HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

SudarshanP

163 karma · joined May 2, 2010

http://www.hackernewsers.com/users/SudarshanP.html
submissionscomments
SudarshanP··on [dead]
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3642570 is a relevant thread. It discusses "Why Anti-Authoritarians are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill". Once Feynman was diagnosed as mentally ill... Great care is needed before labeling people as "needing fixing.". It is probably not a good idea to make everybody act and behave like everybody else.
SudarshanP··on The Future Is So Bright, it's Dematerializing
Robots/Automation already grows crops, builds houses and produces goods we use. 6 people are involved in the production of millions of TVs at Panasonic. Foxconn is adding millions of robots to its workforce. While not a virtual world, it definitely is a growing into a more digitally operated world.

Ubiquitous surveillance and a swarm of drones doing policing probably is as effective as most law enforcement is. I don't like it though... but not liking something does not make it less effective.

In the new world, the value of sweat is falling, but the value of each person's time is improving.

SudarshanP··on Why does HN generate unique URL's for the 'more' pages?
I have a suggestion for a hack that would make life a little more pleasant for those who do not mind running Javascript while not affecting those who want to use the site as is. The script can be implemented by the community and hosted on Git. PG can just include the script in the arc code with just a "one line change".

The JS will just fetch the initial n pages and allow easy navigation using the more button. It will be visually very similar to what we have now. If the community cares it can become much more richer in functionality. If PG refuses, at least there r enough HN users who are annoyed by this bug that we can create a Chrome plugin for HN that fixes this. I can probably write something like this myself. But probably the community can first formulate excatly what the plugin should/should not do. Does such a plugin already exist? Is it a bad idea to solve it this way? Would the additional burden on the servers be too high to be worth it?

SudarshanP··on 2 Billion Jobs to Disappear by 2030
http://matternet.net/ Point to point delivery may not be such a far fetched idea technologically. Quadcopters are becoming more and more common. But legal and security hurdles may slow down the adoption of such services.
SudarshanP··on I have a bad feeling about this
http://paulgraham.com/wealth.html
SudarshanP··on What Silicon Valley gets wrong about math education again and again
Did I say something inappropriate?
SudarshanP··on What Silicon Valley gets wrong about math education again and again
I think the author is fussing around the wrong problem. I guess the situation is something like this.

Incompetent/bored math teacher < khan academy < better online learning platform < Good math teacher.

The number of bad math teachers across the whole planet is staggering considering that we are nearly 7 billion people on the planet especially more so in the developing and underdeveloped countries. Khan academy sets a reasonable good lowest common denominator education that our next generation of students can receive both in quality and coverage. Competition will just push this bar even higher.

To replace good teachers we may have to wait for deep AI even if wanted to do that. Till then KA, Udacity etc. can produce more autonomous students who can make better use of a great teacher's time.

SudarshanP··on Khan Academy: It’s Different This Time
Education is already structured like game with every every feature of gamification like points(scores) and grades(levels) and Leaderboards and so on... But it is a very boring and badly designed game.

Playing a physical game like football and maintaining a good physique for winning a football game seems a lot more fun than exercising to not be sick. Same thing could be said about khan academy. Would it not be awesome that a student can learn 50+25=75 without having to pull out an iPhone to calculate the same... Does it matter whether he did it for energy points or self improvement. A student with good "skills" will likely find it easier to navigate more meaningful content in the future like graph interpretation without even noticing that "the algorithmic skill" came in handy. I totally agree that something like KA is not a solution but just piece of the jigsaw puzzle.

One of the students of the stanford online classes ended up making a cellphone powered self driving car by going through the online class. While the student got the basic framework and ideas from the class, he must have learned a huge amount of stuff putting it all together. Learning is very human no doubt. But it can happen in the minds of the learner. Thrun or Andrew Ng do not need to actually talk to the student by standing a few feet away. They just need to empower and inspire students to work on awesome projects. The students can learn by themselves and each other.

SudarshanP··on The 'Startup Boom' is a disguised jobs fair for big corporations
Here is a suggestion for those who build a statup for getting acquired as a team. Build a start up centered around an opensource project that is awesome but not necessarily profitable. A Big$ company could acquire the group. They get a bunch of top quality programmers. Your creation wont be sunset. The opensource project may develop a life of its own at least through forking. At least it is better than creating a project that will be terminated on acquisition or lack of business model.
SudarshanP··on Handwriting to LaTeX maths
They rely on analysing your strokes. So images cannot be used .
SudarshanP··on 25 Startup Ideas for 2012
Reading DNA without taking it out of a cell sounds like such an awesome idea. All you need is bunch of proteins to do that. All those proteins are just DNA sequences. possibly even Biobricks. So all that translates to "Just introduce a plasmid into a cell and the necessary woodoo happens inside the cell... which sets off some kind of cascade which can be read out by say a CCD or voltage detector." So the startup is all about just designing DNA sequences for protein. And these days even novices have begun to design proteins. This is just brilliant!!! Instead of 1000$ per genome how about 99 cents?? Of course I have no clue how long it should take to reach there beyond extrapolating on a log graph...

Someone here stated the moore's law for sequencing. Which while true needs disruptive startups for each transition. Fortunately or unfortunately these startups dont work like an intel doing similar drudgery year after year to continue doubling... each major leap happens by a radical switch of strategy. As he states the case of Ion Torrent, each step centers around an awesome breaktrhough. But it also raises the question... Will the cost of computation become a bottleneck for a 99 cent genome. Sequencing and synthesis are a lot more useful than just medical diagnosis. Let us not undermine the value of a 99 cent genome or a 1 cent genome sequencing/synthesis capability.

SudarshanP··on How Much Is an Astronaut's Life Worth?
What is the risk a mountaineer or fighter pilot or car racer facing? Should we ban these people from taking calculated risks? Are there some stats about how risky various adventure sports are compared to Space Exploration?

Another question is what is the worth of revisiting the moon to set up a hyper expensive tourist camp there? Should it not be NASA's job to focus on research that lays the groundwork for entrepreneurs like Elon Musk to expand human presence beyond Earth?

SudarshanP··on Average Is Over
The economy does a lot to give people a delusion of purpose. If u r scared that ur kids will starve, or ur wife will go without healthcare, ur focus is now on survival. If I know that "the system will take care of me and my family", I will suddenly have a lot of free time. So I now need a philosophical or religious strategy to find meaning in my life. Just consider what is already happening in the so called services economy... a lot of it is pointless paper pushing coz we have not yet simplified it to the level necessary. Just imagine if the entire banking and insurance industry was replaced by a single web scale app with a few simple rules... u'd have a huge chunk of people sitting at home. All these people "remain busy" because of the economy... I wonder whether boredom or drudgery(hand everyone spoon instead of a shovel??) is better...
SudarshanP··on Blindly submitting content to HN, good or bad?
Can some arc hacker explain the algorithm for the rest of us here. As far as I know the rank of post declines exponentially over time and improves with upvotes. Does the decay also depend upon the rate of submission and the points earned by previous submissions?
SudarshanP··on Y Combinator’s Short-sighted War Against Hollywood
like programmers/doctors/teachers?
SudarshanP··on Request for Startups: Kill Hollywood.
Hollywood only allows a tiny fraction of people with talent to suceed... The remaining 99% who never got into hollywood would want to work if they could succeed. Probably becoming millionares rather than billionares.
SudarshanP··on Request for Startups: Kill Hollywood.
Free Software is not Just Vi or Emacs. It evolves into Android, Firefox, Chrome, Eclipse, jQuery, etc. You may get to see work before it is fully ready... But finished products in Free software can also be user friendly and mainstream. And for niches it serves, Free software does a far better job than than the Lowest common denominator that suits the masses.
SudarshanP··on Show HN: Charts for Hacker News Polls
Awesome! It would be nice to have prev and next button for the chart detail page. Even better if u could add a swipe for mobile devices
SudarshanP··on Startup will wash your car wherever it is located
A useful service could be N washes per year with a minimum interval. The user chooses N. Out of this a fraction would be "on-demand". The others would be optimized for availability of resources like manpower and suitable places where there is no objection to washing. For Eg. the user can indicate some travel patterns which can help identify optimal schedules. This approach will enable the user to have a generally clean car and summon a cleanup when there is a special occasion. Such a subscription service would charge lesser per wash.
SudarshanP··on An Investment Manager's View on the Top 1%
When Google's employees started to become rich, they were taught the best investment was index funds; that investment firms like Goldman were just out to grab their fees and didn't perform any better over the long run.

http://www.tradersnarrative.com/the-best-investment-advice-y...

SudarshanP··on Take me to Silicon Valley: 19 year old designer seeking opportunity
The Economy is cyclical. The best time to grow is during a bubble. In a couple of years when all those me too incubators have burned themselves up there will be fewer people willing to tunnel him into the US... He could do his Graduation during a bust.
SudarshanP··on Tmpltr - jsFiddle clone for realtime JSON templating
It would be awesome to have handlebars support.
SudarshanP··on The Recording Industry Likes to Make Me Look Like an Asshole
The author claims "And I support record labels, because many of the albums I love would not exist without label financing, and I might not know about them if not for label marketing and promotion."

While this statement may be true about "the particular albums this particular author likes" it is untrue in general. A good song will get popular through various means. An artist does not need his life to be controlled by a middle man so that the audience can be advertised to. There are many ways in which the word spreads in the 21st century. The hard thing for an artist is to acquire the minimum artistic ability which probably means years of toil to reach a level when some one cares to listen to you. Making a song is a relatively inexpensive task. And once u have a reputation, you have mechanisms like kickstarter to fund your project. More alternatives will evolve as the recording industry dies.

SudarshanP··on HTML5 Map of the the World Migrations using SVG, Raphael.js and offline storage
The blue arrow next to the arrivals and departures selection, acts like a radio buttion, but looks like an arrow. This is misleading... I was wondering why it said "Arrivals => Deprture" which looked weird... only after i clicked around, it was obvious that it was acting like a radio button.
SudarshanP··on How to build the world's most extraordinary town
http://seasteading.org/ is an idea on similar lines by the free market libertarians and http://www.thezeitgeistmovement.com/ for the more communist minded libertarians led by Jaques Fresco.
SudarshanP··on Today I launched my solo project, Listry. Feedback/suggestions appreciated
I tried starting a list of "shops in india that would be of interest to Hackers and Makers": http://www.listry.com/list/83050/list-of-shops-in-india-that... on the lines of "Coffee shops in Cambridge, MA"... And I added two shops that I had painstaking discovered a few months ago for buying a few things I needed.

I was a bit annoyed that getting things you want from your own country(minimizes shipping and taxes) is still so hard in the era of google. So I wanted to share it with the world hoping that others would populate the list further and I could benefit from this. But it was voted -2. Now I have no complaints against that... Maybe such a list is unsuitable for this type of site. But I think it may be a smarter idea for you to make it more obvious as to what constitutes a bad list. Why "Coffee shops in Campridge" is kosher and why "Shops interesting for hackers in India" is not.

SudarshanP··on Today I launched my solo project, Listry. Feedback/suggestions appreciated
Nice Site.

Feature request: For each list allow users to link to lists in the wild. For Eg there could be a 10 reasons to quit smoking on some magazine. The user may not want to recreate the list, but just provide a bookmark. You could even provide a "listify" bookmarklet. For Eg Paul Graham's list of reasons why startups fail and a lot of startup failure story post mortems could be Supplimentary materials for a list of the same name.

The list which begins life as a list of useful bookmarks to external lists about the same topic could over time be deduplicated by the community to create a Master list that would be much more useful than the external lists themselves.

SudarshanP··on If Software Is Eating The World, Why Don't Coders Get Any Respect?
The lawyers/MBAs and doctors will be disrupted. This is already happening... Then they will be on the streets. all the low level jobs in Backoffice and law is getting outsourced. So if u r getting into law... u should actually be capable of creating value. Just look at all those industries that Apple Amazon etc are disrupting... No Newspaper also means the news paper does not need expensive lawyers, MBAs etc. Of course you could say Apple,Amazon,Google etc. will need the lawyers MBAs etc. But these few players need far less external help and glue coz they have captured most of the supply chain.

Imagine a device where u put a drop of blood/urine etc and out pops a diagnosis. Imagine a pharma company in a box which synthesizes a medicine on demand using basic raw materials. Then there are diagnostic solutions like IBMs Watson...

Education and healthcare will take much longer than Print/Retail/Music/Advertising/Communications to get disrupted... When these get disrupted, they will hurt more than they needed to coz of enjoying the protectionism.

There will always be demand for Good Doctors/Teachers/Programmers/Lawyers/MBAs... But those whose existence depends solely depends on protectionism or monopolies are going to see their jobs disrupted.

SudarshanP··on Twitter Bootstrap
It would be awesome if there was a forked Django/Rails/Sproutcore framework with tight integration with something like Twitter Bootstrap.

That way you would have a super awesome looking app right from the start.

The pros can work on the lean frameworks while the lazy ones like me can hop onto the shoulders of the giants ;-)!

SudarshanP··on Show HN: Codecademy.com, the easiest way to learn to code
Coffeescript and other languages that compile to Javascript could be an interesting starting point and would need the least work for u guys...
← PreviousPage 4 of 6Next →