You're judging a product now. I'm telling you to judge it in a few years when it is more convincing, more subtle, etc. People already "fall in love" online with people they've never met, partly because someone showed some interest in them. Many are scammed easily online because their greed has them look past telltale signs.
You've just interacted with me on some level, but what's to say I exist? Pretend I only have social network profiles online for you to background check. Those would be easy to dynamically and convincingly generate.
And don't just imagine your reaction, but the reaction of multitudes of people who aren't skeptical about religion, about crystal healing, who are superstitious, who watch whatever is put in front of them, etc.
I bet someone could scan my body of online work and design an array of profiles that might pique my interest.