HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

chii

20,536 karma · joined March 5, 2010

submissionscomments
chii··on Meta takes down a critical video about meta AI Glasses after filming at Meta
> wonder how he's still CEO.

it's because he controls the board by being the majority voting shareholder.

This is what happens when the gov't decides that it is legal for share classes with different voting rights. It ensures that you can sell equity to obtain money, without actually giving up control of said company at all. In theory, buyers would discount the sold equity due to this, but in practice, they don't (esp. if they're retail buyers).

chii··on Show HN: How long do I need to work at my salary before I can coast, or retire?
but the upsides of AGI could counter the unbounded liability - you will need to actively utilize the AGI to help you retire.
chii··on Samsung accidentally freezes its smart fridges with a software update
Fridge sellers dont want their product to be seen as commodities, because they can't charge a high margin on those type of products.
chii··on What California is learning from solar panels built over irrigation canals
not if you want to suspend it above the water.

Tarp, and pitch it across the canal like how you might do a hammock - you just need two anchor points on each side (or 4, at most).

chii··on What California is learning from solar panels built over irrigation canals
putting tarp over the canal might be an even cheaper solution? You dont need metal to make shade.
chii··on Samsung is expected to more than double output of its HBM4 and HBM4E DRAM
> their economic dividend runs out

i dont think it will - they still have a chokehold on battery production (which implies dominance in the EV sector), and they also control the vast majority of all rare earths. The chinese gov't can subsidize chip research/development with these other sectors that are dominating.

The west is the one that need to watch out for their own economic dividend running out from the past century.

chii··on You can defeat the Dream Devourer from Chrono Trigger using an int overflow
it's more likely that the stat for equipping is calculated differently to when unequipping (ala, "same" code in two different places, and one got modified at some point and forgot about the other).
chii··on US interest rates raised for first time in three years
Except the person doing the pooping doesn't drink from the same well as he's got his own private reserve supply.
chii··on The Google Play app review process now regularly takes longer than a week
> It does generally make sense that the OS vendor needs to play a key part in helping ensure trusted parties are involved in the supply chain.

this position of privilege is what the OS vendor (google in this case) wants, because it spells profit.

I dont trust it.

The only trust i have is community trust. Piracy works on this trust, and it has worked for very long.

chii··on Steam Frame starts at $1059
> Lower volume with consumers fully covering the device cost will probably become the norm

dont know about lower volume, but having the consumer pay the cost of the device fully (instead of subsidized by the later sale of games on the system) is better aligned with the interests of the consumer. You'd be less likely to get monopolistic device sellers signing exclusivity for games like the consoles of the past.

I want the device to be as good as it can be, rather than wanting the device for the exclusive game that it has.

chii··on Steam Frame starts at $1059
The VR world still has not produced a killer app.

I had imagined that remote work would induce a VR desktop work environment (as the killer app), but that hadnt taken off at all (mostly, i think, because it's difficult to type and do keyboard work in VR).

Gaming has not and will not be the killer app for VR imho. It needs to be business/money/work-related for it to actually gain a level of traction like how personal computing gained traction from mainframes.

chii··on Garry Tan wants US open-weight AI labs to 'distill' frontier models, too
There's no independent verification of what that checkbox actually does. The company can say anything, and you are unable to verify that they actually do it.

The only verification you could do so far is GDPR-style data export, and also the adherence to GDPR regulations (and even those might get skirted if they aren't operating in europe).

chii··on Why is privacy so hard? (2019)
The reason it works for churches is because the data told to churches are somewhat embarrassing for the confessor, and if leaked, will destroy the confessor's reputation (if not get into legal troubles).

The data that google collects are somewhat useless on their own, and is only valuable in aggregate with the millions of others they also collect. And for an individual, the leakage of this data (e.g., your advertising profile) is not detrimental unless the data is highly identifying (like your name, address, phone etc).

Therefore, people tend to simply ignore such leaks, and place zero value on the data. This difference in valuation is how google generates their money. The church, on the other hand, generates value from the gratitude of the confessors, and is therefore, aligned with the interest of the confessors.

chii··on Aligned to whom?
> lobbying against those laws.

the original question was that the LLM creates extinction level event for mankind in order to lower emissions. I'm sure that no matter how the LLMs lobby, they cannot successfully lobby for a law (which has to be enacted by a human) to allow murder to take place freely.

chii··on Flock worker calls police on reporter filming public camera installation
> one should be held to a different standard than the other.

harassing a worker is not the way to fix the problem. The worker has no agency to affect the changes desired by the harasser. It's an issue with the gov't, and needs civic procedures to change.

This behaviour is the same as harassing hospitality staff for bad prices. Harassers would be considered borderline committing terrorism if they go further.

chii··on Aligned to whom?
Why can't the LLM's be told/prompted to follow all relevant laws while it optimizes for a result?
chii··on Nvidia is the central bank of AI
> Monetarily, Nvidia is creating a lot of money in our economy.

nvidia's money either comes from equity, or from debt. This means this money is "created" not from nothing, but from future commitments (ala, debt repayments, or promise of profits), which is not the same as what comes out of the Fed.

The Fed printing has no backing behind it - it is definitely inflationary if they do it. Investment from nvidia (or any other company) "creating money" may be productive enough to completely offset their inflationary effects - after all, the company investing demands returns from their investments, and so will only invest in things they expect to return much higher than the cost of interest (or cost of capital).

Therefore, you cannot compare Fed printing money to company investing money.

chii··on OpenAI agents carried out an undisclosed attack on RubyGems
> They're still autocomplete

it's like saying our brain is just some chemical chain reactions. True, but also irrelevant.

chii··on AI researchers debate how close we are to recursive self-improvement
> If a self improving model can't produce enough value to pay the electric bill then who cares? Unplug it.

so you would unplug a child who hasn't shown their potential yet, simply because they don't produce enough value at the moment to justify their food?

chii··on More questions about whether researchers can trust OpenAI with unpublished math
> without providing attribution or compensation?

many teachers also taught many students over the course of history, and very few would eventually pay any compensation or even attribute their financial (or career) outcomes to the teachers.

What made model training different?

chii··on Automattic's board forces CEO Matt Mullenweg into leave of absence
and people misuse this quote to justify unreasonable behaviour that does not progress the world.
chii··on Automattic's board forces CEO Matt Mullenweg into leave of absence
> the greatest scientific minds

if one has a scientific mind, they will accept evidence which may be contrary to their personal views. If you dont, you cannot be said to have a scientific mind, let alone greatest.

> founding fathers of the United States

that may in fact, be the case, but chances are someone today of similar disposition would not be able to do the same.

chii··on Automattic's board forces CEO Matt Mullenweg into leave of absence
I dont know any clinical information, but some (many, in fact) people assume mental illness when someone behaves in such a way that they believe their world view and mental model is absolute and fight to the last tooth and nail against any opposing view points (to the detriment of their own well being and others).
chii··on A Stupid Idea for AI Alignment We Came with by Looking at Specification Gaming
> do no harm to humans?

but you haven't specified _exactly_ what harm to humans mean.

Would you consider the AI overlord to have harmed humans if they kept humans like we keep zoos today?

chii··on Copyright does more harm than good and should be abolished
> copyright ownership is not a monopoly because there are other copyrighted works

they are not fungible, unlike houses.

Also, if you could copy a house like you could copy digital goods (i would download a car), i am also going to claim that the "monopoly" on the house must also be shortened.

chii··on Copyright does more harm than good and should be abolished
> until the end of the author's life.

which is too long, and also too short - what about authors who wrote finished their book on their deathbed? Then their rights are shorter than someone young - an unfair discrimination.

That's why age should be irrelevant. Copyright is useful, and should be granted. However, current copyright grants last far too long - age plus some years beyond. Not to mention corporations lobbying to increase the length right as some copyrights for some works are about to enter public domain.

Therefore, copyright should be granted for a single period and end - like patents. 20 years seems to be a good middle ground, but i could hear arguments for slightly longer or shorter.

chii··on Copyright does more harm than good and should be abolished
> It you think copyright should be shorter to everyone, then inheriting something valuable shouldn't be a thing as well?

inheritance has nothing to do with copyright. Financial assets are not monopolies. Copyright is only a valuable asset because of the granted monopoly on copying/distribution.

Therefore, to reduce the value copyright has (as it currently does seem to have too much), reducing the granted terms should be sufficient. Like patents, a good 20 years seems like a sufficiently long time to recover cost of production, while letting people who are currently alive to produce derivatives of it afterwards.

chii··on We have a year to fix security everywhere
forensic accounting and audits also require a paper trail.

So if you have no logging and such, you will have already failed regulatory reporting standards - just like you would fail an accounting audit if you have no paper trail of where your money went!

chii··on We have a year to fix security everywhere
> would have to be honestly reported for that idea to work.

and why does this idea work for accounting audits, but not for security? As long as regulations for companies exist, they would necessarily follow it, and this would lead to reporting of security breaches just like companies would have to report their financials honestly.

chii··on We have a year to fix security everywhere
> pay their fortinet renewal and check "Security: Done!" without any kind of analysis.

there exists objective measure of security, which would be some sort of hacks/breaches per period. If customers cared about it (and i assume they do), they would choose companies that have less breaches over others with higher counts, normalized on cost differences.

Therefore, if companies didnt actually try to fix their security but instead just checked boxes, they would get breached more often, resulting in customer losses.

The only thing stopping this from actually occurring is the lack of mandatory regulatory reporting of it. So this is where gov't needs to step in and mandate disclosure etc.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →