1,067 karma · joined September 10, 2012
On the other hand, I imagine that if you were someone that liked pagination, this might be pretty nice.
I also cannot adequately express my thanks for putting a mute button on there.
So, all in all, the sheer monotony of the game has been quite a positive thing for me.
Assuming you know that a given password can be used 10 times and there's a database of 100,000 users in your scenario above, how would you work out who that is?
I agree that it really should be the user's attitude that needs to change, but there will always be that one person even if the other 99% of people get things right - so I think that at least trying to build a system to compensate for this is just as worthwhile as educating users.
I quite like the idea from XKCD [http://xkcd.com/936/] of using words instead of letters (but also have a few problems with it), perhaps rather than having passwords, we should have pass sentences that also have requirements (8 words of more, at least 2 punctuation marks, for example) or are generated for the user (could be nonsense sentences or contain misspelt words).
Hopefully I'm being short-sighted or missing something that'd mean this could be done simply and quickly, because in theory it sounds like quite a good idea.
I had to set up a management system a while back, and given the sensitivity of the data, it seemed prudent to block passwords such as "password" and "123456". The result? The most common password was "drowssap", even after an email explaining why they needed to use strong passwords.
I could have gone back and added something for permutations of common passwords, extended my exclusion list or any number of other solutions, but it seems like every time you find a way to stop a user being a security problem, they find another way.
If the average user were to even understand what cookies were, I could see at least some reasoning behind the law, but as it stands, it's like having a prompt at the petrol pump that asks you if you consent to something in your fuel that's there to help your engine - most people don't know about it and don't want to be bothered being asked the question in the first place.