HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

CarolineW

6,352 karma · joined July 9, 2011

submissionscomments
CarolineW··on A Link Between Pure Math and Physics
Discussed at length:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15825700

CarolineW··on Sussman anomaly
It also just "blows up" on any problem of any real complexity, and as such isn't really a solution.
CarolineW··on Sussman anomaly
That feels trivially like saying: "If you can identify the crucial part of the challenge then it's easy."

The problem then becomes one of identifying the crucial part of the challenge. If framed that way, your comment doesn't really help.

CarolineW··on Circular Runways
Note for readers - this is a new story, based on the idea of circular runways that's been submitted many times before, but talking about actually building one for real for drones.

Here's a discussion of the main idea:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13883954

Here are other submission of the same story, and the inventor's rebuttal of some of the criticisms:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14163971 (Inventor's defence)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13901392 (submitted video now unavailable)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13890437

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13885124 (Repeat of 13890437)

CarolineW··on [dead]
Discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16084575
CarolineW··on Ask HN: New York Times Submissions by New York Times. Is This OK?
I count 12 different articles in the last 24 hours, some of which are duplicates - a known feature of HN. That doesn't seem excessive to me.

Can you be more specific about why you think this is "a flood?"

CarolineW··on Show HN: Beta version of a new backlink analysis tool
OK, I made two quick queries to check what it did and roughly how it worked, then went to do a "proper" query and got the "You've used your quota for today" message. Which is fair enough, but it would have been nice to be told that before I burned my quota with explorations.

I find the display crowded, but there's a lot there. I wonder if you could provide a "novice" mode that has a lot less detail, but gives significant "bang for buck". Then people can learn how to read the basics, and see that there is more information if they choose to self-identify as "experienced". It might help prevent the "Wall of Stuff" response.

The information appears to be useful, and the fields and abbreviations have pop-ups to name them, even if they don't have complete explanations about their meanings and implications.

In short, I like it, and if I want a tool like this I'd use it. I'm not sure I'd remember where it is if at same random point in the future I wanted the facilities it offers.

That's a problem I've never seen a solution to.

CarolineW··on 3D printed objects that can connect to WiFi without electronics
Discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15861123

Other submissions:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15871960

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15857461

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15855076

CarolineW··on Facebook is locking accounts, then demanding “verify” by scanning their face
Discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15807200

350 comments

CarolineW··on A pile of matchboxes that can learn [video]
I know people for whom this is much more understandable than state diagrams. They are equivalent under an appropriate isomorphism, but that doesn't mean that they are equally easy to understand for everyone.

They aren't. You made this assertion:

    ... if someone can't comprehend a
    paper diagram they can't comprehend
    this either.
I believe you are wrong.
CarolineW··on Ask HN: Learning Lisp, and I have some questions
I don't entirely agree with your reply, but I think it's unreasonable that it's being downvoted. I've upvoted it to try to balance that, although it's not clear my vote will count for much, if anything.

I think what you've said is reasonable, although it doesn't really address the poster's questions.

CarolineW··on A Letter to Jamie Dimon
A few comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15486582
CarolineW··on A Letter to Jamie Dimon
A few comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15486582
CarolineW··on A Letter to Jamie Dimon (and anyone else trying to understand cryptocurrencies)
A few comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15486582
CarolineW··on A Letter to Jamie Dimon
A few comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15486582
CarolineW··on A letter to Jamie Dimon
A few comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15486582
CarolineW··on A Letter to Jamie Dimon [on Cryptocurrency]
A few comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15486582
CarolineW··on Letter to Jamie Dimon and anyone else struggling to understand cryptocurrencies
In case you're wondering why this hasn't got much discussion, here are a few comments from an earlier submission:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15486582

CarolineW··on Left Truncatable Prime
It's good enough for smallish primes, especially when you use multiple bases. There aren't many Carmichael numbers, and the early ones all have a small factor. So the test is certainly adequate in this range.
CarolineW··on Students learn more effectively from print textbooks than screens
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15502811
CarolineW··on Review please
This has been submitted before, and my comment now is the same as the comment that was made by someone else last time - I have no idea what this is about, and there is nothing about it that makes me think I would ever care.
CarolineW··on Ask HN: How can I get myself out of this?
Random advice from a random person on the internet, possibly affecting your life decisions ... take this for what it's worth.

You need to decide what you want to accomplish. If things can be changed, would you want this job anyway? If you do want this job (assuming it can be saved/fixed) then what is it that needs to be changed?

Your point 6 nails it - as I see it you need to go to the CEO and say that while your title is "manager", your "team" is actually going to and taking direction from the CEO. As a result, you say, you are unable to do the job.

Now you need to make the decision as to what you want, or you can simply leave it up to them. Choose:

* Say that you require the authority as well as the responsibilities, so your team must only take direction from you, except in exceptional circumstances which must then be confirmed by you;

* Say that since you are not given the authority of a manager then you require that you return to being a member of the team;

* Give them the choice between the above two options, and that whatever is agreed must include written confirmation of the separation of duties.

But you must decide what it is you want to achieve. Yes, it would be a PITA to relocate again, but as it stands you will be miserable, in danger of being "let go" regardless, and have no control. If you do take control of your own destiny, at least you will have some control!

You have the title of manager. That doesn't just mean that you tell your team what to do, it also means that you must manage your relationship with your manager - the CEO. Perhaps even start by saying that you are keen to make a success of your position, you need their assistance and guidance, and that to do your job properly you must be given the authority. To phrase it like that means they demonstrate power by giving you the control you need.

FWIW. As I say, random advice from a random stranger on the internet.

CarolineW··on David Bowie and the autistic child he helped
I have deliberately not linked to the original because the original is utterly unreadable on my phone. The link to the original is there if you want it.
CarolineW··on It’s not a bug, it’s a puzzle
The article repeats the urban myth:

    The origin of the word bug as
    it pertains to engineering goes
    all the way back to 1947 when
    Dr. Grace Hopper discovered a
    moth stuck in one of the relays
    of the Mark II computer.
It goes back further than that - there's a cartoon from the 1930s in which a prospective car buyer lifts the bonnet/hood and some moths fly out, with the voice-over saying "The engine still has a few bugs to be worked out."
CarolineW··on Elliptic Curve Cryptography for Beginners
Seems to have labelled "C" and "-C" in a very misleading manner. Take point A. Draw a tangent, that cuts the curve at point C. That's not the point 2A. That's the point C.

Reflect C across the X axis, and that's point 2A.

So you're not missing anything, the article is misleading at best.

In short, to take the sum of two points A and B, draw a line through them both to find a third point on the curve, reflect that point across the X-axis, and the result (which will also be on the curve) is A+B.

If A and B coincide then use the tangent at A.

The point at (vertical) infinity plays the role of the zero.

CarolineW··on An introduction to Scuttlebutt, the lovely decentralized social network [video]
An 11 minute video? No transcript? No subtitles?

Really?

CarolineW··on Efficient strlen implementation in C (2007)
OK, I don't know what you mean by:

    > I can't see where that was written
                        ^^^^
To what exactly are you referring by the "that"?

    > Only that malicious users may read
    > past the end.
There's an entire section after that:

    Reducing complexity

    Improvement is not that much effective?
    Actually, we are optimizing the wrong way!
    Really ;)! When optimizing code, you have
    to, in order:

        reduce complexity;
        tune your compiler;
        optimize your code.

    So, how can we reduce complexity (Currently
    O(n) for both algorithms)? Simply by storing
    the string length somewhere! The complexity
    is then O(1)
etc.

But it's all there, and either you've read it and I don't know what you mean, or you haven't read it, and I've provided the pointer for you.

CarolineW··on Efficient strlen implementation in C (2007)
You are absolutely right, but it appears that you didn't read to the end, stopping at the broken implementation that the author says is broken.

But you're right, and it does put the entire article in question. I'm tempted to use this as an interview question:

There's a bug in this code - can you find it? Talk to me about why this is a bad thing to do? How can we fix it? What's the most important thing to be thinking about?

I was also interested to read the follow-up linked to from the bottom of the article, but that's a 404.

CarolineW··on Efficient strlen implementation in C (2007)
Quoting:

> As you can see, it can be totally transparent for the user. You just have to take care ...

It's that word just that bothers me.

"Programming is simple, you just have to write the code."

"Bug-free programming is easy, you just have to avoid putting bugs in."

Yes, this code "just" requires some care.

CarolineW··on Will London monetise Metro passengers mobility data
Discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15382274

There are a number of other submissions of this story, but the titles vary wildly and I haven't been able to find any other significant discussion.

← PreviousPage 2 of 26Next →