How is this system supposed to work well? It seems to be clearly designed to make money, not to educate people, which doesn't seem like a good way to enhance and maintain your society.
How is this system supposed to work well? It seems to be clearly designed to make money, not to educate people, which doesn't seem like a good way to enhance and maintain your society.
It would be better if it was 100% of course, but it's not like most people leave school and have to fight a desperate battle against debtors. For most people it's just a temporary drag on their income that gets paid off relatively quickly if they earn enough to pay over the minimum.
The reason it sort of quasi-works in the U.S., but seems inconceivable in Europe, is likely the differences in the labor markets. In general the U.S. doesn't have the same kinds of problems (or as severe) with youth employment and underemployment. For example, during normal economic periods, youth unemployment in the U.S. is around 13-15%, during the recession we considered it to be a major crisis when it went to 20%. By contrast the EU youth employment rates (not unemployment) sits at around 30% (with Germany being a notable exception at ~8%).
Furthermore, it's generally considered acceptable in the U.S. to job-hop for higher salaries every year or two, meaning that your earning potential 5 and 10 years out of college will be much higher than directly after graduation, further improving your ability to pay your loan off.
In other words, it's more possible in the U.S. to take on loans for education, and have a reasonable expectation of graduating out of college into a full-time job, where you can further expect to have increased your earning ability and thus pay the loans off.
> How is this system supposed to work well? It seems to be clearly designed to make money, not to educate people, which doesn't seem like a good way to enhance and maintain your society.
It does work well, for certain interests. But it's the same for almost any important financial concern in America. Taxes, utilities, medical care, retirement funding, most of our important systems are intentionally structured to fatten the wallets of powerful interests at the expense of maintaining society. And it's only getting worse, as the trade deals currently under negotiation clearly demonstrate.
You are absolutely correct. Our educational system sets you up for failure. There is no vested interested in your success. We pay teachers a shit salary, in some cases it's not even a living wage, and we expect 99% of the population to accumulate tremendous debt, simply to get a college degree. There is a very slight chance that you'll be successful with that degree, if you went to the right college, if you got the right degree, if you finished in the proper amount of time, if...if..if.
You're screwed if any one of those legs turns out to be not right.
It's interesting you use those words, as I've lately come to realize that's how the majority of institutions in America function.
Health care / insurance: Screw as many as possible. Profit is king.
Education: Screw as many people as possible. Profit is king.
Car Insurance: Screw as many people as possible. Profit is king.
etc, etc.