Hacker News Reader

HNHacker News

Top New Best Ask Show Jobs

Comment by VieElm | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

VieElm·

Pretty terrible that such a thing is even allowed by Windows. This is why as a user I like Apple's OS X sandbox.

View on HN

Similar things have happened on OS X: http://apple.slashdot.org/story/01/11/04/0412209/itunes-20-i...

Parent said "This is why as a user I like Apple's OS X sandbox.".

This is a bug from 15 years ago, much much before the sandbox feature was introduced.

A sandboxed iTunes would have prevented that.

A sandboxed iTunes would also prevent syncing your iPod and importing existing music collections, because those both require access to files outside the sandbox, which is probably why Apple hasn't done that.

Programs can read files outside their sandbox if they're asked to by user input[1]. Sandboxing does not prevent interaction with USB devices

[1] See "Powerbox and File System Access Outside of Your Container" at https://developer.apple.com/library/mac/documentation/Securi...

That doesn't mean iTunes can't work in a sandbox, it'd just need to request specific permissions.

A sandbox isn't a totally isolated prison. It's a permissions system. Programs can read specific files and folders outside the sandbox and can even ask the user add new files/folders to their whitelist.

If a software needs/has root rights, then all bets are off. This is true on any OS.

Windows 8 introduced a sandbox and users hated it. (Probably because it also forced digital signatures but hey, specifics)

About a year ago or so I tried to fix a computer of an OS X user where the Dropbox installer somehow deleted the home directory and replaced it with the dropbox application... That was an odd experience (and one where sandbox didn't help...)

Reply on news.ycombinator.com