HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ElectronCharge

58 karma · joined October 13, 2014

submissionscomments
ElectronCharge··on Any application that can be written in a system language, eventually will be
I'm surprised the author of this article thinks Go is a "system language".

Go uses GC, and therefore can't be used for hard real time applications. That's disqualifying as I understand it.

C, C++, Rust, Ada, and Mojo are true system languages IMO. It is true that as long as you can pre-allocate your data structures, and disable GC at runtime, that GC-enabled languages can be used. However, many of them rely on GC in their standard libraries.

ElectronCharge··on Stealing Isn't Innovation – America's creative community message against AI
I think there are some major problems with this thinking. How does this relate to human artists who studied prior art and then produced something?

I’ll grant you that AI isn’t actually intelligent, but I’ve seen many images and video that exhibited a good bit of originality, and were at a minimum a derived work…

ElectronCharge··on Statement from Jerome Powell
… TBC
ElectronCharge··on Richard Stallman at the First Hackers Conference in 1984 [video]
Ayn Rand had many insightful ideas, however she took them to an extreme.
ElectronCharge··on Inside CECOT – 60 Minutes [video]
What you see as “corrupt government” others see as a “virtuous cycle”…

The main problem with your thought process is that your conflating “wealth accumulation” with “wealth creation”!

ElectronCharge··on The U.S. Is Funding Fewer Grants in Every Area of Science and Medicine
One reason foreign enrollment is declining is concern about (mainly) Chinese espionage. That’s entirely reasonable, given the vast amount of stolen engineering and research…
ElectronCharge··on Over 40% of deceased drivers in vehicle crashes test positive for THC: Study
Buy a Tesla with FSD. No, it’s not L5 autonomy, but it’s already safer than the average human driver…and autonomous cars will only get better.
ElectronCharge··on Tell HN: X is opening any tweet link in a webview whether you press it or not
From your linked article:

"Musk has recently said that President Trump has agreed to shut down USAID"

Anything DOGE did was approved by the Executive Branch, as required.

ElectronCharge··on Tell HN: X is opening any tweet link in a webview whether you press it or not
I hope you're right, the nuclear option is looking mighty good right now! ;-)
ElectronCharge··on Tell HN: X is opening any tweet link in a webview whether you press it or not
An "administration" doesn't add debt - Congress does. Power of the purse strings, no?

I'm not sure what you mean by "this administration". Are you including DJT's first term?

Regardless, here are the numbers per Investopedia:

"Based on total dollar amounts, Joe Biden contributed the most to the national debt, adding $8.5 trillion during his presidency, followed by Donald Trump ($7.8 trillion in his first term) and Barack Obama ($7.7 trillion during his two terms)."

DJT's first term had the excuse of the COVID pandemic. Other than the final year when that was an issue, his spending was reasonable. 0'Biden on the other hand, had no such excuse for his spending binge, which was consistent across his (thankfully few) four years in office.

The "talk of lowering debt" is necessary, since right now we're spending 25% of federal revenue (about $1 trillion) paying the interest on our current massive national debt.

The hope is that a supercharged US economy can raise revenues enough to ease the pain of paying down the national debt that's largely been accumulated since 2000. It must be done to avoid the inevitable consequences.

ElectronCharge··on Record-High 62% Say U.S. Government Has Too Much Power
Seeing the downvotes, I'm fascinated with the effectiveness of propaganda in 2025. Truly amazing!

The midterms should be fun!

ElectronCharge··on Record-High 62% Say U.S. Government Has Too Much Power
I'd gladly wager some real money were such a thing feasible. We'll see who's "wildly out of tough [sic] with reality"!
ElectronCharge··on Record-High 62% Say U.S. Government Has Too Much Power
I'm not sure of your understanding of America's government.

Conservatives control all three branches of government to an extent. The Senate GOP doesn't have 60 members, so the Dems can block legislation (the GOP hasn't invoked the "nuclear option" that would prevent that). That's why there's a government shutdown, 100% of that is on the Dems.

The Supreme Court exists only to interpret law in terms of constitutionality. Even with a conservative majority, it shouldn't, and almost certainly won't, violate the Constitution.

As I said above, events leading up to the midterms, and the midterms themselves, will determine the way forward...quite democratically. :-)

ElectronCharge··on Record-High 62% Say U.S. Government Has Too Much Power
America has a strong executive, as mandated by the Constitution.

We'll have a much better idea of how things are going by the 2026 midterms. Then our democratic republic can vote accordingly. :-)

ElectronCharge··on Record-High 62% Say U.S. Government Has Too Much Power
I see just the opposite. This current administration is trying to prevent the kinds of authoritarian excesses and illegal acts that occurred under BHO and JRB from ever happening again.

Perhaps America will once again be a place with "freedom and justice for all"!

ElectronCharge··on Starship's Tenth Flight Test
I can think of three worthwhile goals at a minimum:

1) Access the vast resources available elsewhere in the Solar System.

2) Move most polluting and destructive heavy industry off of Earth (this will take big advances in propulsion technology).

3) Provide good habitats for humans and ideally much of Earth's ecosphere elsewhere in the Solar System. Certainly the human population alone could rise to the hundreds of billions if desired/needed.

Surely it'll take a lot of progress to achieve those goals, but they're within reach of our current scientific knowledge. Interstellar travel, on the other hand, is much more of a stretch goal! ;-)

ElectronCharge··on The air is hissing out of the overinflated AI balloon
Actually one of the fast food restaurants here takes automated spoken orders at the drive through. I've only used it once, but I was surprised that it worked flawlessly for me...
ElectronCharge··on The F-35 is losing the trade war
The F-35 isn't inferior to many other aircraft as far as raw capability goes. Really only the F-22. Nor is it expensive, at least the F-35A (I'm speaking of the initial cost, not sustainment which may or may not be a bargain).

The F-35 is the only genuinely stealthy aircraft any country outside the USA has access to (other than China, and the efficacy of its stealth technology isn't known). F-35 stealth is a game changer, as seen in every exercise in which they're involved.

ElectronCharge··on Apple announces American Manufacturing Program
I guess you didn't read the article.

TSMC is building factories in America, and Apple is the biggest customer so far. It's a similar situation for rare earth magnets. So, not just "assembly".

As to tariffs in general, you should learn about something called the "trade deficit". The other countries, such as China, already had tariffs on American products, America is simply reciprocating. If tariffs are so stupid, why do so many countries use them I wonder?

One beneficial side effect of tariffs is bringing strategic manufacturing onshore, such as...semiconductor manufacturing.

Like it or not, the US economy will grow explosively as a result of the current economic policies, after an adjustment period.

ElectronCharge··on Starlink is currently experiencing a service outage
Sure, it's too bad that almost all of that hatred is due to propaganda instead of anything real.

If anyone has benefited humanity over the last couple of decades, it's Elon Musk! I'd argue he's done more than anyone!

ElectronCharge··on Hulk Hogan Has Died
A hard right turn into politics would benefit quite a lot of HN readers...

The anti-capitalism movement is completely misguided. Capitalism has improved the human condition immeasurably! Every other system tried recently has failed miserably.

Is capitalism perfect? No, so let's work on improving it, in the face of robotics and AI!

The future is bright, if we go energy-intensive and break out into the larger Solar System! Otherwise, we face stagnation and decline...and likely a global catastrophe.

ElectronCharge··on Britain is lowering the voting age to 16. It's getting a mixed reaction
Because the number of senile/crazy people voting is a tiny percentage. The 16-17 year old block is potentially much larger, and might actually swing an election.

I share the opinion of many here that almost all those below 18 are too ill-informed, poorly educated, and immature to deserve a vote. They'd be easily propagandized and peer-pressured into voting poorly. That's not to say that many 18 and older don't fall into the same category, but we don't need a new large group like that.

ElectronCharge··on Marines being mobilized in response to LA protests
> The date is entirely unimportant.

The date is exactly what was being discussed. I was responding to the mischaracterization of "a military parade for the president's birthday", which is factually inaccurate. Plus, the plan was made during Biden's term.

> I suppose it's just a coincidence that Trump is following project 2025, step by step, since day one

He's following Agenda 47, which was published on his campaign website. He stated he agreed with some of Project 2025, but not all of it.

It's unsurprising that some involved in writing Project 2025 are working for the Trump admin.

ElectronCharge··on Marines being mobilized in response to LA protests
Are you claiming that the Army anniversary date being on DJT's birthday ISN'T a coincidence?

That must take some crazy mental gymnastics...

As to your other points, most aren't coincidences, though some aren't real either.

ElectronCharge··on Marines being mobilized in response to LA protests
> The action of having a military parade for the president's birthday is expensive and doesn't benefit us.

The funds for the "United States Army 250th Anniversary Parade" were allocated before President Trump was elected, during the Biden debacle. The fact that it falls on June 14th is what is called a "coincidence".

Be careful about blindly accepting propaganda as fact.

ElectronCharge··on Roto: A Compiled Scripting Language for Rust
I see. The problem is you left out that only non-networking contexts were considered, so that list missed the most relevant answer with no explanation.
ElectronCharge··on Roto: A Compiled Scripting Language for Rust
That was a pretty bad response, so I tried Grok 3, using the prompt "What's the likely meaning of BGP in a Hacker News article?"

Its entire response:

"In a Hacker News article, BGP most likely refers to Border Gateway Protocol, a key internet protocol used for routing data between different networks (autonomous systems) on the internet. It’s often discussed in contexts like network security, internet infrastructure, or outages caused by misconfigurations, as BGP is critical for directing traffic across the global internet. For example, a Hacker News article might cover BGP-related incidents like route leaks or hijacks, which can disrupt connectivity or enable cyberattacks.

If the context suggests something else (e.g., a specific acronym in a niche domain), could you provide more details about the article? I can also search for the specific post if you have a link or title."

Pretty good, eh?

ElectronCharge··on Ask HN: What's behind the strong anti-AI sentiment on Hacker News?
The Turing Test didn't anticipate super-parrots that converse nicely, instead assuming that an AI would actually reason to participate in a conversation.

The "AI" we have now isn't actually "I".

ElectronCharge··on I genuinely don't understand why some people are still bullish about LLMs
Yes. One of my early observations about LLMs was that we've now produced software that regularly lies to us. It seems to be a quite intractable problem. Also, since there's no real visibility as to how an LLM reaches a conclusion, there's no way to validate anything.

One takeaway from this is that labelling LLMs as "intelligent" is a total misnomer. They're more like super parrots.

For software development, there's also the problem of how up to date they are. If they could learn on the fly (or be constantly updated) that would help.

They are amazing in some ways, but they've been over-hyped tremendously.

ElectronCharge··on New Horizons for Julia
I'm surprised this has no comments/interest, it seems to me Julia is making great strides towards being an approachable, high-performance general purpose language with a great STEM emphasis.

My personal list of the most interesting modern languages: Mojo, Rust, and Julia.

Of course there are plenty of other worthy candidates, Haskell and jank being a couple that are less relevant to my use cases...

← PreviousPage 2 of 7Next →