HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Ygg2

8,245 karma · joined March 28, 2012

submissionscomments
Ygg2··on Turtle WoW classic server announces shutdown after Blizzard wins injunction
Why do people write fanfiction rather than writing their original stuff?

> Oh yeah, because people didn’t want a new game, they wanted free WoW.

That's an error; Turtle WoW isn't a free WoW. It's WoW fixed to classic, with 2 new races, extra content. It's basically their flavor of WoW.

Free WoW exists and it's called a pirate server. This isn't it chief.

Ygg2··on Turtle WoW classic server announces shutdown after Blizzard wins injunction
> I mean you can't get a clearer case of copycatting than this

I'm pretty sure Turtle WoW has its own storyline, quests, etc. The story focuses heavily on extending Vanilla.

In other words, it's not a simple copycat but a fan project.

Rather than hiring and vying for talent, Blizzard is CnD their fans away.

Ygg2··on Bevy game development tutorials and in-depth resources
I have instructed Claude to make two games in each of your engines for Q3 2031. Your claim is still invalid :P
Ygg2··on France's government is ditching Windows for Linux, says US tech a strategic risk
Interesting. I merely pointed the flaw in your logic. You assumed I'm some multipolar proponent.
Ygg2··on Bevy game development tutorials and in-depth resources
No, the statement is there is more Rust engines than games.

It also adds easy to move goalpost of notability, that only accounts for luck and age, not actual capabilities.

Ygg2··on Bevy game development tutorials and in-depth resources
Here is ten games in bevy engine

https://youtu.be/50g3eSrSM6Q

Rust has like 2-3 game engines and a bunch of bindings.

Ygg2··on Bevy game development tutorials and in-depth resources
"The claim which is made without proof can be dismissed without proof" - Big Brain
Ygg2··on France's government is ditching Windows for Linux, says US tech a strategic risk
Past performance doesn't guarantee future performance. Otherwise xkcd https://xkcd.com/605/ would be true.
Ygg2··on JSON formatter Chrome plugin now closed and injecting adware
Water is merely 49C, said the frog. It's not even 100C. I'll stay.

Google really is slow boiling Internet until everyone forgets you can have stuff without ads.

Ygg2··on The Cognitive Dark Forest
> What I mean is such a standard says that 1990-2018 was all unaffordable. 2019 was basically the only year that qualifies.

Nah, the period around 1080 was honestly the golden age, before the age of RTX ushered the pest that is AI.

> In terms of e-waste, if you look at an unfixable mini computer with core parts that on average die 2 years sooner than a full-size computer, it causes less e-waste because it's so much smaller.

I don't think any particular component in a PC has the same amount of waste as a Mac Mini. And replacing a component is part of 3R (Reuse, Reduce, Recycle).

> They can sell bigger chips that cost more money to power users, why would they not care?

Because power users have less money than large corporations and governments. By selling you an GPU for $1000 that could be sold for $10000, they are losing the $9000 on each sale.

> But even if it was just phone chips

Not just Phone chips, locked down sanitized spy garden. It's very hard to do anything remotely creative on a phone like programming or rendering. You want to use your phone as a Desktop? That's not allowed. It's called War on General Computing. Not war on Consumer Computers.

Ygg2··on Xilem – An experimental Rust native UI framework
Tech wise? If you have your UI in Rust it's both the safest and most performant language to implement it.

And you don't need to ship the entire web stack just to get GUI.

Ygg2··on Every GPU That Mattered
Turns out corporations and governments can pay way more than individuals.
Ygg2··on The Cognitive Dark Forest
> It beats the 10 year old high end. That's not necessary to avoid being a waste of sand.

I remember when GPUs didn't need to wait 10 years for same chip makers worst offering to beat the top of the line.

> Motherboards are looking at the smallest price hikes of all.

For now.

And for the record I bought a bargain bin Xeon. Only to realize later the only motherboard that accepts it costs $1000. And I needed another Xeon chip. This was around 2020

> And you didn't address how your threshold for "affordable" would exclude every year before about 2019. It's too strict

Honestly. It's the last time hardware prices were close to sane.

> Listen, if I can get a whole computer for $300 then I don't need repair.

If you are willing to bear externalities of e-waste. Fine.

Also replace them with what? You think industry will care about power users? Nah. They can eat cock. Everyone gets a tightly sealed mobile phone that LARPs to be a computer.

Ygg2··on The Cognitive Dark Forest
> Does it have to be DIY?

Yes. Because only DIY allow your computer to be repaired at will. Go laptop or corporate and those get increasingly hard to fix. Not to mention if DIY market is healthy the non-DIY market is even cheaper.

> But price per performance continues to improve. A 5050

If 5050 didn't beat a 10 year old graphics card it would be an even greater waste of sand.

> Governments might want it, but that doesn't transfer to chip makers.

If governments want it, there is money to be made.

> Plus people could buy old datacenter chips for pennies on the dollar.

Sure, but no one will be able to afford all the other amenities. Buying a server CPU isn't the issue. It's buying every other part of the server rack. Namely the board, the cooler, the memory and the storage. And housing and power for it.

Ygg2··on GitHub backs down, kills Copilot pull-request ads after backlash
That's why I said in theory. Consider that at some point Valve was a startup.
Ygg2··on The Cognitive Dark Forest
Yeah, but it won't be cheap or easily repairable. And they don't make them anymore.
Ygg2··on The Cognitive Dark Forest
> What's your definition of affordable? What years were PCs affordable?

That DIY entry PCs can be built for 400 USD or less. Budget PC should be able to browse net and play a few games on the iGPU (so overall 1TB SSD, some iGPU and 16 GB of RAM). Ideally on current generation of RAM and processors.

> By my reckoning PCs are affordable today. If you're not trying to run games they're downright cheap.

By what reckoning? And not just games, 3D workload, compilation. Hell. Even browsing + some productivity eats 32G of RAM as if it were nothing.

> I'm not sure what issue you're referring to with bitcoin

The first permanent jump in GPU prices. After Bitcoin prices of high-end GPUs remained at +1000 USD.

> Cartels just agree not to make anything for PCs? Why would that happen?

For bigger profits. You can see most hardware manufacturers moving from selling to consumers to selling to governments, cloud, and data-centers.

Why not make anything for PCs? Because individuals can't compete with the coffers of large corporations and governments.

> The point of restricting supply to a market is to maximize profits, not to refuse forever and lose out.

You can maximize profit by leaving a market. In the same way, you can still sell SSDs but for much bigger margins to data centers and governments.

Say all but one/two manufacturers leave the consumer market. The monopoly/duopoly hikes up prices again and again until you have a few stragglers on 40k USD workstations, and everyone else is on an iOS-like platform.

Once you are in the walled-in-cloud-garden, computer is not your own, and you can be monitored perfectly. This is something most governments want and is essentially the endgame for war on general computing.

Ygg2··on GitHub backs down, kills Copilot pull-request ads after backlash
Sure. But a startup could, in theory end up profitable and self-sufficient without a public offering. It's not impossible.
Ygg2··on GitHub backs down, kills Copilot pull-request ads after backlash
Thinking of megacorps as anything other than slimy, amoral, scum honestly requires superhuman levels of mental gymnastics.
Ygg2··on The Cognitive Dark Forest
And COPA didn't succeed at first, but try and try and you get COPPA, and now age verification laws.

I don't think we'll see PC affordable in my lifetime. It didn't happen after Bitcoin crash, didn't happen post pandemics. New price gets normalized and the cartels just agree to not make anything for PCs.

And if you get everyone on cloud? Then you can control Internet same way you can control TV or the press.

Ygg2··on The Cognitive Dark Forest
> I've been writing code in Emacs for 20 years, I'll be writing code in Emacs in 20 years

Bold assumption. On what will you run Emacs if average PC costs $12000? Yes. Even Raspberry Pi. It's not called war on general computing for nothing.

If you say the cloud, that will be cut up and reused by the next AI crawler.

Ygg2··on I use Excalidraw to manage my diagrams for my blog
> It looks off

Depends on what you want to achieve with your look. Do you want to scream professionalism, authority, and completed? Use a regular UML tool.

Want to say this is a rough draft of a few ideas? Then using UML is probably THE wrong look. And Exaclidraw should be used instead.

--- Anecdote time. According to one of my professors, they showed how the prototype will look in action, and the customers were so impressed by the smoke and mirrors prototype they wanted to start using it right away.

In the end, customer walked away because they thought they were being strung along to pay for something that was already done.

Ygg2··on An incoherent Rust
> But reading some of the made-up syntax in the "Removing Coherence" section makes my head hurt.

It's interesting to note the discrepancy between replies to this blog here and, say, lobste.rs (which is neutral to it).

Here it's very concerned about complexity, while on lobsters it's mostly about needing this feature - yesterday.

Ygg2··on An incoherent Rust
> It feels really wasteful to burn CPU and spin up fans every time I save a file. I find it hard to justify using 30+ GB of memory to run an LSP and compiler.

Have you tried using RustRover. I've never seen it go above 2-3GiB of RAM, but I don't write the most complex of software in Rust.

> I hate how crates.io requires a GitHub account to publish anything.

You don't need Github account to publish iirc, you need it to authorize to crates.io. You can use any Git host, but your account is tied to GitHub.

Ygg2··on Fyn: An uv fork with new features, bug fixes, stripped telemetry
> Recording information about someone's computer and then sending it to the developer without their knowledge or consent is spying.

That's why I said done properly. You need full transparency. What is recorded and why, and how is the information dealt with.

In practice most people don't care. If they did they would disable all achievements, because even achievements are a form of telemetry.

You can see what percent of people finished the game for example. What percent played mini game, etc.

Anything that reveals remote metrics, is telemetry.

Ygg2··on Fyn: An uv fork with new features, bug fixes, stripped telemetry
If that's the issue, that's a problem. They are telling you X. People, if they tell you, don't give their honest feedback. Or they might be a loud minority.

If you ask people what coffee they want, they will all tell you low-sugar, very bitter black coffee. Then you see what they buy, and they keep buying sugary and creamy coffee that contains almost no caffeine.

Telemetry isn't spying. At least when done properly. How do you figure out rare OOM crashes without some telemetry data? What if the reporter doesn't know how to figure out their OS and installed software that's required for debugging?

I'm NOT saying telemetry should capture everything and sell that data to info brokers. I'm saying, done properly it give you valuable feedback. And you should be transparent about it.

Ygg2··on GitHub appears to be struggling with measly three nines availability
In the future, no one will need more than one and a half nines.
Ygg2··on Fyn: An uv fork with new features, bug fixes, stripped telemetry
Telemetry isn't bad in OSS per se. Without it, it's hard to say how an app is used and how to develop it in the future.
Ygg2··on White-collar AI apocalypse narrative is just another bullshit
No posts found.
Ygg2··on Type resolution redesign, with language changes to taste
> Then you might say that Rust is an expressive programming language.

That's not what I mean. Expressivity allows you to objectively test if two languages are different. The functional/objective/imperative are trying to capture some expressive features.

Using expressivity, you can finally put a Turing machine to that feeling and test it.

> The terminology there already exists and is commonplace, as far as I see.

Missing the point. Message oriented language captures the expressivity of having the ability to send and receive arbitrary methods. This is what I mean.

If OOP or MOP is just a marketing term, then it carries no value.

← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →