HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

SirHumphrey

476 karma · joined August 29, 2024

submissionscomments
SirHumphrey··on The engine of Germany's wealth is blocking its future
It's also that the west collectively convinced themselves that the economy could be built on high value knowledge work and services and manufacturing will be handled by someone else. Of course people would rather live near some offices, or maybe a workshop than a heavy industrial site...

The transition of my country from a socialist to a western capitalist system included a mass closure of heavy industry and what remains is dying a slow death of high energy costs. I remember when a coal mine closed there were all those marvelous ideas how the area would transition to high tech programming jobs; the thing that actually saved the area was a fuse manufacturing plant.

SirHumphrey··on You Don't Need a Vector Database
I was asking myself the whole article “what does this mysterious semantic search api actually do?” and was a bit underwhelmed when the result came out to be - managed vector database.
SirHumphrey··on Terence Tao, at 8 years old (1984) [pdf]
There is a slightly unexplored tangent in Brave New World about an experiment on Cyprus, where a society of humans bread to be intelligent descended in to civil war because nobody wanted to do menial work.
SirHumphrey··on The Singularity will occur on a Tuesday
Maybe it was, maybe he just writes that way. At some point somebody will read so much LLM text that they will start emulating AI unknowingly.

I just don’t care anymore. If the article is good I will continue reading it, if it’s bad I will stop. I don’t care if a machine or a human produced unpleasant reading material.

SirHumphrey··on Europe’s next-generation weather satellite sends back first images
Well, at least in my experience with EU projects, they tend to be much more restrictive with data sharing than equivalent US institutions: e.g. a lot of paid EUMET data has publicly available NOAA equivalents - though usually of worse quality.
SirHumphrey··on Updates to our web search products and Programmable Search Engine capabilities
I can manage fine with other search indexes for English language searches; weather that is because others got better or google got worse i cannot tell, though I suspect the latter.

But for searching in more niche languages google is usually the only decent option and I have little hope that others will ever reach the scale where they could compete.

SirHumphrey··on Dead Internet Theory
Maybe, but at least in my circles it’s a structure thing- until the group actually can be organised in a single chat sanely something else will be used- but as soon as multiple chats are required the thing is moved on discord.
SirHumphrey··on After 25 years, Wikipedia has proved that news doesn't need to look like news
Admittedly I do not know how much of a sensitive issue this is, but I find it surprising that the name given at birth is not mentioned anywhere on the Wikipedia page, even though in other cases of name change usually "Name (born Old Name)" is written.
SirHumphrey··on TimeCapsuleLLM: LLM trained only on data from 1800-1875
I don't know if any dataset of pre 1904 writing would be large enough to train a model that would be smart enough. I suspect that current sized SOTA models would at least get to special relativity, but for general relativity and quantum mechanics I am less sure.
SirHumphrey··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
So they can write a strongly worded letter?
SirHumphrey··on GOG is getting acquired by its original co-founder
And Balkan on the southeastern.
SirHumphrey··on GOG is getting acquired by its original co-founder
Amazon was basically conducting a price war founded by AWS division. Unless GOG is trying to undercut Steam this is a bit apples and oranges.
SirHumphrey··on Kidnapped by Deutsche Bahn
Underfunded and wasteful are not opposites. When there is not enough money to do things properly there is often a lot of duct tapping going on which waste available resources without fixing anything. There is scarcely anything more expensive in government than saving money.
SirHumphrey··on Some Epstein file redactions are being undone
The amount of things Trump did circumventing Congressional approval might suggest that he does not a clean pass even though Republicans have majority in both the house and the senate.
SirHumphrey··on Some Epstein file redactions are being undone
One can only imagine what America not fighting an attack on NATO member would have on nuclear proliferation.
SirHumphrey··on Clair Obscur having its Indie Game Game Of The Year award stripped due to AI use
No, the only difference is that image generators are a much fuller replacement for "artists" than for programmers currently. The use of quotation marks was not meant to be derogatory, I sure many of them are good artists, but what they were mostly commissioned for was not art - it was backgrounds for websites, headers for TOS updates, illustrations for ads... There was a lot more money in this type of work the same way as there is a lot more money in writing react sites, or scripts to integrate active directory logins in to some ancient inventory management system than in developing new elegant algorithms.

But code is complicated, and hallucinations lead to bugs and security vulnerabilities so it's prudent to have programmers check it before submitting to production. An image is an image. It may not be as nice as a human drawn one, but for most cases it doesn't matter anyway.

The AI "stole" or "learned" in both cases. It's just that one side is feeling a lot more financial hardship as the result.

SirHumphrey··on How China built its ‘Manhattan Project’ to rival the West in AI chips
Yes? The replication of the foreign capability domestically has been a driving force of China's economy for the last 20 - 30 years. No major R&D program in which china is catching up or even exceeding the western capability was started there, even the quite recent AI boom is mostly based on the work of American companies and labs.

If anything the constant underestimation of Chinese capabilities caused "the west" to react way to late.

SirHumphrey··on Independent review of UK national security law warns of overreach
>>> Old farts making laws about things they know nothing about.

We should probably stop saying and believing that. This is basically the UK government making a deal to the developers they cannot refuse: cooperate (install backdoors) or get prosecuted. The French tried to do something similar not so long ago.

A decade ago politicians genuinely didn’t know much about the internet so most of the laws were terribly ill informed good ideas. The new sweep of internet legislation like chat control, age verification and banning of vpns are much more dangerous because those pushing know exactly what they are doing.

SirHumphrey··on No AI* Here – A Response to Mozilla's Next Chapter
By M series and amd strix halo. You don't actually need a gpu, if the manufacturer knows that the use case will be running transformer models a more specialized NPU coupled with higher memory bandwidth of on the package RAM.

This will not result in locally running SOTA sized models, but it could result in a percentage of people running 100B - 200B models, which are large enough to do some useful things.

SirHumphrey··on No AI* Here – A Response to Mozilla's Next Chapter
I use it a lot more now I know it's done locally.
SirHumphrey··on I'm Kenyan. I don't write like ChatGPT, ChatGPT writes like me
I can’t guess how old they are but there is some sense in doing that if you think about it like math exercises. It makes for terrible prose but the only way to get the ability to write more complicated sentences is to practice writing them, even when they are not necessary.

The problem is that teachers stop pushing complexity for complexity’s sake way to late.

SirHumphrey··on IBM CEO says there is 'no way' spending on AI data centers will pay off
Until China sees it valuable to fund open weights SOTA-ish models, even the winner might struggle. There is very little capture - protocols are mostly standard so models are mostly interchangeable and if you are trying to raise prices enough to break even on the whole operation, somebody else can probably profitably run inference cheaper.
SirHumphrey··on A Love Letter to FreeBSD
I would run something like that if it would exist - illumos zones sound quite appealing as does a more native support for ZFS.
SirHumphrey··on AI has a deep understanding of how this code works
Why are you submitting a PR if you do not use the software? You could just as easily donate the money that you spent producing 13k LOC to the project and they would spend it to use Claud on things that need to be fixed or just pay themselves to fix things manually.

This way there were hours, kwh, and dollars wasted on something that will be of no use to anyone.

SirHumphrey··on China reaches energy milestone by "breeding" uranium from thorium
The truth is that nuclear power is not that financially attractive at the present and would the price of uranium rise enough that breeders would become economically viable most countries would just stop bothering with nuclear power altogether.
SirHumphrey··on New Glenn Update
But 26.3% of the world’s GDP.
SirHumphrey··on Cognitive and mental health correlates of short-form video use
I would caution against reading too much at this stage, even though the researchers were very careful to talk about only correlation, a lot of people here seem to read causation. This are population studies so the variables are not independent.

The argument became a bit unpopular because it has been (ab)used by smoking companies and gambling establishments but while an addictive substance can addict anybody, who gets addicted is not random. Watching of TikTok reals is a time wasting and dopamine inducing behavior - while I don't doubt they are bad and I avoid them, you may also be selecting for depressed or lonely people.

This I only write because people sometimes get in to an obsessive social media cutting frenzy spending effort that would improve their lives much quicker spent fixing diet or exercise.

SirHumphrey··on Do not put your site behind Cloudflare if you don't need to
Cloudflair is what happens when a platonic idea of the internet clashes with market realities. All the questions posed are very important but most websites are run by businesses with motives about as pure as Cloudflair’s.

As for people… A programming club I attended is filled with people who run homelabs, use Linux and generally dislike anything corporate. The project to switch communication of discord is now more than a year old. I do feel sometimes that resistance against corporate internet is futile.

SirHumphrey··on Linux on the Fujitsu Lifebook U729
It runs well but battery life is quite a bit worse than on macos.
SirHumphrey··on The Manuscripts of Edsger W. Dijkstra
Working a bit with some old programming languages that are very natural language like (FORTRAN’s .and. and .or. or COBOL’s IS GREATER THAN) I don’t think the readability increases that much, maybe the benefit is more approachability. In a more symbolic language skimming code is much easier because the symbols provide visible distinction between more syntactic control flow and the declared functions, variables etc.
← PreviousPage 2 of 6Next →