Hacker News Reader

Comment by tosh | Hacker News Reader

Exciting to see Erik Meijer (Haskell, C#, Hack, LINQ, Rx) as co-author of this article.

I've been addicted to Rx since I started using ReactiveCocoa in my iOS applications. I was disappointed looking at Dart initially when I saw it was heavily future based and not observable/signal based.

I haven't looked at Dart in awhile but I hope this means Rx style composability/async/error handling is in Dart's future.

You might like `frappe` https://github.com/danschultz/frappe a bacon.js inspired library for Dart.

Could you explain what you're missing from Rx that isn't already supported by Dart's core library. For example in Dart Iterables and Streams already have: where, skip, take, map, fold, reduce, expand (which is flatMap or mapcat), as well as a few others.

https://api.dartlang.org/apidocs/channels/be/dartdoc-viewer/...

https://rx.codeplex.com/

To me the only thing that's missing is a Property object - a Stream with a current value. I've ended up implementing it a few times already.

Dart's Stream class is missing many of the composition, transformation and termination methods that you'd find in other FRP libraries. It's also lacking a concept of time-varying values, which to me are important for holding and responding to state changes.

Having functions like flatMapLatest, flatMap, combine, merge, scan, and takeUntil are pretty much essential to building any RX heavy application.

There are some packages out there that extend Dart's streams to add this behavior. One of which I'm the author of, Frappe. Of course, it'd be nice if Dart included this stuff out of the box.

https://github.com/danschultz/frappe

I thought Stream.expand(f) is flatMap.

i.e. From docs: "Creates a new stream from this stream that converts each element into zero or more events."

Stream.takeWhile(f) is takeUntil with the return value of the f argument negated.

But sure, you can always add more features to a core library, the difficult decision is when to stop, and leave the rest to libraries.

Note that Erik Meijer was also one of the guys behind LINQ and adding generators to CLR languages when he was at Microsoft.

Agreed. I took his edX functional programming class mostly Haskell) and it was great fun.

> I took his edX functional programming class mostly Haskell)

Missing a ( there.

He said he learned Haskell, not Scheme :)

Reply on news.ycombinator.com