Hacker News Reader

Do the true/ false gods know how the random god would answer? I don't see how they could since only he know the randomness. But if they don't know, they would have no way to answer the question, "what would guy x say ja meant" where x happens to be the random one.

View on HN

This is a question of implementation, and answering it was part of the reason why I implemented this problem in the form of a computer program in the first place. In this implementation, the True and False gods simply pose the question to Random and take Random's answer - which is random. If you then ask the same question of Random again, of course you may not get the same answer.

True and False give random responses if you ask them how random would answer, unless you include clauses like "would that god definitely say X"

Reply on news.ycombinator.com