I'm looking for:
* Technical skills (on a rather broad level): how much experience do they seem to have? Are they interested in their field beyond work?
* How clear is their communication? Can they argue well?
* How well their preferences align with ours in terms of technology.
(But then, it’s nothing new. Rule of the thumb is always, hire for attitude and train for skills - and not the other way around.)
Oh, and lying happens all the time. The only way around it is getting better with inter-personal skills.
Wherever I've worked, they all expected deeper knowledge. How else would you distinguish good vs mediocre ones? It takes time to get good at anything and getting good means deep knowledge of at least one thing, plus the requisite breadth. Mediocrity misses the first part.