HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Typhon

736 karma · joined July 28, 2010

Website's here : http://baalhammon.fr/english.html
submissionscomments
Typhon··on Esperanto as an Asian language
Maybe so, but why include the sentence I quoted, then ?
Typhon··on Esperanto as an Asian language
"Linguists are undecided about Esperanto"

Indifferent would be a better word.

In any case, Esperanto has no feature which set it apart from other European languages, whether in lexicon (obviously) or in grammar, it is thoroughly european (as demonstrated in great detail here : http://jbr.me.uk/ranto/ )

Typhon··on Bees can train each other to use tools
It is fascinating indeed.
Typhon··on Grammar isn't merely part of language (2016)
You know who definitely agrees with you ? Linguists who specialize in conversational analysis, multimodal discourse analysis and interactional sociolinguistics.

It makes me kind of sad when people assume that "Chomsky's work = the whole of linguistics".

Typhon··on Grammar isn't merely part of language (2016)
Actually human languages are much better suited for all kinds of communication : To the best of our knowledge, most animal systems of communication don't allow reference to either the speaker (i.e "I"), the hearer (i.e "you"), or a distant third party (i.e "it"). Even elaborate systems like the bee dance are highly specialized in the type of reference that is possible. In human speech it is possible to talk about things or people that are not here, things that don't exist but may, things that have existed, things that will exist, things that won't exist. Hypotheses, conjectures, and so on, are not part of any other species way of communicating, as far as I know.

Furthermore, all known human languages allow you to attribute utterances to another, earlier speaker, what is known as reported speech (often, though not always as Pirahâ demonstrate, through an embedded clause "He said that X").

Human non-verbal communication (which is EMPHATICALLY NOT to be confused with sign languages), on the other hand, is typically not very expressive. Apart from the admittedly very important, but nevertheless quite specialized domain of human emotion (conveyed by facial expression for instance), it is more or less inadequate for much of what we want to communicate.

Typhon··on Grammar isn't merely part of language (2016)
Not every linguist agree with Chomsky.
Typhon··on No Proton Decay Means Grand Unification Must Wait
Neurons are constantly being replaced

Are they ? As far as I know, neurons last more or less from before birth to death. There is neurogenesis in the hippocampus but it doesn't replace existing neurons, and the new cells themselves last until death.

Typhon··on Ask HN: What is your favorite internet rabbit hole?
Seconded, it's worse (better) than TvTropes, in this regard.
Typhon··on Sam Altman: “YC not going to fire someone over support of a candidate”
I agree that however hateful and ridiculous he gets, Trump is not a nazi. I roll my eyes whenever someone calls him a nazi or implies he is a nazi. For example, this guy : https://twitter.com/paulg/status/785769454516916228?lang=fr

I think there's a contradiction in PG's (and Sam Altman's) public attitude towards Trump and their attitude regarding Thiel.

I mean either Trump is beyond the pale, in which case they should not associate themselves with any of his supporters, or he is not, in which case they should cut the goddamn hyperbole.

Typhon··on We May Never Truly Fathom Other Cultures
I disagree completely with you on this. Nazi violence was just as much a product of culture and social forces than Aztec violence, it's merely much closer to home and we know a lot more about it.

I think this 'outlier excuse' works when talking about serial killers or even criminal gangs, but I'm talking about violence on a much bigger scale, a scale where cultural factors are always contributing.

Typhon··on We May Never Truly Fathom Other Cultures
Well I thought Viet Nam was a more clear cut example of America being barbarous but yeah, Iraq works as well, let's not forget Abu Ghraib.

Anyway, as far as I know, although my country has committed its share of horrible massacres around the world, none of it has happened in my lifetime... I just hope it'll last.

Typhon··on We May Never Truly Fathom Other Cultures
70 years after the Holocaust, 40 years after Cambodia and Viet Nam, 20 years after Rwanda, as Syria is partly occupied by ISIS, what I truly can't fathom is how anyone would single out senseless bloodlust as "that alien thing from a distant dead civilisation we will never understand".
Typhon··on Ask HN: Insider history of the demise of Kodak?
You failed to paste your second link correctly.
Typhon··on [pdf] an example of incorrect behaviour from a senior mathematician
We often hear about that kind of thing happening, but it is rare to see a specific example going into details and making specific accusations towards a specific person.
Typhon··on Letters between Backus and Dijkstra (1979)
What he did say : « I don’t think object-oriented programming is a structuring paradigm that meets my standards of elegance » (https://www.cs.utexas.edu/users/EWD/transcriptions/EWD12xx/E...)

I guess some decided that Dijkstra didn't have enough inflammatory quotes attached to his name and fabricated the other one.

Typhon··on Letters between Backus and Dijkstra (1979)
I could never find a reliable source for this oft-quoted remark about Object-Oriented Programming. As far as I know, Dijkstra never said this, not in this exact phrasing anyway.
Typhon··on Can Multilingualism Survive?: How cities preserve and abandon languages
I thought I'd written 'North America', but apparently I didn't, so yeah, point taken.

Even if there are more minority languages in SE Asia and South America, I'm not sure they're treated better there than in Europe.

Typhon··on Can Multilingualism Survive?: How cities preserve and abandon languages
Tu as tout à fait raison. Pourquoi perdrais-je mon temps à apprendre ta langue pour ton bénéfice, c'est une perte de temps total. Merci de m'avoir ouvert les yeux.

J'aime bien aussi ta deuxième phrase qui sous-entend qu'on ne peut communiquer avec les autres qu'en anglais. Je me demande comment je faisais pour discuter avec mes parents quand j'étais petit. C'est sans doute de là que vient la tragique incommunicabilité qui a marqué mon enfance.

Typhon··on Can Multilingualism Survive?: How cities preserve and abandon languages
Uninflected languages usually have a more complex, constrained syntax, whereas inflected languages are more free.
Typhon··on Can Multilingualism Survive?: How cities preserve and abandon languages
Europe wants to achieve anything in common

It's unclear if "Europe" wants anything of the sort at this point, and you seem to assume that English would be the common language, which is not unreasonable since it's the one currently being used, but it's not politically acceptable, and it'll be worse if the UK finally decides to leave.

Note also that Europe is probably the part of the world where minority languages are in better shape. E.g Catalan is spoken by 4 million native speakers, which is more than all of the native american language speakers combined.

Typhon··on Can Multilingualism Survive?: How cities preserve and abandon languages
It all depend on what you count as connotation, but I'd argue that if anything can be expressed verbally, then it can be translated. There is no such thing as untranslatability.
Typhon··on Can Multilingualism Survive?: How cities preserve and abandon languages
Weirdness of a language is completely subjective, and easyness too.

Overall, the intrinsic qualities of a language matter little if at all in driving its adoption.

Typhon··on Can Multilingualism Survive?: How cities preserve and abandon languages
I'm quite pessimistic concerning the future of multilingualism. Small, isolated communities manage to preserve their language for century, but a community the same size in a big city can lose its language in the space of a generation or two.

EDIT : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8IBfgUNpRsY Note that the title is kinda stupid, it's obviously not their native language if they can barely speak it, and that's kind of the point. Note also that their parents come from a huge language community which is in no danger of disappearing anytime soon and nevertheless, it's not enough.

Typhon··on Can Multilingualism Survive?: How cities preserve and abandon languages
It's much more complicated than that, and unless you know french, I doubt you'd guess what a "logiciel" is or an "ordinateur".

Furthermore, there is no such thing as a "concept that cannot be expressed" in a language. More often than not when people say a language has "no word for X", they turn out to be wrong, and even when they're right, the concept can be expressed through paraphrase.

Typhon··on Tell HN: Apply HN apology and revision
Possibly merely "don't run open-ended online polls with unclear rules for submission". Don't be too quick to generalize.
Typhon··on The internet has been stolen from you. Take it back, nonviolently
I'm not sure what kind of new tools we need ?

All the tools to create personal websites existed more than 20 years ago. They haven't disappeared.

If anything they're probably cheaper, easier to find and to configure now, and also, more diverse, slicker, have more features, etc... And as pointed out by others, distributed social networks have existed for probably about ten years now.

And yes, the fact that the author chose to publish this pompous trite on medium is laughable.

Typhon··on 301 redirects: a dangerous one way street (2012)
This seems yet another example of web professionals not understanding HTTP.

Much like webpages that say "404 not found" with a "200 OK" header.

Typhon··on The Refragmentation
I remember when Paul Graham pointed out that, « internally, most companies are run like communist states » (in http://paulgraham.com/opensource.html )

The picture he paints here of postwar-America as a bland, uniform country dominated by a few mega-institutions reminds me of the USSR.

How ironic.

Typhon··on You never did math in high school
I've already read that somewhere...

http://mysite.science.uottawa.ca/mnewman/LockhartsLament.pdf

EDIT : Oops, I hadn't seen that he already linked to this text. That'll learn me to post too quickly. Oh well.

Typhon··on Voynich Manuscript partially decoded, text is not a hoax, scholar finds
Or maybe it's an existing language in a yet unknown script.

they don't really get how much people in the past and in other cultures are just like us, they like funny, silly and fun things too

Thank you for your condescension. Obviously, philologists, linguists and other specialists are stupidly wasting their time while you have it all figured out based on the "obvious" insight of one rather lame XKCD strip.

← PreviousPage 2 of 6Next →