Hacker News Reader

Comment by cxseven | Hacker News Reader

One thing Google Reader did great was "sort by magic" where it somehow knew VERY well according to my individual tastes what article I'd be most interested in reading from my massive set of subscriptions. Feedly and other readers' auto-selected articles don't seem to have come close, but that may be a function of their reduced userbase and shrinking RSS activity.

View on HN

In my opinion Feedly is hands down better than any other RSS reader I have ever used, including Google Reader. I don't read auto-selected articles, however, I subscribe to and curate feeds on my own.

I'm afraid RSS readers aren't very popular, however, and Google was indeed in a better place to change that.

I would love to use Feedly but Feedly requires an extension to use who's only possible purpose is to spy on you. The extension provides zero features that could not be provided without it. Since it's required (as opposed to optional) the only logical explanation is its spying on you.

What? I use feedly daily but don't have a feedly extension. You can just go to feedly.com

They used to require an extension but they don't any longer. Also, their mobile apps are amazing. I don't believe Google Reader had anything like that.

I used the google reader android app before it was shuttered.

Good to know. Sorry. I should have checked to see if they got rid of that requirement

Citation needed.

Correct! I use The Old Reader, free, because it's awesome. I remember now why I did this choice, and indeed invasive browser extensions which ask for * access to all my sites are a big no-no. Whenever I want to use a web-screenshot tool, I do it in a separate profile.

This is no longer true, Feedly is completely accessible by browser, no extension needed.

The extension was required to cache articles back in time when local storage sucked and feedly's infrastructure was not big enough to handle influx of all of the people who had to leave Google Reader.

The best part about Google Reader was I could easily share articles with select friends and it would show up in their streams and comment on it. Feedly is pretty awesome but I miss that.

Nothing has ever come close to the level of, for the lack of a better word, intellectual intimacy I felt with my small circle of Google Reader friends. I still miss their daily share of thought-provoking articles to this day.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com