It's fascinating. Some more critical observers are very disappointed with performance like this. I've seen comments about how dumb it seems. I don't think it does, I think you are bang on. It seems somewhat like a conversation with a child.
126 karma · joined May 27, 2022
Admittedly, small talk is only part of the problem. There are other aspects such as eye contact, tone of speech and so on. Read a book like 'The Charisma Myth'. Practice on 'peripheral' strangers, those who you encounter regularly but are not close to. You'll be anxious, you'll feel awkward but I promise you that you will get better. Quite often now it's natural to me, but I can always fall back on learned patterns when I'm feeling awkward. People now tell me I'm very easy to speak to. 6 years ago I would have been described as awkward.
I recently was diagnosed with ADHD, primarily in attentive. Honestly, this explains my 'naturally' poor social skills. But I learned anyway. You can too!