HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

MPSimmons

4,597 karma · joined July 20, 2010

Author of http://www.standalone-sysadmin.com
submissionscomments
MPSimmons··on X blames users for Grok-generated CSAM; no fixes announced
>I wouldn't even think twice about banning CSAM outputs.

Same, honestly. And you'll probably catch a whole lot of actual legitimate usage in that net, but it's worth it.

But you'll also miss some. You'll always miss some, even with the best guard rails. But 99% is better than 0%, I agree.

> ... and just expect the user to use it legally?

I don't think it's entirely the responsibility of the builder/supplier/service to ensure this, honestly. I don't think it can be. You can sell hammers, and you can't guarantee that the hammer won't be used to hurt people. You can put spray cans behind cages and require purchasers to be 18 years old, but you can't stop the adult from vandalism. The person has to be held responsible at a certain point.

MPSimmons··on X blames users for Grok-generated CSAM; no fixes announced
I am, in general, pretty anti-Elon, so I don't want to be seen as taking _his_ side here, and I am definitely anti-CSAM, so let's shift slightly to derivative IP generation.

Where does the line fall between provider responsibility when providing a tool that can produce protected work, and personal responsibility for causing it to generate that work?

It feels somewhat more clearcut when you say to AI, "Draw me an image of Mickey Mouse", but why is that different than photocopying a picture of Mickey Mouse, and using Photoshop to draw a picture of Mickey Mouse? Photo copiers will block copying a dollar bill in many cases - should they also block photos of Mickey Mouse? Should they have received firmware updates whenever Steamboat Willy fell into public domain, such that they can now be allowed to photocopy that specific instance of Mickey Mouse, but none other?

This is a slippery slope, the idea that a person using the tool should hold the tool responsible for creating "bad" things, rather than the person themselves being held responsible.

Maybe CSAM is so heinous as to be a special case here. I wouldn't argue against it specifically. But I do worry that it shifts the burden of responsibility onto the AI or the model or the service or whatever, rather than the person.

Another thing to think about is whether it would be materially different if the person didn't use Grok, but instead used a model on their own machine. Would the model still be responsible, or would the person be responsible?

MPSimmons··on Total monthly number of StackOverflow questions over time
Oh, that's good that they added them. I stopped being active in on the sites a long time ago, so I missed that.
MPSimmons··on Total monthly number of StackOverflow questions over time
The fact that they basically stopped the ability to ask 'soft' questions without a definite answer made it very frustrating. There's no definitive answer to a question about best practices, but you can't ask people to share their experiences or recommendations.
MPSimmons··on Cardiovascular disease is a solved problem
>Lp(a) levels are almost purely genetically determined and so elevated Lp(a) is essentially due to a poor roll of the genetic dice... For simplicity, we will devote little further attention to either of these secondary risk factors”

As someone who rolled poorly on those genetic dice, I would like to complain. But also, disregarding a factor that impacts 20%[1] of the population seems disingenuous.

[1] - https://familyheart.org/family-sharing-tools/high-lpa-family...

MPSimmons··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
As far as I can tell from the narrative, Venezuela was basically serving as a puppet state for China, and if that's true, I would probably give that as the primary reason, but who knows. Maybe it's because Venezuela did poorly in the FIFA World Cup qualifier and this was action dictated by his recent peace prize award.

On a slightly more serious note, the charges against Maduro were actually filed in 2020: https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/pr/nicol-s-maduro-moros...

MPSimmons··on Flock Exposed Its AI-Powered Cameras to the Internet. We Tracked Ourselves
Gonna have to write more speeding tickets to pay for these, I guess
MPSimmons··on The New Right-Wing Tech Intelligentsia
Yeah, this is definitely an n-dimensional modeling space. Left/Right wing are only one axis, and as far as I can tell, not even the most definitive in terms of determining if I agree with someone's perspective. I think that would be the authoritarian / anti-authoritarian. Lots of left wing people are still authoritarians, but between those two, you can get a _decent_ feeling of where someone is with regard to the national politics.
MPSimmons··on Designing a Passive Lidar Detector Device
Agreed, I immediately thought of vehicles, but this is cool too.
MPSimmons··on Adafruit: Arduino’s Rules Are ‘Incompatible With Open Source’
No, not like there are with Arduino. Arduino is definitely the best I know of for embedded programming, and it has its place there, but I stopped trying to do real work with it.
MPSimmons··on Adafruit: Arduino’s Rules Are ‘Incompatible With Open Source’
Yeah, for sure. My more... uhh.. creative toys are definitely not ESPhome, but it's super cool that I can solder on a few wires to a DHT-11 and throw it in a closet with the weakest USB power plug I own, and end up with a great sensor.
MPSimmons··on Adafruit: Arduino’s Rules Are ‘Incompatible With Open Source’
I also really appreciate how routine ESPHome has made building sensor networks in my home. Really just incredibly useful software.
MPSimmons··on Adafruit: Arduino’s Rules Are ‘Incompatible With Open Source’
Ever since I got involved with Espressif's ESP32/ESP8266 chips, I haven't even thought about arduinos, except to download the UI, but you don't even need to do that with the right VSCode extensions to make your life better.

I do keep meaning to try this though - https://platformio.org/

MPSimmons··on Ask HN: Is starting a personal blog still worth it in the age of AI?
As a bit of personal advice from a former blogger who had a million+ visitors per year, it's not about anything except your readers and the community you build. AI might have facts on everything, but AI content will not build a community and enrich the people's lives who engage with the site.

When everything else is a computer, be a human.

MPSimmons··on Science Communications on YouTube
I don't know to what extent it has directly impacted his quality, but it appears that Derek sold Veritasium to a private equity firm

https://www.electrify.video/post/electrify-completes-majorit...

MPSimmons··on 1300 Still Images from the Animated Films of Hayao Miyazaki's Studio Ghibli (2023)
Warning: I thought the first 10 minutes of Up were the saddest thing I'd ever watch, but then I watched Grave of the Fireflies.
MPSimmons··on SpaceX in Talks for Share Sale That Would Boost Valuation to $800B
What a ridiculous, intellectually dishonest comment. Why even spend the time?
MPSimmons··on Microsoft Download Center Archive
PowerToys (https://legacyupdate.net/download-center/powertoys) used to be on my "first software to install" list on a new machine. Between Tweak UI and Deskman, you could _almost_ get a minimal X Windows-like UI. Get those set up and add on LiteStep (http://litestep.net/) and you were pretty much good to go, with the exceptions of the kernel, network stack, and CLI toolset, of course.
MPSimmons··on The RAM shortage comes for us all
Awesome charts, thanks! I think it bears out that the multiplier for older hardware isn't as extreme as the newer hardware, right?
MPSimmons··on The RAM shortage comes for us all
Undoubtably the cost would go up, but nobody is building out datacenters full of DDR4, either, so I don't figure it would go up nearly as much as DDR5 is right now.
MPSimmons··on The RAM shortage comes for us all
This reminds me of the recent LaurieWired video presenting a hypothetical of, "what if we stopped making CPUs": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L2OJFqs8bUk

Spoiler, but the answer is basically that old hardware rules the day because it lasts longer and is more reliable of timespans of decades.

DDR5 32GB is currently going for ~$330 on Amazon

DDR4 32GB is currently going for ~$130 on Amazon

DDR3 32GB is currently going for ~50 on Amazon (4x8GB)

For anyone where cost is a concern, using older hardware seems like a particularly easy choice, especially if a person is comfortable with a Linux environment, since the massive droves of recently retired Windows 10 incompatible hardware works great with your Linux distro of choice.

MPSimmons··on Bring bathroom doors back to hotels
Growing up in West Virginia, I was in a moderately sized city (40k people) but when traveling to smaller high schools for football games, you'd often find a shared latrine as the bathroom, and everyone who needed to pee would just crowd around a long sink thing and just let 'er rip. No idea what it was like in the ladies'
MPSimmons··on How Charles M Schulz created Charlie Brown and Snoopy (2024)
Interesting, you know more about it than I do, I suppose. Do you know of any source for Jim discussing how/why he started Garfield?
MPSimmons··on How Charles M Schulz created Charlie Brown and Snoopy (2024)
I mean, even originally, Garfield strips had some substance, but Jim Davis really liked money, I think...
MPSimmons··on Microsoft makes Zork open-source
Thanks for making this! Yeah, I play it whenever I have some time. Lots of fun!
MPSimmons··on Microsoft makes Zork open-source
I like playing Zork via docker: https://github.com/clockworksoul/docker-zork1

> docker run -it clockworksoul/zork1

MPSimmons··on Ticker: Don't die of heart disease
How old are you? I was told that they're not considered diagnostic until somewhat later in life (>50) because the plaque may not have calcified yet, which could cause a false negative.
MPSimmons··on URLs are state containers
One example I think is super interesting is the NWS Radar site, https://radar.weather.gov/

If you go there, that's the URL you get. However, if you do anything with the map, your URL changes to something like

https://radar.weather.gov/?settings=v1_eyJhZ2VuZGEiOnsiaWQiO...

Which, if you take the base64 encoded string, strip off the control characters, pad it out to a valid base64 string, you get

"eyJhZ2VuZGEiOnsiaWQiOm51bGwsImNlbnRlciI6Wy0xMTUuOTI1LDM2LjAwNl0sImxvY2F0aW9uIjpudWxsLCJ6b29tIjo2LjM1MzMzMzMzMzMzMzMzMzV9LCJhbmltYXRpbmciOmZhbHNlLCJiYXNlIjoic3RhbmRhcmQiLCJhcnRjYyI6ZmFsc2UsImNvdW50eSI6ZmFsc2UsImN3YSI6ZmFsc2UsInJmYyI6ZmFsc2UsInN0YXRlIjpmYWxzZSwibWVudSI6dHJ1ZSwic2hvcnRGdXNlZE9ubHkiOmZhbHNlLCJvcGFjaXR5Ijp7ImFsZXJ0cyI6MC44LCJsb2NhbCI6MC42LCJsb2NhbFN0YXRpb25zIjowLjgsIm5hdGlvbmFsIjowLjZ9fQ==", which decodes into:

{"agenda":{"id":null,"center":[-115.925,36.006],"location":null,"zoom":6.3533333333333335},"animating":false,"base":"standard","artcc":false,"county":false,"cwa":false,"rfc":false,"state":false,"menu":true,"shortFusedOnly":false,"opacity":{"alerts":0.8,"local":0.6,"localStations":0.8,"national":0.6}}

I only know this because I've spent a ton of time working with the NWS data - I'm founding a company that's working on bringing live local weather news to every community that needs it - https://www.lwnn.news/

MPSimmons··on Microsoft Teams will start tracking office attendance
There are some that are wall-powered and have an actual physical spinning disk that moves your mouse around.
MPSimmons··on UA 1093
What happens to the payload mass when you add the transponder?
← PreviousPage 5 of 32Next →