HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

dimmuborgir

390 karma · joined July 7, 2010

submissionscomments
dimmuborgir··on Comparing Indian states with countries
That's limited by space and time. Either it's true in some parts of the society or it's true for a single generation or both.

Otherwise, considering economy is the only real variable factor in a society, it would mean that a society never changes.

dimmuborgir··on Comparing Indian states with countries
"...these stats will not show inequality."

Are you saying Gini co-efficient doesn't show inequality? How? We're not talking about poverty here, just 'inequality'.

"The second example you give is, in fact, an example of outsourcing"

That's not outsourcing but offshoring and how is it a bad thing? Don't you think talking about indigenousness in today's globalised world is nothing but jingoism?

"...cultural revolution..."

A country's culture and economy are tightly linked. It's a chicken-egg situation. Don't know about Indian culture but Indian economy is certainly doing good.

dimmuborgir··on Comparing Indian states with countries
First, not just other developing countries like Russia, Brazil and China but even US has more inequality than India. [1]

Second, Indian outsourcing industry is over-hyped. It contributes just 5% to the Indian GDP. But India is silently making big progresses in other industries. How many people here know that India is now the world's biggest manufacturer of small cars, overtaking Japan? [2]

[1] - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Gini_Coefficient_World_CIA...

[2] - http://www.thestar.com/business/article/742457--india-overta...

dimmuborgir··on China: Vote as I say
Russia has always been against NATO and lately it is pushing hard for a strong SCO (Shanghai Cooperation Organisation) [1] which is branded as Russia's/China's answer to NATO.

The current major issue with SCO though is it needs either India or Pakistan or both as its members to make it a formidable military alliance. But since India and Pakistan are archrivals there are differences between Russia, which has always backed India, and China, which has always backed Pakistan.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shanghai_Cooperation_Organisati...

dimmuborgir··on China's 'Wealth Drain': New Signs That Rich Chinese Are Set on Emigrating
My Chinese online friend has similar sentiments. Her main concerns are rampant corruption and lack of religious freedom.
dimmuborgir··on The Linux desktop experience is killing Linux on the desktop
In most Linux forums, user stories like this appear time and again. In most cases it turns out that the problems are unique for that particular person.

Have been a happy Ubuntu user (desktop + netbook) for the last 5 years without a single glitch.

dimmuborgir··on Why The Y Combinator Model Does Not Work In India
Apologies if I sounded rude. It's just that there has been increasing number of blog posts lately by Indian entrepreneurs comparing India with Silicon Valley and expressing overt pessimism. No offence was directed at you.
dimmuborgir··on Why The Y Combinator Model Does Not Work In India
India has a huge untapped market so there's definitely a place for Indian knockoffs of ebay/amazon/groupon etc. Nothing wrong in it.

Almost all Chinese web startups which are making huge IPO exits these days are direct ripoffs of successful American web companies.

dimmuborgir··on Why The Y Combinator Model Does Not Work In India
The title should be Why the Y Combinator model doesn't work in India YET.

The Silicon Valley has a classic chicken-egg situation where companies are chasing investors and investors chasing companies. Both are equally responsible for the valley's ecosystem and it took it a great deal of time and struggle to become what it is today.

Whining every other day that "OMG my country is so not valley, nothing will work here, we're screwed big time" helps no one. Be ready to take big risks. Be ready to grab every little opportunity. There's no reason why every emerging economy can't have its own Silicon Valley in the near future.

dimmuborgir··on Anonymous India strikes again against corruption
As if people around the world actually visit Wikileaks website to read the expositions. That's the task of media.

The gazillion newspapers and TV channels of India will do a nice job in highlighting Wikileaks expositions of Indian politicians if it is released. (recently Julian Assange promised to release the list of Indian black money holders in Swiss banks)

dimmuborgir··on Anonymous India strikes again against corruption
Not sure if the Yogi's protests will be fruitful because his demands are long and unrealistic. Since the black money in Swiss banks is an international issue it takes time to bring back that money.

But there was a country wide agitation a while back demanding for an Ombudsman bill (against corruption) which is now being worked out by a joint committee. It will most likely get passed in the parliament within two months. If it happens it'll be the first major step taken against corruption in the independent India.

dimmuborgir··on Tiobe: Lua enters the top 10 for the first time in history
Tiobe index is the single biggest source of language holy wars.

Don't know why it is so highly regarded.

dimmuborgir··on As an entrepreneur in India
The author in the rush of justifying her feelings of moral suffering has put some factual lies and false notions.

First, she claims that the standard of living in India is plummeting and goes on mentioning slums, filth, corruption, bureaucracy etc. If one checks the recent national census and other survey results, the poverty has been steadily declining [1], the illiteracy has sharply declined [2], Indian consumers are the most optimistic in the world! [3], and ironically - Indian entrepreneurs are the most optimistic in the world! [4]. The rest of her complaints are just nitpicks.

Second, the notion that happy existence or perfect system is the prerequisite to creativity and success. This is false. If one studies Anthropology, creativity/art/culture/economic-activity/entrepreneurship exist everywhere, even in the most failed country. It is the nature of man to grab every little opportunity. The fact that Mercedes has opened R&D centre in India only shows their creativity, their ability to grab the opportunity and their entrepreneual spirit. More power to the potholed roads! There's nothing called perfection in this universe.

Third, not a criticism but, one doesn't need to be overly pessimistic. India and other emerging economies are yet to see several decades of growth. Especially India and China, because of their huge population, will continue to see high economic growth for very long (ask any economists) [5][6]. And no, the moral suffering due to inequality will not disappear anytime soon. China even after growing at a breakneck speed of 10% a year for last three decades and pulling millions of people out of poverty has more inequality than India (Gini coefficient) [7]. I think we'll just gradually evolve to live with it.

[1] - http://www.moneycontrol.com/news/current-affairs/indias-pove...

[2] - http://www.deccanherald.com/content/150267/indias-literacy-l...

[3] - http://www.afaqs.com/news/story.html?sid=30621_Indian+consum...

[4] - http://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&q=cache:5wJKiOx4osAJ:w...

[5] - http://www.livemint.com/2011/05/25191535/India-could-be-worl...

[6] - http://www.deccanherald.com/content/140463/india-likely-worl...

[7] - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Gini_Coefficient_World_CIA...

dimmuborgir··on Google acquires Postrank.com
Well deserved. Postrank has been the best example of usage of EventMachine.
dimmuborgir··on Anonymous releases 10,365 e-mails from the Iranian government
Both English and Farsi.
dimmuborgir··on Astronomy Picture of the Day (timelapse with Earth rotating)
The camera is turning at an angular speed of 7.2 × 10^-5 rad/s which is the speed of Earth's rotation.
dimmuborgir··on Alternative jQuery Documentation
Have been using railsapi/sdoc for many months now. It's fantastic and I highly recommend it.
dimmuborgir··on The Github Follower Problem
Lot's of good suggestions for GitHub coming up lately through various blogs.

I think it's high time GitHub put a public Brainstorm/Suggestions interface with possibility of voting the entries.

There's a GitHub profile on GetSatisfaction but there's no activity there.

dimmuborgir··on GitHub: Block the Bullies
May be before putting all your blames on a open source community, you should have studied a little bit of social-anthropology.

You see, if you had involved deeply with any hot new tech community, like node.js, instead of Rails, you would have had the same problem with that community.

dimmuborgir··on The reverse brain drain
I was asking with respect to bribery. The list you quoted takes a lot of other things like infrastructure, funding etc into consideration.
dimmuborgir··on The reverse brain drain
The article is old and it quotes an unnamed 'survey'.

I'm reminding you again, the discussion here is about progression of India from its own past but you're either coming up with figures for some particular year or some senseless comparison with other countries. In other words, you're simply trolling.

dimmuborgir··on The reverse brain drain
Any source that China is more conducive to small businesses than India?
dimmuborgir··on The reverse brain drain
Are you trolling or something? The article mentions neither USSR nor India.

And FYI, the disintegration of USSR was due to economic crisis because of Socialism. India abandoned Socialism soon after the collapse of Soviet Russia and embraced American capitalism and the Indian economy is booming now.

dimmuborgir··on The reverse brain drain
We're talking about whether India has made progress from its own past. Why are you bringing former Soviet states for comparison?
dimmuborgir··on The reverse brain drain
What are you talking about? The UN's Millennium Development Goal (MDG) report says:

"India is expected to reduce its poverty rate from 51 per cent in 1990 to 24 per cent in 2015, reducing its number of extremely poor by 188 million."

http://news.outlookindia.com/item.aspx?685779

dimmuborgir··on The reverse brain drain
Are you saying that Chinese authorities are not corrupt? Did the state controlled media of China make you believe so?

Take a look at Corruption Index published by Transparency International:

http://transparency.org/policy_research/surveys_indices/cpi/...

Both China and India are the same. In fact, with free-media, India has a greater chance of tackling corruption in the future than China.

dimmuborgir··on 1 in 6 Russian entrepreneurs are in jail, 1 in 3 prisoners are businessmen
Apples and oranges. We're talking about corporate entrepreneurs and you're talking about games organisers who are/were on government payroll. Corporate scandals in India are almost unheard of. (Satyam fiasco is an exception though)
dimmuborgir··on Linux: The Source of All Desktop Innovation
It's unfortunate that KDE doesn't get the attention it deserves. It has been long rebuked as a Windows clone.

But, KDE's Plasma Desktop is highly innovative (through a wide range of interesting plasmoids). The fact that it can be easily scripted in JavaScript makes it even more awesome.

dimmuborgir··on Gimp with task-based interface customizations
Yes but as you said earlier, it has taken up way too much screen real estate and it's not at all intuitive. Making it a plugin will retain the classic GIMP intact as well as one doesn't need to install a separate GIMP client.
dimmuborgir··on Gimp with task-based interface customizations
Agreed.

Making it a plugin will also ensure that the classic toolbox is still available. That way, a novice user can quickly become proficient in GIMP.

← PreviousPage 5 of 7Next →