HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

czr80

2,044 karma · joined March 14, 2012

submissionscomments
czr80··on NASA paywalls first papers arising from Curiosity rover – I am setting them free
Well, prestige is used as currency precisely because we as a society need a mechanism to generate knowledge that isn't (immediately) commercializable. I, for one, would find it tragic if we lost that.
czr80··on NASA paywalls first papers arising from Curiosity rover – I am setting them free
This seems to prove too much. Either all scientists are irrational, or they get some real value out of the journals system.
czr80··on IPCC climate report: humans 'dominant cause' of warming
Wikipedia, first hit on Google:

"Global cooling was a conjecture during the 1970s of imminent cooling of the Earth's surface and atmosphere culminating in a period of extensive glaciation. This hypothesis had little support in the scientific community, but gained temporary popular attention due to a combination of a slight downward trend of temperatures from the 1940s to the early 1970s and press reports that did not accurately reflect the full scope of the scientific climate literature, i.e., a larger and faster-growing body of literature projecting future warming due to greenhouse gas emissions."

But this is so easy to find that I suspect the details don't really matter to you. Perhaps another wikipedia article might help: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motivated_reasoning

czr80··on Apple Chiefs Discuss Strategy, Market Share, and the New iPhones
My view is that it's a fine article, that correctly identifies the issues that you need to address to make a prediction about the market. That's a good piece of analysis.

His actual prediction is beside the point - he laid it out in enough detail for the reader to intelligently disagree, if they had better information on the drivers he identified.

czr80··on Apple Chiefs Discuss Strategy, Market Share, and the New iPhones
When? iOS never had the dominant share (globally) - that passed from Symbian to Android.
czr80··on Apple Chiefs Discuss Strategy, Market Share, and the New iPhones
So, I read the article and your summary is very poor - quite intellectually dishonest, really. He clearly lays out the conditions which would have to hold for Android to grow significantly, and it turned out that they were met (Nokia collapsed, Windows proved unable to compete with free, and Samsung was able to establish a viable Android business)
czr80··on America's next president had better believe in restoring liberty
Americans. Always holding out hope that the next superman will rescue them from themselves.

I blame Hollywood.

czr80··on James Burke predicted the future in 1973. Now he does it again
I'm not sure - if private companies maintain these databases, wouldn't it be easy for a hypothetical corrupt government to access them?
czr80··on Privacy is not dead
If you have sufficient karma (500, last I knew) you can downvote comments.
czr80··on The cardinal UX mistake we made, you might be making it too
Means "Not in service", for those wondering.
czr80··on The cardinal UX mistake we made, you might be making it too
I'm guessing you mean "cardinal" but I'm not going to click that link at work :-)
czr80··on If Steve Ballmer Ran Apple
Indeed, Apple is doomed.
czr80··on Poll: do you live in the country you were born in?
No.
czr80··on NSA broke privacy rules thousands of times per year, audit finds
The FBI is meant to deal with domestic terrorism. The NSA's remit is foreign signals intelligence.
czr80··on NSA broke privacy rules thousands of times per year, audit finds
Tangentially, so could Google.
czr80··on Single Tweet Sends Apple Shares Soaring
That's a great article, thanks. I actually had the coin example in mind when I wrote the comment, but was too busy to write out the full argument!
czr80··on Single Tweet Sends Apple Shares Soaring
I don't think the (strong) version of the efficient-market hypothesis is defensible but Warren Buffet's track record is not proof that it is wrong - in a random market, given a large number of investors, some will do well purely by chance.
czr80··on iPhone logs my complete movement profile
Copy what? The idea of showing context aware information?
czr80··on Jeff Bezos Is Playing Chess
Large brick and mortar retailers also usually have negative working capital, it's nothing to do with being an online company, rather it's about bargaining power vs suppliers.
czr80··on The world is socialist
Medical care is not unequivocally a private good.
czr80··on New Zeeland man is 3D printing his own Aston Martin
Well, it does show a certain historical awareness... :)
czr80··on The Quantum Zeno Effect actually does stop the world
The only correction I'd make to their sentence is change "showed" to "appeared to show". And his paradoxes did appear to show all those things. Of course empirically you (and the ancient Greeks) could see that they must be wrong - the challenge was to find the logical flaw in his arguments. Finding that took a very long time.
czr80··on The Quantum Zeno Effect actually does stop the world
Seems okay to me - what precisely do you think they got wrong?
czr80··on Snowden granted 1-year asylum in Russia, leaves airport
A large part of the response is irrational fear, true, a good example of salience bias. That said, there is a rational argument as well, and that is that terrorism has two special features:

- High variance : Even though deaths to date are low, there is a non-zero chance that someone will manage to pull off a very large attack (9/11 is an example, the next one might be a dirty bomb)

- Escalation : The point of terrorism is to create fear - if low level attacks don't promote fear the incentive is just to escalate until the attacks reach a point that does trigger a reaction. In other words - you're battling a human opponent and they will adjust their tactics to what you do.

czr80··on What does it mean for light to be stopped or stored?
FTA: "What makes the experiment most exciting is that this experiment has proven to be an extremely long term method for storing quantum information, which has traditionally been a major hurdle. Normally a quantum computer (such as they are) has to get all of its work done in a fraction of a second."
czr80··on Light completely stopped for a record-breaking minute
> Photons are responding to the curvature in space-time, not directly to the gravitational field

In general relativity, space-time curvature is the gravitational field, so I'm not quite sure what distinction you're trying to draw?

czr80··on Light completely stopped for a record-breaking minute
Light does have mass (it has zero rest mass, but it's always moving at c, and as we know m = E/c^2...)
czr80··on Block NSA funding for collecting the call records of all Americans
You need to wrestle with three issues:

- Preventing the emergence of warring factions [1]

- Enforcement of rules underlying market transactions (e.g., contract law, property rights, policing, etc.)

- Underinvestment in public goods, such as basic research and national defense [2]

There is zero evidence that these three things are addressable at scale without some type of government, although of course we are free to argue forever about the level of centralisation, marginal tax rates, precise scope of activities, and so on.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warlord

[2]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_good

czr80··on Block NSA funding for collecting the call records of all Americans
So, let me get this straight: we abolish taxes, eliminate governments, and then ... paradise?
czr80··on Obama wins back the right to indefinitely detain under NDAA
Depends what the alternative is, I guess.
← PreviousPage 4 of 10Next →