Those statistics have some skew, as well. "Crime" is at a low, but it's not a crime when police steal your life savings of cash via civil asset forfeiture, nor is it a crime when they put you in a chokehold until you are dead, or burden you with unreasonable financial penalties for minor traffic infractions.
Crime as a category for the measure of citizens' happiness does not mean what it did 20 years ago. We can walk more neighborhoods at night with less fear, but we are more afraid than ever of what can be done to us in broad daylight by someone with a badge.