The economic logic of some amazingly awful websites
ello.co
ello.co
Off now to source a previous article on Indian supermarkets and this finding - the owner found cleaning displays less increased sales as customers correlated 'lower care' with 'lower prices'.
[Edit: Alas, it's behind the WSJ paywall - http://www.wsj.com/article_email/SB118651168871890705-lMyQjA...
Here's an OK synopsis http://www.retailcontrarian.com/2007/08/bright-future-f.html]
People expected the sites to look gaudy and tasteless and when they weren't, they went elsewhere. They didn't trust the well-designed site.
Note that it discusses pr0n though there's no nudity / sex acts portrayed IIRC.
"Things You Learn Designing Porn Banners for a Living"
http://www.vice.com/read/this-girl-designed-porn-banners-for...
In the beginning, I sent my banners and the trafficker told me, “it’s too pretty. The picture needs to look homemade”. He introduced me to this amazing keyword: “amateur”. It opened up a whole new world of pictures I could use! I had no idea. When I started, I didn’t know the genres.
I’ve seen this with clients competitors, what may look terrible to me as a web site developer looks entirely different to a non-tech customer. Advertising is not 100% science and small businesses are not faced with the same branding constraints big business is.