifications
I gave some thought to switching back when Eich "resigned".

In the end I decided that continuing to support Mozilla by using and advocating for Firefox was the lesser of two evils - the alternative being to surrender to a Web mono-culture.

The deciding factor for me was: what would harm free speech more?

1) a browser duopoly involving an org willing to chuck their CEO under a bus for legitimate but oppressive political donations, or

2) a browser monopoly owned by an advertising company?

In the end I decided (1) was the best bet. But I swear, Mozilla keeps me on my toes reconsidering it :)

duncan_bayne··on Firefox push[ing] irrelevant notifications
Submitter here (and author of one of the bug reports that got merged into this one).

My guess is the downvotes are an expression of the idea that, just because you personally find something relevant, doesn't make it okay for Mozilla to spam ~250 million people with what is essentially political advertising.

duncan_bayne··on Wayland and LVGL on PinePhone with Ubuntu Touch
That's pretty much why I abandoned Ubuntu Touch on my PinePhone, and switched to Mobian.

Feels like running a regular GNU/Linux distro, just on my phone. Much more suited to my purposes.

duncan_bayne··on The personal info of what could be Instacart customers is being sold online
Eh. If someone wants to fire me for chuckling at a bad-taste lawyer joke, I'd rather not work for them anyway ;)
duncan_bayne··on The personal info of what could be Instacart customers is being sold online
> We used to laugh at comments like GPs

Used to? I'm still chuckling.

duncan_bayne··on The FBI is secretly using Sabre as a global travel surveillance tool
> We can fight it by electing the correct people.

No, you can't. Because the people you're allowed to elect are all complicit in the creation and maintenance of these systems.

duncan_bayne··on Samsung Blu-ray players bricked because of an XML config file
> You can't actually break that contract with unconscinable means such as fine print that nobody reads nor is expected to read nor has had explained.

You shouldn't be able to, but I think in most jurisdictions you most certainly can.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/End-user_license_agreement#Enf...

duncan_bayne··on Samsung Blu-ray players bricked because of an XML config file
What makes you think that what they broke is your property?

Read the EULA. It almost certainly specifies that what you think you own, has in fact just been licensed to you.

duncan_bayne··on Samsung Blu-ray players bricked because of an XML config file
> Only corporate greed

Go read up about the Cheka, Mao, and the Stasi.

I use Fastmail, eschew most social media, and run a PinePhone. I'm not a fan of corporate surveillance.

But they're amateurs compared with the murderous surveillance states of years past.

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →