HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

KPGv2

1,085 karma · joined September 8, 2023

submissionscomments
KPGv2··on Making Teenagers Read Newspapers. A Nationwide Experiment in French High Schools
The fact you can't find a quality newspaper to read says more about you than the state of journalism.

The Guardian, AP, Reuters, NPR, etc. Hell, the New York Review of Books is crazy good, although their world news coverage usually is slipped into book reviews.

KPGv2··on Isar Aerospace reaches orbit and deploys payloads on second flight
> These milestones are necessary to advancement of human race as we need new planets to occupy.

We can't even positively terraform Earth to stop the climate crisis here. Why does anyone think we need to be terraforming elsewhere? Just terraform here!!! Make the planet we are on more hospitable to human life!

It's not like we're running out of space, and the global population is about to start dropping.

KPGv2··on Discovery of a new OpenAI agent message board
Scale affects priority. I don't think we have enough federal employees to actually go after everything Trump has done.
KPGv2··on Discovery of a new OpenAI agent message board
I'm responding to someone who accused every politician of engaging in the same level of corruption as Trump. What is your basis for accusing Biden or Obama of even 1/100th of this amount? The Viktor Shokin conspiracy theory? Or the Hunter Biden Burisma story?
KPGv2··on The revolt of the reader
> It is pretty safe to assume that must of us catch it most of the time because the simple fact is so many people just copy and paste whatever the LLM outputs without even trying to edit it or mask that they used one.

This statement does not logically cohere. "We can spot it because so many people make it easy to spot." You don't see how this is just petitio principii in action?

KPGv2··on The revolt of the reader
> the current crop of LLMs have some pretty blatant

This is just "em dash redux." Except now we've moved on to accusing anyone who does "It's not X. It's Y." of being AI. In six months, it'll be "use of the word 'petrichor'" or something.

KPGv2··on The revolt of the reader
> To those who read broadly, the hand of the LLM is so clear it’s as if the writer’s intellectual fly is open

I dunno, man, according to Hardcover, I've read 76 fiction books this year, and I can't tell. All the "AI tells" fail the vibe check. I'm a writer and I get flagged by many of them.

And according to PhD linguists with expertise in the field, most AI tells are just the equivalent of old wives' tales. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ORgKY9AlybA

I vaguely recall that researchers were able to train people to tell, but only for a minority language that AIs likely aren't particularly good at mimicking, and after training.

This whole thing reminds me of how "you can recognize a vegan because they'll tell you." There, you have a ton of false negatives (i.e., since you aren't polling people to find out if they're vegan, you're only flagging the obvious vegans and missing all the regular people who happen to be vegan).

Except here, it's a bunch of false positives and negatives I bet. You don't really have a way of knowing, so you're accusing some people (without complete accuracy) and missing some people (without complete accuracy). But you have no way of knowing, so you're just like "hell yeah, my vibes tell me I'm right."

Research and experts disagree.

KPGv2··on Discovery of a new OpenAI agent message board
By the pigeonhole principle, "mostly A" and "mainly B" cannot both be true if A and B are not the same entity
KPGv2··on Discovery of a new OpenAI agent message board
This exactly. The conservative MO has been to accuse everyone else of doing exactly what conservatives do in the shadows, and once everyone believes non-conservatives are corrupt in a certain manner, conservatives goes mask off.

Then their supporters shrug their shoulders and say, "Meh, it's okay because everyone else does it." Except that everyone does NOT do these things. It's just the lie campaign took hold.

KPGv2··on Audacity 4.0
> Stringed instruments like guitars

guitar is a percussion instrument :D

KPGv2··on Audacity 4.0
> how do you notate 'gradually increase the filter cutoff here'?

probably a standalone Italian word would be fine, or some special < like we have for gradually increasing volume

KPGv2··on Mom gets 6-month suspended sentence for letting 5-year-old walk to the pond
The article really glosses over the fact that the kid was 5yo walking to a pond. It mentions it at the very start and then never brings it up again. That's the part that got me: the mom gave her 5yo permission to go to a large body of water unsupervised.

I'm a parent of three and strongly believe in letting your kids roam around (indeed, I live on acreage and taught my kids about the venomous snakes and spiders in our area, and then let er rip). But a 5yo who specifically asks to go back to a large body of water unsupervised is a bit too much for me.

Reason always strikes me as an opinionated libertarian media outlet, and this article really feels that way to me, where they keep playing up the "walking on the street" type stuff, the "we're too afraid of kidnappings" part, but not the fact that a 5yo unsupervised at a pond is by far the most dangerous part of this entire story.

Even as a kid of the 80s, I never saw 5yos out and about unsupervised, let alone by a pond. 5yo is possibly preschool.

Religious conservative, likely politically so, whose college degree was in family science at BYU—a degree Mormons steer their daughter into for her Mrs Degree—with experience in conservative politics at the state level who is responsible for passing a law giving parents a lot of freedom to let their little kids run around by basically saying "unless they're in immediate danger, YOLO"? So of course a reasonable judicial system tried to find a way to stop this wild behavior perpetrated by a woman with self-dealing political sway.

Article does not pass the vibe check. Letting your PRESCHOOL age kid go to a pond alone is pretty damn irresponsible, and Reason is trying to gin up anti-gov't feelings when this is probably the best possible outcome. Mom gets slapped on the wrist for fucking up in a way that just barely skirts a law she helped get passed and politicians were too stupid to think about before passing.

KPGv2··on Can I opt out of my input or output data being used for training?
Here's the dictionary: https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/opt-in

> The property of having to choose *explicitly* to join or permit something; a decision having the *default option being exclusion or avoidance*; used particularly with regard to mailing lists and advertising.

You're just using the term wrong. That's okay, I've used words wrong before, and it just means you've been presented an opportunity for learning a new fact.

But there's no argument to be had except with the dictionary.

KPGv2··on Can I opt out of my input or output data being used for training?
> They said "opt in to training on prompts by default," which is coherent English and perfectly fine

"Opt in" and "by default" are contradictory phrases. They mean literally the opposite of each other. The only reason it's coherent is that most native speakers will elect to believe "by default" was used correctly because it's the easier to use term.

> there is not a rule of the English language that would make their usage unacceptable

I think you're using emotionally inflammatory language, possibly unintentionally. no one is refusing to accept what they wrote.

That being said, the way they used "opt in" is categorically wrong. It's the opposite of the dictionary definition.

https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/opt-in

> The property of having to choose explicitly to join or permit something; a decision having the default option being exclusion or avoidance; used particularly with regard to mailing lists and advertising.

KPGv2··on Can I opt out of my input or output data being used for training?
Most people don't want a second job trying to figure out self-hosted AI stuff.
KPGv2··on Dyson CameraJet: The only toothbrush with a camera and a jet
The source was just someone on Reddit who said they did that and it improved their pocket numbers significantly. It was mostly a "wow, I never even considered just brushing twice" thing for me.

The toothpaste is a prescription one called All Day 5000 that my dentist gave me. I used to also use Apagard, which has apatite and is from Japan. Supposedly helps remineralize enamel. But I'm just sticking with the dentist toothpaste now and trying to drink water right after my lattes to wash the acid from the coffee off my teeth.

I still had a deep cleaning bc I don't wanna mess around with periodontal disease. I've reduced the brushing to just once at the very end now (you aren't even supposed to rinse after the All Day brush, just spit it out), but I added a waterpik because some of my teeth in the back have wider than normal gaps, so flossing didn't get it all out because floss works best in normal, narrow gaps.

Also FYI if your intervention is a deep cleaning, all this means is they will put a gel on your gums to numb them, then they'll do the standard dentist stuff, but under the gums a bit. I perceived it no differently from a normal cleaning. Just in case you're scared about it hurting a lot. no injections or anything. Just topical gel.

KPGv2··on Dyson CameraJet: The only toothbrush with a camera and a jet
I had some deep-ish gum pockets and switched to this pattern, and many of them resolved over a year without intervention:

0. tongue scraper 1. brush with normal toothpaste 2 min 2. floss 3. mouthwash 4. rinse 5. brush with a dry toothpaste that you don't rinse

I started to treat it like an important health step, less a chore. Like exercise or cooking healthy food instead of buying shit takeout.

KPGv2··on The Lost Art of Carrying Loads
I suppose I read enough books that I've seen this from human writers all the time for decades. It's even an English construction that I was specifically taught Japanese and Spanish equivalents in my foreign language classes decades ago, and I use the German equivalent with my family all the time.
KPGv2··on Can I opt out of my input or output data being used for training?
Possibly because Mistral is a French-based company, so EU companies can cut the American umbilical cord a bit more.
KPGv2··on Can I opt out of my input or output data being used for training?
> You are "opting in to sharing your prompts for training", by default in this case.

The English term for that is "opt out" not "opt in." To opt is to choose. If something is on by default, you have not opted in. You were forced in, and turning it off means you must opt out. (I.e., choose to be out.)

normally I wouldn't care about a mistake like this, except that opt in/out are very important concepts in software development and hacker culture. And it reversed the meaning of the original comment in a highly confusing, relevant way.

KPGv2··on AnkiDroid: Google Play no longer allowing Open Collective donation link
> I think a lot of people here are operating on the assumption that apps have the inherent right to ask for money on a proprietary platform that gives them a monetization path.

no one here thinks that there is an "inherent right" to ask for money on a proprietary platform. That's a strawman.

You're also still wrong about the nature of AnkiDroid, and it's making you look silly when you're so confident and rude about it.

KPGv2··on AnkiDroid: Google Play no longer allowing Open Collective donation link
We Americans collectively voted for this for decades. Virtually everyone who has cast a ballot for a national race has voted for this state of affairs.

Especially in the software community, overwhelmingly self-described libertarian, all voted for this.

It takes a big government to stop this from happening. (It also takes a big government to stop structural racism, etc., which means higher taxes, which means there's no such thing as a fiscal conservative who is also socially liberal. But I digress.)

KPGv2··on AnkiDroid: Google Play no longer allowing Open Collective donation link
> The bottom line is that Anki's lawyers messed up.

Anki and Ankidroid are not the same entity and they have different owners, if you want to call it that.

Anki is owned by Nicholas Flint, a physician who sells med school-related decks online under the name AnKing, which controls Ankihub, which now controls Anki after the original founder (Damien Elmes) gave them control about six months ago.

Ankidroid is a non-profit project that arose when there was only an iPhone mobile version of Anki. Completely unrelated to Anki except that it was blessed by the original creator of Anki.

It's also just some nerd programmers who ported Anki to run on Android. It's not some org with a revenue stream and attorneys.

> Obviously we're all reading this expecting that Anki is a 501(c)(3) charity

No, no one is reading it thinking that Anki is a charity.

Anyway, when you are going to harp on about HN not caring about the minutiae of tax policy, you should make sure you understand that you're talking about two unrelated entities run by different people as if they were the same entity.

KPGv2··on American Airlines mechanic Azriel “Al” Blackman has died
You don't need to write it down to pass the knowledge down to an apprentice.

Your bicycle case is a great example. People don't learn to ride a bike from a book. They receive in-person instruction of exactly the type the comment you're responding to was writing about.

KPGv2··on UC Berkeley indefinitely suspends international student work authorizations
Stanford has been top three in the US for at least twenty years (the other two are Yale and Harvard), and UCLA hovered in 14–16 range for twenty years as well. The past few years, the rankings went haywire. I think their methodology changed, bc there isn't a law firm in the world that would hire a Chicago student over a Harvard student, ceteris paribus.

Boalt has kind of been the butt of a lot of jokes since I was a student decades ago. Maybe those jokes came to fruition. (A bit like Brown among the Ivies.)

KPGv2··on It takes 5 cloud services to hear my doorbell
Amazon had these little Dash buttons about 10 years ago. The goal was you would click one, and it would re-order that product from Amazon. Many were branded.

Basically just a wifi button. I hacked one so I could, in my brain fog, record the moment i started and finished feeding my infant by sending a ping to a server via a simple click.

There's a bunch up on eBay. Could probably 3M tape one beside your door. Easy solution, esp if it's shielded from rain.

KPGv2··on It takes 5 cloud services to hear my doorbell
> People steal things from stores which have had cctv for decades.

The crime there (shoplifting) doesn't begin until they leave.

In the case of a burglary, the crime begins when they enter.

Seems to be a pretty important distinction when discussing whether knowing a person is physically present on your property alerts you to a crime in progress.

KPGv2··on It takes 5 cloud services to hear my doorbell
People who break into houses are going for a few obvious high-dollar items. They're not searching for a server closet they don't know exists. They're looking for laptops, pharmaceuticals, jewelry. High dollar, portable items. not a strange-looking device hidden in a closet. And obviously you can put it in a rack that requires a key to open. They won't bother.
KPGv2··on Htmx 4.0
That's like rejecting video games because the CRT was built for displaying live TV streams sent over the public airwaves.
KPGv2··on Htmx 4.0
The last time I made a website about a year ago, Gemini used HTMX. It was actually my first experience with HTMX, so in a way, LLMs led to me adopting it. :D
← PreviousPage 2 of 27Next →