Hacker News Reader

Could you elaborate on this? This project seems to be moving in the same direction the React team is with Relay and GraphQL – the component describes the query it requires to render itself, and a query/caching layer executes the query automatically.

View on HN

What I described as a Service would be what this query/caching layer is. I would just rather not have it embedded in the Component, making it harder to follow what a Component does. The beauty of them is that they are simple to read and understand. The more mixins you use, the more esoteric it gets and you have to read a bunch of code to understand why the render function magically has these properties to display with.

Another point would be that the service or store could be re-used in more than just react, and it can be tested without having to consider the UI.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com