Hacker News Reader

Comment by Theodores | Hacker News Reader

The Excel Spreadsheet using person that happens to need access to their Office 365 documents through their Android mobile phone could install Cortana to make their busy lives theoretically that bit easier. Other than an imagined use case like this I have no idea why anyone would want this on their phone.

I have a feeling that Cortana et al. will be like Dragon Naturally Speaking, exist as a product for a long time without ever picking up momentum. I don't see people using Siri/Google Now! except for novelty value, I can't imagine people moving from Siri/Google Now! to Cortana at all ever.

View on HN

I use Siri daily to.....

- Send text messages (speaking punctuation like period/question mark helps accuracy, as well as breaking up thoughts by saying dot dot dot) in the car or if Im too lazy to type.

- Telling Siri to play whatever song while driving via Apple Music.

- Directions

- Weather reports

- Setting reminders

Overall I would say 30 to 40 percent of my friends/family use Siri or something similar. As more and more use Siri or Google Now, the accuracy will continue to improve to 100 percent and the percentage of those using will increase. In five to ten years Im guessing the majority will be using their voice assistant.

I actually use Siri daily, but only to set reminders and turn on alarms, two incredibly trivial use cases.

I'm not opposed to using it more but those are the only things that work reliably for me, I'd get over it disappearing pretty quickly.

I also use Siri to send text messages if I'm driving or riding my bike, or to find the answer to a piece of trivia, or to launch applications, rather than having to hunt for them. That makes quite a lot of use cases, but nevertheless I agree with you that I wouldn't miss Siri if it was to go away

I use Cortana all the time now. I've posted here before how it feels like Star Trek, and it impresses me more and more as time goes on.

Example: The other day I said to my phone "Hey Cortana, where are some coffee shops with wifi around here?" And, you know, it worked. It even used the speech synthesis to talk to me. It's eerie having a conversation with the phone like that, using natural language, not even trying anymore to treat it like a computer (e.g. careful phrasing or enunciation).

I seldom open maps by hand anymore, but I ask the phone for driving directions all the time. I never set my own alarms, and for a long time, didn't know how to on this phone.

I don't use all the features Cortana has, like the flight tracking stuff, but I can see getting into the habit with that, too.

It just blows my mind how useful it is, and how little thinking I put into engaging with it as a computer-driven system anymore. Cortana's my first "it just works" experience with a computer, like, ever.

I use Google Now all the time.

The voice search is pretty good, but the travel organisation features are killer. I don't know what I'd do without it.

Siri serves 1 billion requests a week, according to Tim Cook. That's about 1000 per second? Could all be novelty attempts, I suppose...

I use Siri at least 30-40 times a day, mostly for responding to texts.

Actually, Cortana will probably be the break-through that will bring mass adoption to everyone. It is integrated very well in win10, so probably everyone will use it.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com