Hacker News Reader

What compiler settings were you using? In my experience, C is faster than Java if you turn on full optimization settings.

View on HN

Now that is just ridiculous! With O2 and O3 I get 0.03 seconds on average! I try to understand what could possibly mean all of the flags that get switched on with optimizations from this page: https://gcc.gnu.org/onlinedocs/gcc/Optimize-Options.html

I also wonder if Java has any kind of optimizations to experiment with.

If you don't put in ANY optimization flags, it puts in full debugging info, which slows things down a lot.

I don't know anything about Java optimization.

Java doesn't have any optimization flags and the debugging info slowdown makes sense I suppose. That is the exact difference between them, GCC with -O3 is almost 100x faster in another test I just did: 10s for Java, 0.1 for C. When you turn off the optimization flags C jumps right at the same 10s figure though.

Really cool interesting stuff!

That's what I figured - a lot of people who say "Java is as fast as C" aren't doing proper compiler optimizations on their C. I suspected that was true, but I didn't spend the time on a proper test.

-O2 or -O3 does some neat stuff like unrolling loops and inlining functions

--fast_math is another one I use

Reply on news.ycombinator.com