677 karma · joined April 2, 2009
For background:
* http://www.codeforamerica.org/blog/2015/11/30/a-new-approach... * http://www.codeforamerica.org/blog/2015/12/07/child-welfare-...
So, not science reporting, then.
I'm not talking about just how Movie OS looks, but how it behaves as a whole. I agree that sticking a Star Trek skin on Windows 98 reduces usability.
Well - we won't know without trying. But it's clear that in the Read/Write Web Facebook case, a bunch of people had thought that they had logged in to Facebook when in fact they hadn't. And that they didn't even know where they were.
You may not want it every time. But at the moment, we don't even have it at all. That's restrictive in the kind of messages we can send out.
For emails flying off the screen: the execution is in the detail. A few seconds may be too long. For some people, it may not even be long enough. But the animation isn't necessarily just showing that an email is being sent: it can convey a lot of other information in a clear, yet subtle way. It's interesting that there's no visual cue when an email is sent that distinguishes between sending to a single individual or a group of people, or an even larger group of people.
From the point of view of a naive user, there are new types of interactions that can have massive social implications: e.g. changing Facebook relationship status. At the moment, the notification of that status change to the user is pretty minimal. It does not, for example, make clear that that change will be propagated to, say, over 500 people, and all of their contacts.
There may be people who are more concerned about their social standing than whether they've accidentally formatted a volume or not.