HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

DanBC

56,529 karma · joined September 22, 2011

submissionscomments
DanBC··on MRI brain images become 64M times sharper
> If you want the procedure though nationalised healthcare (NHS), there is a wait

Unless it's an emergent procedure, in which case it'll be done same day or within the next 72 hours.

DanBC··on MRI brain images become 64M times sharper
> the real benefit comes from having periodic scans against a baseline.

This is over-testing, and it leads to over-diagnosis and over-treatment and it is a well recognised form of harm in healthcare.

DanBC··on Most people thinking about suicide don’t tell anyone
How does he square this with the fact that most people who die by suicide have sought help within the past twelve months?
DanBC··on Apple halted M2 chip production in January amid 'plummeting' Mac sales
It's US government agencies that call death by suicide a form of violence, and that's the reason that death by suicide involving a gun is a form of gun violence.

This is despite all the weird laws in the US against collecting, analysing, and reporting statistics.

DanBC··on Apple halted M2 chip production in January amid 'plummeting' Mac sales
So, gun violence isn't a problem but only if you ignore several signifcant forms of gun violence?
DanBC··on Apple halted M2 chip production in January amid 'plummeting' Mac sales
> Access to healthcare is pretty much instant and high quality for all but the very bottom of the society.

The US simultaneously under-treats poor people while over-treating rich people. This is why health outcomes in the US are so bad across a range of indicators.

DanBC··on The Fake Chip Scourge
This video is a pretty good discussion of the problems of fake ICs.

It starts with an example that is genuinely shocking - a fake IC being used in a military aircraft. I've worked in the electronics industry building test equipment, and the traceability requirements were fierce. A company avoiding that and using fake parts is surprising because they save a few dollars but destroy their reputation. The video gives other examples of counterfeit ICs that get into the defence supply chain.

I was pleased to see discussion about the difficulties caused by military certification of designs - these "lock in" designs making it very difficult to use substitute parts. So, when very old equipment needs to be serviced the parts simply aren't available new because they're not being made anymore. People are stuck having to use non-standard supply sources to get the items.

DanBC··on How to avoid false narratives around DR Congo's M23 conflict
I'm submitting this because it's important to understand how social media platforms are actually used, and how this can contribute to human death.

This isn't an isolated incidence - we've seen it in many other places too.

DanBC··on UK: Excess deaths in 2022 among worst in 50 years
> The main way is via your allocated General Practitioner (GP). To see a GP you need to telephone the GP's place of work, known as a surgery, and to have any chance of getting a same day appointment you need to call at 8am precisely. Don't call at 7.59 because you won't be connected, and don't leave it until 8.01 because it will be far too late. Call within the first few seconds after 8am and you'll be informed that you're in a queue, behind several dozen earlier callers.

1) Genuinely baffling to see people who think their individual sucky experience is universal. What you describe is how your gp works. Change GPs! There are better surgeries around.

I called my GP after 12 midday and explained that I had turned a bit yellow and had pain under my right ribcage, and they booked me in for an appointment a couple of hours later, and after I'd send them they booked me into my local hospital's surgical assessment unit (thus bypassing A&E) where I was hooked up to IV fluids and antibiotics. I got scans that day, I got surgery the day after, I was discharged a few days later when the infection had clear and my numbers were better.

Same day appointments are for emergencies, and if you have an emergency you will get a same day appoint

> The only other means of accessing the NHS is by rocking up at the Accident and Emergency (A&E)

No, this simply isn't true. In this order depending on severity of illness, people can chose to get support from: NHS Website, NHS 111, Pharmacy, GP, Minor Injury and Illness Units, Emergency Departments, or Ambos.

Plenty of services now have self referral - podiatry, physiotherapy, dietetics, eating disorder, mental health crisis, antenatal, etc etc. So you don't have to go via your gp, you just phone them up and make an appointment.

DanBC··on UK: Excess deaths in 2022 among worst in 50 years
You reduce bed numbers by pushing less sick people out of hospital. This means that your two 6-bed bays now don't have 4 people who need minimal nursing, 6 people who need moderate nursing, and 2 people who need high level nursing. It means you have 8 people who need moderate level nursing and 4 people who need high level nursing.
DanBC··on UK: Excess deaths in 2022 among worst in 50 years
Please at least read the pages you quote.

> this is likely to have been driven in part by activities in response to the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic, such as testing and tracing services and the implementation of the vaccination programme.

Yes, if we include the many billions spent on faulty test and trace and broken PPE -the corrupt spending that went to pals of the Tory party- we see an increase in health spending.

Guess what happens to the amount of health care funding if you ignore the corrupt spend on PPE?

DanBC··on UK: Excess deaths in 2022 among worst in 50 years
The Kings Fund is a credible source of information about the NHS systems in England, Scotland, Wales, and NI. One of the reasons that they're credible is because they're cautious about definitions. In your quote they're saying "lots of people have written about this, and they all use slightly different definitions for management, and so they all give different numbers".

What is a manager? Are you only including non-clinical staff? Or do clinical staff count too? If you're including clinical staff, how many hours of their working week are you counting as clinical hours and how many are you counting as managerial hours? Are you converting people who work part time as managers to Full Time Equivalent positions, or not?

If you want to poke the data it's here: https://digital.nhs.uk/data-and-information/publications/sta...

If you want more description of the complications of counting managers in the NHS I found these useful (if a bit old now):

https://www.kingsfund.org.uk/publications/future-leadership-...

https://www.kingsfund.org.uk/projects/general-election-2010/...

https://www.kingsfund.org.uk/projects/health-and-social-care...

DanBC··on UK: Excess deaths in 2022 among worst in 50 years
> If you think the government should provide everything you need to live

If you're going to argue against fundamental human rights like "right to life" then you're going to have to do better than the arguments you're using here.

DanBC··on UK: Excess deaths in 2022 among worst in 50 years
> That is NOT the same thing as NHS, which completely takes over and provides the care.

There's loads of reasons to dislike NHS care and it's genuinely weird that people who are so against the NHS never manage to hit on something real, and instead resort to stuff that's simply fiction.

NHS England spends billions commissioning care from private providers. That's why we have Priory Group, Cygnet, Operose, etc etc all providing care. (And in the case of cygnet and priory, often poor quality care).

And patients have a right to chose where to get their care - that's what chose and book is.

People who don't understand the NHS think it's a single organisation -which is what you've done here- and that's not correct. Patients have a choice of where they get elective care. NHS England commissions specialist services, and 42 ICSs commission the bulk of regular services. They're not allowed by law to have a preference for NHS providers, so if a private provider can do it for the money they should put a bid in. That commissioned care is provided by about 200 - 220 NHS trusts. NHS Trusts include ambo services, acute hospitals, community hospitals, mental health care, and community care. These NHS trusts are independent organisations that have their own boards of directors and their own accounts and they can compete against each other to provide services to particular regions. This does not include primary care which is provided by GP surgeries.

DanBC··on Some UK hospitals with emergency services in complete state of crisis
Most of the people in hospital who are medically fit to discharge but who need a care package before discharge are underweight, not overweight.
DanBC··on English as She Is Spoke (1884) [pdf]
But it isn't, which is why there are so many people on YouTube earning money telling you how to do things the wrong way.
DanBC··on English as She Is Spoke (1884) [pdf]
There are a million YouTube videos of people confidently telling you how to do something but getting it pretty badly wrong.

There are so many that there's now another genre of reacting to this bad advice.

DanBC··on Some UK hospitals with emergency services in complete state of crisis
Hospitals should run at something like an 80% capacity. This allows safety and flexibility in the system.

UK politicians have spent the past ten years talking about "efficiency savings" (meaning real term cuts), and so now the system is running normally at 90-95% capacity. And then you have something like COVID, combined with a bad flu season, combined with a bad respiratory illness season for young people, combined with a cold snap where councils didn't de-ice pavements, combined with Brexit meaning many staff have left, combined with years of defending of social care:

All of these mean we have older, iller people in hospital, we can't get them out of acute hospital and into care / nursing homes because those don't exist anymore, we can't get them back to their own home with paid carers because all those staff left in Brexit.

That means when someone is in ED and needs a bed there isn't one, and when someone is in an ambo and needs to get into ED they can't because there's no space, and when they're on the floor at home after a fall and need an ambo there are no ambos because they're all queueing at the ED.

For years in England we've pushed risk onto ambo staff, and this year we've finally said acute hospitals have to share that risk, so we're seeing the inevitable results of over-crowding and over-full hospitals.

And this is all entirely predictable and preventable - people have been describing FOR YEARS exactly what would happen and how it would happen and even when it would happen, and now it's happening.

The blame lies squarely with a Conservative government that doesn't believe in tax funded public services and which has decided to cut as much as it can.

DanBC··on Some UK hospitals with emergency services in complete state of crisis
It should be obvious that they're not all doctors and nurses - there's nothing in the medical education of a doctor that would prepare them to be eg an accountant or a buyer.

"The NHS is over-managed" is a tired, boring, argument that is easily debunked with a simple search.

The NHS has fewer managers than similarly sized organisations. That's not a sign of an out of control bureaucracy.

DanBC··on Hydroxychloroquine lowers Alzheimer's disease and related dementias risk
It would if you sued to prevent the off-label use, which is something that happened with avastin and lucentis for wet AMD.
DanBC··on A search engine for searching books in the Z-Library index on the IPFS network
> Is that a crime?

You didn't say where you are. Copyright infringement tends not to be a criminal offence, unless you're doing it as part of a business (so if you print out copies of that ebook and sell them) or you do so much of it you distort the market (you distribute so many copies of that ebook you destroy the profits that publisher might have made).

The rights holder can sue for their losses, but this tends to be the cost of the item, so they tend not to do that.

DanBC··on Hydroxychloroquine lowers Alzheimer's disease and related dementias risk
I don't think you re-patent an off-label use, you re-patent a minor modification. See for example ketamine to eskatamine; or citalopram to escitalopram.

Once you have the new med you use the courts to prevent the off-label use. See eg lucentis or avastin for Wet AMD.

DanBC··on England poised to become fisrt country to eliminate Hepatitis C
I'm submitting the link to the Twitter post because the Times has an unpredictable paywall.
DanBC··on Social Security denies disability benefits based on list with jobs from 1977
Bit odd that the US tolerates, even celebrates, massive tax avoidance but spends a lot of money on preventing relatively small sums of benefit fraud.
DanBC··on Women like working with people, men like working with things, all over the world
Are you saying there aren't female coal miners? What do you think coal miners do?
DanBC··on Turn your best programmers into managers
Yes, it's like people have completely forgotten, or maybe never heard of, the Peter Principle.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_principle

> The Peter principle is a concept in management developed by Laurence J. Peter, which observes that people in a hierarchy tend to rise to "a level of respective incompetence": employees are promoted based on their success in previous jobs until they reach a level at which they are no longer competent, as skills in one job do not necessarily translate to another.[1]

The concept was explained in the 1969 book The Peter Principle (William Morrow and Company) by Laurence Peter and Raymond Hull.[2] (Hull wrote the text, based on Peter's research.) Peter and Hull intended the book to be satire,[3] but it became popular as it was seen to make a serious point about the shortcomings of how people are promoted within hierarchical organizations. The Peter Principle has since been the subject of much commentary and research. Co

DanBC··on The strange case of Britain’s demise
The vast majority of healthcare is provided to outpatients so numbers of staff to beds is a fucking weird ratio to look at.
DanBC··on The strange case of Britain’s demise
> Most folks who have money I know always tend to go private rather than dealing with a 6 month wait for a routine check up.

I don't get this - if it's a routine check up you'll have one per year, so your GP will be booking it in for you, and they are paid money to do so.

If you're talking about a routine check-up for the worried well who don't have any health problems but who just want a doctor to tell them that they don't have any health problems, well, those checks cause harm and do not prolong life so you'd want to delay them as much as possible.

DanBC··on What happens to a smartphone when it gets stolen?
> but currently in the UK, the police are pretty much always the first (often only) to deal with MH issues and get people into care/section them etc.

I can't talk about Scotland, Wales, or NI. But here's the data for England:

https://digital.nhs.uk/data-and-information/publications/sta...

There were 34,000 detentions under the act. Of these, only 4,150 were detentions following a Section 135 / 136 place of safety order (the bit of the Mental Health Act that the police can use).

The CQC also have their "Monitoring use of the Mental Health Act" report here: https://www.cqc.org.uk/publications/monitoring-mental-health...

This strengthens the point you're making. EG https://www.cqc.org.uk/publications/monitoring-mental-health... and https://www.cqc.org.uk/publications/monitoring-mental-health... both talking about the poor care recieved by patients as a result of the defunding of the NHS and social care systems.

DanBC··on NHS waiting lists in England hitting new high of 7.2M people
No, they mean something like England already has for dentistry or social care or opticians - access is available if you pay for it, and not much available if you can't pay for it.
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →