HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ThunderSizzle

1,178 karma · joined October 12, 2021

submissionscomments
ThunderSizzle··on GitHub Copilot is moving to usage-based billing
It was the only clear model from a user's perspective. Sure, a request may not perform as expected, or end earlier than desired, but it was an agreed to cost that was clear on both sides: 1 enter press in a prompt window = 1 request.

If they wanted to limit what a request can do via their harness, I'm sure they artificially could.

I hate all of the other plans I've seen of here a "credit" or here's a "bucket of usage", and we pull an announced amount from it based on arbitrary info that can't be audited or proven, and most of shat is spent might be entirely useless anyway.

Claude Code has a problem where 1 request could take a significant portion of your 5 hour window, and it's unclear why.

It's much like SEO, where Google sometimes says things that might help, but it's just magic wand eaving hoping something works.

ThunderSizzle··on I'm done making desktop applications (2009)
Most apps that wrap websites like that will force me to update to be able to continue using it
ThunderSizzle··on Changes to GitHub Copilot individual plans
I spoke too soon. I just got told I need to wait 100 hours without warning. Crazy. Same problem I had with claude code.

Time to consider buying hardware, I guess

ThunderSizzle··on Changes to GitHub Copilot individual plans
Over the past month, I started a GHCP ~$12 Pro sub, and found I hit my quota about half way through March or so (but I also wasn't being very...frugal). So I signed up for Claude (~$20 Pro) for a month, and I liked it at first, but the 5 hour window was very annoying, and I hit it quite a bit. The first ~week of April was nice though, and I could use Claude to the limit, and then switch to GHCP. I've sym-linked my instructions so it was more or less easy switching back and forth when I hit a limit.

However, Claude changed their limits so I got to 100% very easily, and when I did hit 100%, I couldn't be given a "window" of snapshoting my work into something for another agent (either future claude window or GHCP agent) to easily pick up mid-work.

I found the lack of visibility into what costs what was very annoying. For $20/month, you get an arbitrary amount of usage that they were changing without notice or alerts or visuals. I didn't renew CC after it expired and just kept with GHCP.

Even with this announcement from GHCP, I haven't run into a limit. I'm considering upgrading to Pro+ if I don't see a limit.

But I stick with Sonnet more or less in both environments. I only used Opus for a couple of planning sessions at the very beginning, but JIT planning is done good enough by the more mid-tier models.

ThunderSizzle··on Changes to GitHub Copilot individual plans
Haiku is complete crap compared to sonnet in GHCP. A basic task in Haiku takes 3 prompts with a lot of correction. 1 prompt in sonnet. It isn't worth a third of the price if I have to fix it twice.
ThunderSizzle··on The creative software industry has declared war on Adobe
I think I'm pointing out that it tries to trivialize a cost, as if everyone is just spending $2000+ dollars on coffee a year. If your doing that, of course you can afford a measly $10.

You don't need to try to equate $10 to something. People know what $10 is.

And I agree - last time I got coffee, it was closer to $10. In a low COLA area, technically speaking.

ThunderSizzle··on OpenClaw isn't fooling me. I remember MS-DOS
Thanks. That is what I suspected. The 3090's in my area seem pretty expensive for a several year old second hand card - they are the same price as a new 5080.

5090 is pretty expensive (~$4000) to justify it over a $10-50 sub. I guess the nice thing is the api side becomes "included", if I ever want to go that route. But if I have a GHCP $40 sub vs a $4000 GC to match it, just on hardware, pay off is at 8 years. If I add in electricity, pay off is probably never.

Sure, the sub can go up in price, but the value proposition for self-running doesn't seem to make sense - especially if I can't at least match Sonnet on GHCP or something like that.

I hope to self-run some not useless LLMs/Agents at some point, but I think this market needs to stabalize first. I just don't like waiting.

ThunderSizzle··on OpenClaw isn't fooling me. I remember MS-DOS
Not really. Groceries have to be planned based on existing pantry state (current manual analysis), and future desired meals. Then produce a delta of what you have and what you want for those different meals.

Then you have a shopping list. You can do the shopping digitally now a days, but once it's delivered, now you have to organize it into the pantry existing stock, probably with a way to ensure older items are used first. This might involve separating out certain ingredients into smaller packaging and freezing some for later use.

That is all very manual, and I don't see how digitizing one part greatly simplifies it, especially if the digitization is error prone.

In a high enough income state, the answer is you hire a personal household chef or something like that. That isn't digitizing the problem- that is outsourcing it.

ThunderSizzle··on OpenClaw isn't fooling me. I remember MS-DOS
Chores, yes. If there was a $180/month where ALL my families chores could be accomplished, I'd consider it.

That means picking up and cleaning the house after 3 kids and a dog. Grocery shopping. Dishes. Laundry. Chores.

Tech crap? Nope.

ThunderSizzle··on OpenClaw isn't fooling me. I remember MS-DOS
So that leads to a question: Is there a physical box I could buy that an amortize over 5-7 years to be half the API cost?

In other words, assuming no price increase, 7 years of that pricing is $15k. Is there hardware I could buy for $7k or less that would be able to replace those API calls or alternativr subs entirely?

I've personally been trying to determine if I should buy a new GC on my aging desktop(s), since their graphic cards can't really handle LLMs)

ThunderSizzle··on The creative software industry has declared war on Adobe
I don't pay for $5 coffee. I make my coffee at home, from my own grind, with just some half and half. Sure, I splurged and paid for maybe a $100 grinder or something, but that is being used for years, meaning the cost per cup is abysmal.

It seems very odd we normalize coffee being $5.

ThunderSizzle··on The economics of software teams: Why most engineering orgs are flying blind
That's the difference between programming and software engineering.

A software engineer should be able to talk directly to customers to capture requirements, turn that into spec sheet, create an estimate and a bunch of work items, write the whole system (or involve other developers/engineers/programmers to woek on their work items), and finally be able to verify and test the whole system.

That entire role is software engineering. Many in the industry suck at most of the parts and only like the programming part.

I think the hardest part is requirements gathering (e.g. creating organized and detailed notes) and offloading work planned work to other developers in a neat way, generally speaking, based on what I see. In other words, human friction areas.

ThunderSizzle··on How Pope Leo is pushing back on divine justification of war
Denouncing is an odd word to use or expect. A a Christian isn't going to "denounce" the Bible, even if it's the Old Testament.

I think the proper way to put it is seeing the Old Testament through the vision of Jesus Christ as the Messiah and fulfillment of the Old Testament, which itself is complicated and confusing. It really confused St. Paul when he realized through his vision the Truth, and it took time for him to reconcile his knowledge of Scripture with the reality of Christ.

Regardless, too many Protestants find that hard, because that admits that Christ fulfilled the Jewish faith, and that is "antisemitic"...see Ted Cruz as an example of that opinion. He thinks fulfillment theology is some sort of error, but it's exactly what the apostles came to believe and practice.

Anyway, I hope more Christians come to listen to the current Pope. I could understand ignoring Pope Francis, as he was relatively inconsistent and incoherent, especially for English speakers, but Pope Leo has not shown the same negatives yet.

ThunderSizzle··on How Pope Leo is pushing back on divine justification of war
Please elaborate what semi-perverde form of Catholicism JD Vance follows.

Biden promoted direct theology against church teaching. The most obvious was his public and private stance on abortion, and beyond that, the actual work he did to bring about more evil through that dark ritual.

ThunderSizzle··on How Pope Leo is pushing back on divine justification of war
Considering Christians should be putting the New Testament on a higher order than the Old, it should be trivial to not be stuck in the Old.

You probably can thank Christian Zionism and sola scriptura for people forgetting about Jesus while talking about the OT endlessly.

Both of those heresies truly derive from a sense of individual automony and authority, placing the individual nearly equal with God

ThunderSizzle··on How Pope Leo is pushing back on divine justification of war
Many Catholics were Democrats, although their recent insanity in the last 10 years made many realize the Democrats have nothing resembling them.

Many Catholics currently feel politically lost, as weird as that is. You have so many "Catholics" running around DC, but few of them can or will regurgitate any of the teachings of the Church, Biden being the most recent prominent example.

Many are hopeful that JD Vance might finally fill that gap, but atheists and Evangelicals will probably keep their alliance growing rather than permit traditional Catholicism to have a revival politically.

ThunderSizzle··on Claude Code users hitting usage limits 'way faster than expected'
All I know is I never want to hear another person talk about how my personal electrical usage is excessive after all the power usage needed for these data centers. My house should be able to feel comfortable in the summer if we're building these many data centers.
ThunderSizzle··on Claude Code users hitting usage limits 'way faster than expected'
What started that though?
ThunderSizzle··on DoesItAgeVerify: The age verification status of Open Source Operating Systems
Can minors really not have email accounts?
ThunderSizzle··on AI overly affirms users asking for personal advice
Want a new IP address? Reset your router or cycle it. Typically it'll procure a new IP address from the ISP.

I guess that makes IP banning residential nodes even more stupid.

ThunderSizzle··on No Terms. No Conditions
Liable of what and to what?
ThunderSizzle··on An incoherent Rust
C# isnt a duck type language (well, you can do that via dynamic keyword, but I don't know who would do that typically).

Most integration libraries in Nuget (aka c#'s cargo) are AB type libraries.

E.g. DI Container: Autofac Messaging Library: MediatR Integration: MediatR.Extensions.Autofac.DependencyInjection

There are many examples of popular libraries like this in that world.

ThunderSizzle··on An update on Steam / GOG changes for OpenTTD
This makes me wonder why squatter's rights are not a thing here...but I don't know much about the current and previous legal status of the open genres like OpenTTD.
ThunderSizzle··on Node.js needs a virtual file system
I think that goes back to whether they are programmers vs engineers.

Engineers will focus on professionalism of the end product, even if they used AI to generate most of the product.

And I'm not going by "title", but by mindset. Most of my fellow engineers are not - they are just programmers - as in, they don't care about the non-coding part of the job at all.

ThunderSizzle··on Beyond has dropped “meat” from its name and expanded its high-protein drink line
Diet has less effect on cholesterol than activity levels.

Eating cholesterol doesn't translate to cholesterol in the blood.

ThunderSizzle··on Node.js needs a virtual file system
For half my coworkers, their LLM code is better than their code.
ThunderSizzle··on LLMs can be exhausting
Emphasis on the "terrible" part of the junior.

The cheaper models can't be taught or improved due to their inherit limitations, which makes it a huge pain to even try with even the simplest of tasks. Perpetually, no matter your instruction file(s).

ThunderSizzle··on Ageless Linux – Software for humans of indeterminate age
Since schooling closer to home obviously solves this problem, and a host of many other problems, and doesn't introduce any real problems (bad schools don't save kids from bad parents, which seems to be a rebuttal to home-based education, it would seem to me the answer is obvious:

Return to a single income household economy and bring education closer to the home, if not outright in the home.

ThunderSizzle··on Lenovo’s new ThinkPads score 10/10 for repairability
Jokes on you—humans write trash all the time.
ThunderSizzle··on Ars Technica fires reporter after AI controversy involving fabricated quotes
Agreed. Modern news is beyond lazy, and is not journalism by any means. Too many talking heads do nothing but sit behind a screen watching others for what to say next.

Granted, a few of the remaining newspapers I'm aware of run business awards (Best restaurant, etc), and the way to win is via wining and dining them, even though the paper claims it's based on people's votes.

That style of thinking - of entitlement - probably brought the lack of interest in both cable news and traditional web/paper outlets - as the younger generations started to see through it more.

← PreviousPage 4 of 29Next →