Hacker News Reader

Comment by woah | Hacker News Reader

The native uibutton is made of uiviews too

I don't even see a button class in React Native... but if there was one and it was custom-made from UIViews, it's going to look and act differently than a native button. Turn on accessibility features -- does the button's title get read aloud? If you turn on button highlighting, does the button get an outline? If you turn on bold text or large text, does the text of the button change?

I've spent 15 minutes with React Native so far, and as best I can figure, the answer is no.

If they were building the GUI components from UIKit pieces, they'd get all of this for free. But I understand it would be pretty hard to get all this working with the flexible layout architecture they have... so I'm guessing they'll have to slow add all the accessibility features in over time.

Absolutely. My primary concern is with the controls feeling native. Reimplementing controls with UIViews doesn't seem much better than reimplementing them with HTML/CSS (save for performance). There's still surface area to break the illusion.

Some food for thought: what if you kept HTML and CSS but instead of using a WebView to render it, you rendered the DOM manually using UIViews? You could even make overflow: scroll; turn into UIScrollViews automatically.

If you write JSX. What would be the benefit of using html anymore? Your own components can be the same on web or native. The base components might be a bit different but that isn't difficult to learn.

On the web you might use a div with overflow:scroll on native a scrollView.

One of the big pieces in React Native was reimplementing flexbox positioning (they did it using randomly generated test cases in a TDD-based process; described in the "diving deeper" video iirc). So as long as you use flexbox to position your html, it should be pretty portable to react native.

I mean... if you're talking about the entire HTML and CSS spec, then it'd be way, way, way ridiculously slower than just using a WebView.

>Reimplementing controls with UIViews

If it's using UIViews, it isn't reimplementing native controls. It's using native controls, same as if it was implemented with (interface builder) .nib files. That's like saying "reimplementing html/css with html/css".

It may be a "native control" but if you reimplement UIBUtton and have to recreate what Apple did to create it in the first place, that's where things tend to fall apart.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com