HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

apparent

2,009 karma · joined January 30, 2025

submissionscomments
apparent··on AI boosted homework scores, then exam scores dropped: study
True, but only for things that that your colleagues don't expect you to know already. Remember the "I'll circle back" meme about Jen Psaki? This response can only be used sparingly before it's seen as a sign of underpreparedness/inability to do back-of-the-envelope thinking.
apparent··on Why Are Colleges Giving Financial Aid to Rich Kids?
You misunderstand: they are requiring families to list all of their income and assets so they can decide how much of a discount to give you.

See, they're just trying to help.

apparent··on Why Are Colleges Giving Financial Aid to Rich Kids?
They make it hard to be considered separate from your parents because if it was easy, every student would do it upon reaching age 18.

What I found wild was that they felt entitled to 1/3 of my assets every year. The lesson is: spend your money before college or keep it under the mattress, because your college will take essentially all of it over the course of 4 years.

apparent··on Why Are Colleges Giving Financial Aid to Rich Kids?
This seems like an incomplete take. Part of the reason colleges want these kids is because their stats (GPA, test scores) help the college with their rankings.

Separately, I question how wealthy the families are that are contributing $60k/yr. They obviously have to have enough money to pay this much, but they may be largely bled dry by 4 years of tuition (per kid). This would be half a million dollars of post-tax money for two kids. That's a lot of money, but if it's half (or more) of your retirement savings, then it's not like you're not going to miss it.

One has to be truly wealthy ($5M+ of liquid assets) to not feel half a million dollars, and I assume if this was the type of family the writer was referring to, he would have indicated that these are truly wealthy people, not just someone who would be considered wealthy in Topeka or Duluth.

College has gotten so expensive that it's a big cost for pretty much every family. There have been many articles about how no one pays the rack rate anymore, so it's not really as expensive as it seems. The only way that could be true is if merit-based aid is in the mix.

apparent··on Being ambitious and being a dad
> why must we choose between having a great career and being a great parent

Because there is a limited number of hours in the day? That doesn't mean that one cannot do both at the same time, at times. It doesn't even mean that having kids can't also make you a better founder in some ways. But I think most people recognize that the large time demands of being a founder take away more from one's ability to build than they contribute (in terms of extra motivation or perspective).

apparent··on The Amazon tax
This is an interesting goal. I would agree in general, but in the age of AI I'm feeling like much of the 'labor' being done is done by AI.
apparent··on A particle made of force: physicists say they've found mysterious 'glueball'
I was waiting for someone to make a glueball joke, TBH.
apparent··on The Amazon tax
Imagine there's a best-selling toaster. Amazon can recommend it and many people will be happy buying it. Then, one day a new toaster comes out, and it might be even better than the old best-seller. How would it get sufficient traction to be recommended by the algorithm? To send a strong enough signal, it would probably need a level of sales that could only be achieved with some level of advertising.

Separately, I'd note that Amazon doesn't want high levels of returns (which it has to pay for in many cases), so they still try to herd people toward products that they will find acceptable. Might they not love them as much as some others? Perhaps, though this is a fine line to try to walk, and I'm not sure that Amazon is actually trying to walk it.

apparent··on A particle made of force: physicists say they've found mysterious 'glueball'
Oh cool, will look into this. Have only used it to make podcasts in the past. I'm a little hesitant to build in a walled garden though. I'd rather store things in an open format that can be used with many platforms, not just the one.
apparent··on A particle made of force: physicists say they've found mysterious 'glueball'
How do you plan to make this newfound knowledge 'stick'? Do you have enough relevant/related knowledge that you'll remember it? Or is there a way to have Gemini make a bunch of cards for use with spaced repetition software?
apparent··on 'Buy Now, Pay Later' Lenders Pitch Loans for Needs Like Electricity and Rent
In my mind, the externalities of reckless driving are much greater than getting credit on bad terms.
apparent··on 'Buy Now, Pay Later' Lenders Pitch Loans for Needs Like Electricity and Rent
I respect that position, and you're right that not everyone is smart enough to make good choices for themselves. I don't carry a balance on my credit cards, which makes me somewhat smart, but I also don't follow all the subreddits about maximixing credit card points, moving balances from here to there, etc. Some people might look down on me for "leaving money on the table" in that regard. I could probably make a thousand dollars a year if I were more informed/aggressive.

I don't want to look down my nose at people who make decisions that I wouldn't make. They also face very different circumstances. What if someone needs to pay for an unexpected medical bill (which they cannot BNPL) and needs to choose between that and rent? What might look like a dumb choice from the outside might be an exercise in constrained optimization.

I've said that I'm open to BNPL being unavailable for certain transaction types, but I wonder if someone with your opinions would rather have them outlawed entirely?

apparent··on 'Buy now, pay later' lenders pitch loans for needs like electricity and rent
Payday loan places don't know what you're using the cash for. They just give you a cash advance that you can spend on groceries, rent, drugs, or whatever else you want.

BNPL platforms know what you're spending on, and whether it's a one-time expense that you're spreading out, or a rent/utility payment that's going to come due next month as well.

apparent··on 'Buy Now, Pay Later' Lenders Pitch Loans for Needs Like Electricity and Rent
I can sort of understand using BNPL for seasonal purchases like Christmas gifts, to spread the payments over time. But using them to pay for utilities or rent seems like a colossally bad idea.

In general, I don't favor regulation of loan products, on the notion that people should be free to get loans that fit their circumstances. But I wouldn't be opposed to limiting BNPL loans so they are not available for purchases that are (1) large dollar value and (2) recurring. Or there could be PSAs to warn people about them.

And regardless, they should be teaching kids about money management and the consequences of BNPL in school. There should be plenty of time now that kids aren't learning about "balancing their checkbook".

apparent··on Anthropic's ‘watermark’ text adulteration in Claude is a perversion of writing
It says it only applies to passages over 200 words, so you could use a different LLM to rephrase every other paragraph and undermine the watermarking.
apparent··on Anthropic's ‘watermark’ text adulteration in Claude is a perversion of writing
His complaint seems to center on conversations between him and the LLM, not copy being written for publication elsewhere. That is, if Claude is going to teach him a new skill, he wants it to pick the most accurate words possible, not "pretty accurate words, subject to watermarking techniques".
apparent··on Anthropic's ‘watermark’ text adulteration in Claude is a perversion of writing
And I'm sure students will use tools to have every other paragraph written in the style of a different AI, in an attempt to defeat this fingerprinting.
apparent··on LinkedIn Wants Users to Lean Less on AI. Maybe Less
I appreciate the new AI-slop-reporting button, and I imagine LI will use it to improve their own algorithms so they can detect and down-weight AI on their own.

At the same time, LI's top level algorithm wants to push a bunch of uninteresting crap at me, like posts that someone I know "liked". What's the point of removing AI slop if you're going to keep pushing irrelevant garbage at your users?

I am so grateful for the HNer who recently recommended this extension, [1] which lets you block posts by type. Now I only see posts made by my actual connections (which was the original idea of LI, IMO).

Interestingly, one of the side effects of this is I can now see which of my contacts are annoying over-posters, and can unfollow them. Previously their junk was buried under piles of other junk, so it wasn't so readily apparent.

1: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49224161

apparent··on Semaglutide linked to lower predicted dementia risk
Replying to your edit:

Amazing that you again allege insincerity, with zero evidence. You then go on to make false claims about what I said and avoid the obvious point that my problem is not with the historical figure that you quoted, but the fact that you injected race into a conversation that was about food.

As for whether you violate the HN guidelines, the number of your recent comments that are greyed out tends to indicate that I'm not the only one who thinks you're out of step here.

apparent··on Semaglutide linked to lower predicted dementia risk
How does any of this make my comment insincere? Even if I agreed with it, I wouldn't understand how it proves your original accusation.

I also don't love your injection of flame-bait racial comments, which probably violate HN guidelines.

apparent··on Semaglutide linked to lower predicted dementia risk
Feel free to elaborate on my alleged insincerity. Was I insincere in noticing that there are partisan patterns at play, or insincere when pointing out that the govt should have more control over govt-run/taxpayer funded programs, as opposed to transactions between private parties?

I am sincerely curious to know your opinion.

apparent··on Semaglutide linked to lower predicted dementia risk
I thought the half-life was long enough that skipping a pill or taking a lower dose wouldn't make much of a difference?

Also, do you cut pills? I had looked into this and only found info saying that it ruins the delivery mechanism. I was skeptical of this because it would benefit the pill makers to convince people that these special pills cannot be cut, even though they do not require extended delivery (quite the opposite).

apparent··on Semaglutide linked to lower predicted dementia risk
What's interesting is that it's different parts of the electorate that get upset. When Republicans wanted to make junk food/soda ineligible for food stamps, Dems got upset. And when Dems wanted to tax large sodas, Republicans/libertarians got upset.

I think the former makes much more sense than the latter, since it is literally being funded by the govt. That's a reasonable first step, or possibly only step, especially considering that most people on food stamps are also on govt-funded/subsidized healthcare (meaning taxpayers will end up footing the bill when they require expensive treatments resulting in part from an unhealthy diet).

apparent··on Professor's Death Leaves Behind Hard Questions for Cambridge on Race and Hiring
They did fail him...but he was also the initial instigator of the fraud.
apparent··on Blog about things you don't understand yet
Seeing the title, I expected this to be a blog post trying to convince me what to blog about, written by a person who does not yet understand if his perspective is correct.
apparent··on Bill Gates' daughter's startup accused of 'cookie stuffing' scheme
You're surprised that someone had sex with one of the richest people on the planet?
apparent··on Mars Bar from 1991 found – and it's 20g bigger than today's
Ice cream is shrinkflated by whipping air into it. They can justify using the same size container, and allegedly selling the same volume, but much of it is just air now.

A side benefit: they can also sell it as "lower calorie" than it was before, since it's diluted with air.

EDIT: interesting to see this upvoted and then downvoted so much. Can someone who is downvoting weigh in? Seems relevant to the topic, and no one is saying it doesn't happen (or that it is happening and they like it).

apparent··on The 'Jury Duty' Scam That Cost This Family $25,000
A fairly well-educated victim:

> “I’m a rule-follower,” said Fudge, who majored in mechanical engineering and minored in math.

apparent··on To recruit teachers, school districts are building homes
I would be more likely to teach in a private school than a public one, for sure. But I have a different job for now so am not pursuing it. That doesn't negate the point I made (and which a sibling commenter has said also applies to his/her case).

I'm not sure the point of your last comment. Of course everyone wants to be paid fairly for what they accomplish, which is not just based on intelligence, but also hard work. I have done a very good job educating my own children and have seen enough laziness in our public schools that I'm certain I would be more effective than a great many of the teachers.

But more importantly, if the incentives were aligned then even better teachers would enter, perhaps leaving me in the bottom part of the distribution. Nothing would make me happier than if schools were filled with teachers who were so effective!

apparent··on To recruit teachers, school districts are building homes
Why do you think it is not relevant to the problem of teacher recruiting? I would be more likely to go into teaching if I thought it could be a good place to work and I would be paid fairly. My impression, from seeing my kids go through public schools, is that the lockstep pay (which can be bumped by getting mostly-useless online degrees) creates bad incentives. There is no way to move up quickly by being an awesome teacher, and mediocre teachers are impossible to get rid of. This hurts morale and drains districts of resources that could be used to pay better-performing teachers.
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →