There's always a mix of both contempt and jealousy in these kinds of articles.
There's always a mix of both contempt and jealousy in these kinds of articles.
The article wasn't about being oppressed, so much as being disempowered.
"But they really aren't."
Ok. So why aren't they disempowered in the situation described in the article?
"She mentions women foraging for tubers as a contrast"
What she really said was: "women who contribute to the group or family’s well-being are empowered relative to those in societies where women do not".
"And they don't get to be "empowered" somehow in the bargain."
So again, why don't they get to be empowered (relative to similar societies)?
Can you give an example of such a society? I'm not doubting that they exist, but I've never heard of any and I'm curious.
There is more than one way to be oppressed.
It's rather sad to discover that the group who's "liberation" you dedicated your professional life to doesn't really want to be liberated.
In the case described in the article the males are obviously getting something out of the symbiotic relationship, but it's nowhere near what the females are getting. I'm sticking to my figurative use of "parasitism" to describe the imbalance.
Seems unlikely.
This is the bargain they've made. It's a rather simple exchange. "Parasitic" is a loaded term here, by applying it you're displaying that you have some sort of political axe to grind.
This was also the sentiment being expressed above, when someone said that what you said sounded "judgmental" -- an accusation that you dismissed by being, or pretending to be, oblivious to it's true intent: "you're attaching pejorative terms to these women, without enough information to make a fair case for it."
It's an obviously imbalanced exchange. We don't take intestinal worms out of the parasites category just because they help us prevent autoimmune diseases.
> you're attaching pejorative terms to these women, without enough information to make a fair case for it
No, I'm just trying to be objective. If I wanted to insult them I could have called them prostitutes with a single, long-term client.
Sorry for whatever experiences you've had that led to this.
That's quite judgmental. They really are rich stay-at-home moms and it's a worthy life.
Feminism was not about forcing a new lifestyle. It's about giving the freedom to choose the path.
Good. Judging is a strong indication of thinking ;-)